No Isak, no goals: Arsenal’s need for a top striker evident in Newcastle defeat

Arsenal’s League Cup semi-final defeat to Newcastle United felt like more than just a stumble – it exposed a recurring problem at the Emirates Stadium.

Mikel Arteta’s side dominated possession and created chances at will, finishing the game with an expected goals (xG) tally of 3.76.

However, the scoreline read 2-0 in favour of Newcastle. Arsenal’s 23 shots yielded only three on target, and none of them tested Martin Dubravka enough. It was an all-too-familiar tale of profligacy.

Alexander Isak, a long-standing Arsenal transfer target, showcased the qualities Arsenal desperately need.

His opener, a clinical finish after Jacob Murphy’s inadvertent assist, highlighted his poise in the box.

He was equally instrumental in the second goal, forcing David Raya into a save that Anthony Gordon capitalised on.

With 50 goals for Newcastle since August 2022, Isak has proven his worth, and performances like these only amplify Arsenal fans’ clamour for investment in a striker.

Arteta acknowledged the difference Isak made. “That’s what happens when you have real quality up front,” he said. “They can make the difference and are very clinical.”

By contrast, Arsenal’s attacking trio of Gabriel Martinelli, Kai Havertz and Leandro Trossard repeatedly fluffed their lines.

Martinelli hit the post when through on goal, Havertz failed to convert a point-blank chance, and a catalogue of blocked or scuffed efforts summed up Arsenal’s inefficiency.

Arteta refused to blame luck, instead urging his players to improve their finishing. However, he also lamented the unique flight of the League Cup ball, which he suggested contributed to several wayward attempts.

“The ball flies a lot,” he remarked, although no one would see that as a valid excuse for such wastefulness.

The result leaves Newcastle in a commanding position heading into the second leg at St James’ Park.

Arsenal’s task is monumental – not just overcoming a two-goal deficit but addressing the psychological toll of missed opportunities.

Arteta remained defiant, insisting: “It’s just half-time – we can go up there and win.”

The evidence is mounting that Arsenal need more than belief – they need a striker capable of seizing such decisive moments.

Watching Isak thrive in a role Arsenal have struggled to fill must have been a bitter pill to swallow.