Arsenal’s Interest in Mateo Retegui: A Rising Star or Risky Move?

Arsenal’s pursuit of Atalanta’s Mateo Retegui has sparked considerable debate within football circles. According to CalcioMercato, the 25-year-old striker’s meteoric rise this season has caught the attention of multiple elite clubs, including the Gunners. Retegui, purchased by Atalanta for €22 million just three months ago, now carries an eye-watering valuation of €45 million. Let’s explore what makes Retegui such a sought-after prospect and whether Arsenal should take the plunge.

Retegui’s Stunning Serie A Start

Retegui has been a revelation in Serie A, netting 12 goals in 13 appearances this season—a phenomenal strike rate that averages a goal every 69 minutes. Such efficiency in front of goal is rare, making him a prized asset for Atalanta. Gasperini’s faith in Retegui has been rewarded as the striker has established himself as one of the league’s most consistent performers.

However, Retegui’s form in Europe tells a different story. Despite his domestic dominance, he has yet to score in the Champions League this season. Reflecting on this, Retegui stated:

“First goal in Europe? Let’s hope it comes tonight … I’m calm, it’s a team effort, we’re doing very well both in Italy and in Europe and we have to continue like this, continuing to play this football.”

Such remarks display maturity and patience, qualities any top team would desire in a striker. Nevertheless, his European drought might be a cause for concern for potential suitors like Arsenal, who would expect him to deliver on football’s grandest stages.

Arsenal’s Growing Interest

Reports suggest Arsenal’s scouting team has been closely monitoring Retegui’s performances throughout the season. His profile as an “old-school striker” offers a distinct contrast to Arsenal’s current attacking options. Mikel Arteta’s side, while tactically fluid, has lacked a consistent out-and-out goalscorer this term. Retegui could address this gap and provide a focal point in attack.

According to CalcioMercato, Arsenal’s interest in Retegui intensified after their 0-0 draw against Atalanta in the Champions League. That game also highlighted Retegui’s character—despite missing a crucial penalty, he remained a threat and displayed resilience. Such mental toughness is invaluable in the Premier League.

Atalanta, however, is unlikely to let their star striker leave without a hefty fee. With Retegui’s valuation already doubled in a matter of months, Arsenal would need to break the bank to secure his services.

Is Retegui Worth the Price Tag?

While Retegui’s Serie A numbers are undeniably impressive, there are valid questions about his ability to replicate this form in the Premier League. The physicality and pace of English football present challenges that not all Serie A stars adapt to successfully. Furthermore, his lack of Champions League goals raises doubts about his readiness for top-level football outside of Italy.

Still, Retegui offers attributes Arsenal may find irresistible. His knack for scoring, composure under pressure, and aerial ability could bring a new dimension to Arteta’s attack. But at €45 million, the Gunners would be paying for potential as much as proven quality.

Our View – EPL Index Analysis

From an Arsenal fan’s perspective, the pursuit of Mateo Retegui evokes mixed feelings. On one hand, his goal-scoring record in Serie A is tantalising, especially when contrasted with Arsenal’s struggles to convert chances. His signing could be the answer to the club’s long-standing need for a prolific striker.

However, scepticism abounds. Is Retegui a one-season wonder? Serie A has seen its share of strikers who dominated domestically but faltered elsewhere. The likes of Ciro Immobile and Andrea Belotti come to mind—phenomenal in Italy but unable to replicate their form abroad. Arsenal cannot afford to spend heavily on a player who might not adapt to the Premier League.

Moreover, the timing feels questionable. Spending €45 million on a player with no Champions League goals this season and minimal international experience seems risky. For that price, Arsenal might find better value elsewhere, especially with strikers like Dusan Vlahovic or Lautaro Martínez potentially available.

Ultimately, Retegui represents both opportunity and risk. Whether Arsenal decides to gamble on him may depend on their desperation for a striker and their faith in his ability to translate Serie A success into Premier League dominance.