What's Buzzing:

The Eh Game

In the wake of a fencing controversy, Shin A-lam bounces back to win an Olympic medal

Andrew Bucholtz
Eh Game

View photo


Shin A-lam (second from right) and her South Korean teammates earned silver in team épée.

These Olympics started in horrible fashion for South Korean fencer Shin A-lam, who bizarrely lost an épée semifinal over a timing controversy, had to stay on the piste for an hour to protest, lost the following bronze-medal match and turned down the special consolation medal she was offered.

Shin's Olympics ended in fantastic style, though, as she was crucial in South Korea's run to the silver medal in team épée Saturday, winning seven of her nine matches overall (an appropriately dominant number). It may have taken an extra five days, but Shin finally has her medal.

[Slideshow: Up close and personal with Olympic athletes]

Of course, this came after it became more and more clear that Shin really deserved to advance to the final in the individual event. Fencing's governing body, the Fédération Internationale d'Escrime, announced Friday that the problem came from the timekeeper incorrectly starting the clock too quickly at one point, causing a reset that bumped it back too far:

During extra-time there were a total of four double hits, and the bout continued until the clock showed 00:01. At this stage there were two more double attacks, at the end of which the clock still showed 00:01," the FIE's statement said.

"Unfortunately during the pause in the fight, the clock was re-started in error which took the time down to 00:00," it said.

[Related: Canada's Zach Bell left looking for answers]

Bizarrely, that timekeeper was apparently a 15-year-old Games volunteer. It's rather unbelievable that an Olympic medal could be lost because of a teenage volunteer and a bad timing system, but that's apparently what happened. At least Shin's medal-winning performance in the team épée means that she won't be leaving with only bad memories of these Games.

It was an amazing, unexpected medal for South Korea, too. The South Koreans were ranked 10th heading into the team épée and faced top-seeded Romania in the quarterfinals, but knocked them off 45-38 and then beat the fifth-seeded Americans (who would claim bronze) 45-36 in the semifinals. Shin was crucial to both victories, winning all six of her matches in those two contests.

[More: A fitting finale for Michael Phelps]

This was just the latest fencing triumph for South Korea, which had never claimed more than three medals in fencing events in a single Olympics, but picked up their sixth of these Games thanks to the efforts of Shin and her team. They would have had a seventh if Shin's individual event hadn't run into the timing controversy, but this is still remarkable, and it's a great ending to what was looking like a very sad story. However, fencing really does need to get its house in order before the next Games so that what initially happened in Shin's match is never repeated.

More London Olympics coverage on Yahoo! Canada Sports:
Guide: What to watch Sunday, August 5
Photos: Track and field fashion statements
Want to row for Canada in the next Olympics?
Video: Rosie MacLennan takes home Canada's first gold of London 2012

Sign up for Yahoo Fantasy Hockey
Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.
    • McIlroy's caddie cashes in on FedEx Cup

      McIlroy's caddie cashes in on FedEx Cup

      Rory McIlroy didn't have to check his bank account to know that his FedEx Cup bonus had been deposited. ''I think his words were, 'A tsunami just hit my bank account, so thank you very much,''' McIlroy said Wednesday on the eve of the HSBC … More »

      AP - Sports - 5 minutes ago
    • Life in Manchester 'bit of a disaster', says Mourinho

      Life in Manchester 'bit of a disaster', says Mourinho

      (Reuters) - Manchester United manager Jose Mourinho has said he has struggled to adapt to life in Manchester, labelling his living arrangement in the city as "bit of a disaster". The Portuguese has endured a mixed start to his stint as United boss, … More »

      Reuters - 12 minutes ago
    • England include six uncapped players for autumn series

      England include six uncapped players for autumn series

      LONDON (Reuters) - Coach Eddie Jones has named six uncapped players in England's 33-man squad for the autumn internationals against South Africa, Fiji, Argentina and Australia. Harlequins prop Kyle Sinckler, Wasps flanker Nathan Hughes and Bath's … More »

      Reuters - 14 minutes ago
    • Oxlade-Chamberlain close to sealing starting spot, says Wenger

      Oxlade-Chamberlain close to sealing starting spot, says Wenger

      (Reuters) - Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain is close to a regular starting role for Arsenal, manager Arsene Wenger said after the winger scored twice in the side's fourth round League Cup win over second tier side Reading on Tuesday. Oxlade-Chamberlain … More »

      Reuters - 21 minutes ago
    • Kluber, 2 Perez HRs get Indians by Cubs

      Kluber, 2 Perez HRs get Indians by Cubs

      Corey Kluber and the Cleveland Indians are off to a pitch-perfect start in the World Series. The Chicago Cubs, meanwhile, fell completely flat in their first appearance since 1945. Kluber dominated into the seventh inning, Roberto Perez had four … More »

      AP - Sports - 50 minutes ago