Orioles manager Brandon Hyde explains decision to pitch to Royals’ Bobby Witt Jr.
First baseman Vinnie Pasquantino wowed the baseball world by returning to the Royals lineup Tuesday, less than five weeks after his thumb was broken in a game.
Pasquantino didn’t have an opportunity for a rehabilitation stint in the minors before he served as designated hitter in Game 1 of the Royals’ Wild Card Series against the Orioles in Baltimore.
That became a point of emphasis for Orioles fans following the Royals’ 1-0 victory.
With the Royals’ Maikel Garcia on third base and two outs of a scoreless game in the sixth inning, Bobby Witt Jr. came to the plate. Witt won baseball’s batting title this season and is in the running to be the American League’s Most Valuable Player.
The Orioles were faced with a choice: Pitch to Witt or intentionally walk him and face Pasquantino, who hadn’t played in a game a month. Baltimore chose the former and paid the price. Witt singled off starter Corbin Burnes and Garcia scored the game’s only run.
Hyde explained the decision to face Witt.
“I’m letting Corbin Burnes, the way he’s throwing the baseball right there, determine who he wants to go get,” Hyde said.
Royals manager Matt Quatraro wasn’t surprised by the decision to pitch to Witt.
“That guy was incredible today,” Quatraro said of Burnes. “He’s got incredible stuff. He locates, you know, that’s your best pitcher and our best hitter. That’s why you play this game right? But, I would’ve been more surprised if he walked.”
Orioles fans unhappy
Some Baltimore fans unloaded on manager Brandon Hyde following the game for pitching to Witt.
Here is what they were saying on X.
You 100% pitch around him. Just like you pinch hit for McCann in his second AB.
— Colin Donohue (@cmdonohue) October 1, 2024
Everyone but Hyde knew better to walk Witt
— Brian Mazan (@brimaz13) October 1, 2024
Brandon Hyde is the dumbest manager in baseball. Yeah let’s pitch to Witt who led the league in BA and not try and face a dude who’s been out injured for 6 weeks. Guy should be fired today. Enough is enough with this clown #Birdland
— Brandon Filler (@Filler8) October 1, 2024
Couldn’t have asked for a better situation to bunt than that. Then you follow it up by letting Bobby Witt hit with RISP. That’s the stuff you can’t do in playoff games. Cmon Hyde
— Tyler (@TylerShadle) October 1, 2024
I’d love to hear Hyde’s answer on why they didn’t have McCann bunt Mullins over or why they pitched to a red-hot Witt instead of a guy coming off a hand injury
— Dan Reiner (@DanReiner114) October 1, 2024
What’s upsetting was that Hyde didn’t intentionally walk Witt jr.
— surfing yorkie (@surfingyorkie) October 1, 2024
Hyde not bunting McCann costed the orioles a run
Hyde letting Bobby Witt beat them and not putting him on with an open base and pitching to the guy fresh off the IL costed the orioles another
Should’ve been 1-0 orioles
This is why the team will never win anything— austin koehn (@austin_koehn) October 1, 2024
@Orioles Brandon Hyde mistakes today:
Not bunting McCann
Urias not scoring on the single by Mullins
Not bunting McCann again
Not walking Witt with two outs and a runner on third.
Hyde is ABSOLUTELY the biggest problem.— SportsFan35 (@brando2734) October 1, 2024
So stupid I will never understand how Hyde seems so content with letting the other teams best player beat us even if it’s the MVP or the runner up like Witt.
— Russell hawk (@adoeofj292) October 1, 2024
This story includes reporting by The Star’s Jaylon Thompson