Jesperi Kotkaniemi offer-sheet drama is amazing for the NHL
We don't yet know if Montreal Canadiens GM Marc Bergevin is going to match the offer sheet the Carolina Hurricanes tendered to Jesperi Kotkaniemi. We do, however, know that this whole thing is entertaining as hell.
Canadiens fans, Hurricanes supporters, and the hockey world at large lost their collective minds over the news of the one-year, $6.1-million offer sheet given to the 21-year-old. This story stole headlines over the weekend both because of how rare offer sheet-related drama is in the NHL (a shame, really) and because of how equally rare any non-criminal or non-controversial off-ice stories are in this league — especially in the offseason and compared to other major, drama-filled leagues like the NFL, NBA, UFC and European soccer.
So few exciting and interesting things actually happen in the NHL, especially in late August, that something as seemingly trivial and ordinary as an offer sheet and a rift between two intra-conference clubs has just absolutely gobbled up headlines and consumed the attention of fans and media types over the past couple days.
Scarcity of NHL storylines aside, however, this saga has some real legs to it and is an intriguing and pretty hilarious bit of drama to save us from the usual boring junk floating around the hockey sphere in the dog days of summer.
Let's dissect this wonderful and petty front-office war a bit, shall we?
History behind the offer and outrage
This glorious little off-ice rivalry really took hold in the offseason of 2019. On July 1, the opening day of NHL free agency, Bergevin went scorched earth with a seemingly out-of-nowhere offer sheet to star RFA center Sebastian Aho worth $42.27 million over five-years — including the maximum amount of signing bonus allowable.
That last caveat is a big one, as Aho was reportedly owed over $21 million in cold hard cash in the first calendar year of the contract, testing the Hurricanes' finances and forcing owner Tom Dundon and his stingy reputation to really stress his bank account in order to keep his star, top-line center on his roster.
From a contract structure standpoint, the deal ended up sort of working out for Carolina, as Aho would have likely either been in line for a larger payday in terms of both AAV and term fairly soon, or would have walked for greener financial pastures in free agency similar to the way star blueliner Dougie Hamilton did this offseason. However, the offer also walks Aho right to his first year of unrestricted free agency, which often leads to that player leaving or becoming unaffordable after sparking a bidding war.
But that assault on Dundon's wallet and ego clearly didn't sit well with the dude, and is the main (or only) reason the Canes tendered such a strange, overpay-ish type of offer for revenge on the Canadiens for their attempt at stealing Aho — according to a fair chunk of Habs fans (and most rational hockey followers) at least.
Waddell clearly isn’t the one who did this. Dundon is, and he is very pissy over having to pay a whole lot of money to Aho. The guy loves money and doesn’t like to spend it.
— Joshua (@JoshuaMacIsaac) August 29, 2021
Suspect it's owner driven, as habs sheet made him eat signing bonus$
— NuToronto (@auldtoronto) August 29, 2021
Is it not pretty obvious that the answer is Waddell’s boss Tom Dundon is the one that is pissed and not Waddell? Dundon is pissed over the structure of the deal.
— Drew Way (@Drews_Way) August 29, 2021
Contract would pay Kotkaniemi $6.1 million this season and comes with a $20 signing bonus.
Comes two years after Canadiens offer sheet’d Hurricanes’ Sebastian Aho.
Aho wears No. 20 for Carolina. https://t.co/ZC5TOqcSr2— Adam Kimelman (@NHLAdamK) August 28, 2021
Hurricanes did try to trade for Kotkaniemi instead over the past several days but nothing that came close to making the Habs interested. So Dundon gets his offer sheet revenge.
Anyway, enjoy the fun everyone. https://t.co/kZRTedDaSx— Pierre LeBrun (@PierreVLeBrun) August 28, 2021
Many are thinking and reacting rationally, and some are unsurprisingly a little more bitter than others, to put it mildly.
BS move from Waddell getting even with Bergevin. But KK isn't worth $6 million at this point in his career.
— Jack Todd (@jacktodd46) August 28, 2021
My column on the franchise that embarrassed the game of hockey. And no, this time it was not the Habs.https://t.co/Pz9CK6ytzP
— Jack Todd (@jacktodd46) August 29, 2021
It's possible to foresee the day when Tom Dundon gives Eugene Melnyk some real competition for NHL's worst owner.
— Jack Todd (@jacktodd46) August 29, 2021
Tonight is brought to you by the folks who want you to know that the NHL is run by owners and GMs who have not matured since the fifth grade - and who still believe that it's all about how far you can stand from the urinal when you pee.
— Jack Todd (@jacktodd46) August 29, 2021
Canes stir the pot, rub some salt
Just like a large chunk of Hockey Twitter did following the news of the shocking offer, the Hurricanes' account took its own opportunity to dunk on Montreal-based sportswriter Jack Todd for his very online meltdown over the ordeal, sharing his Gazette article along with a little parting shot.
Guess we made a splash https://t.co/S7njsjvCPg pic.twitter.com/QN153sieyn
— Carolina Hurricanes (@Canes) August 30, 2021
The team's social accounts were in full-out troll mode all damn day, announcing the offer sheet on Twitter, in French, like Bergevin did a couple years ago with the Aho move.
Les Hurricanes ont annoncé aujourd’hui avoir déposé une offre hostile au joueur autonome avec restriction Jesperi Kotkaniemi des Canadiens de la Montreal. L’entente proposée est d’une durée de un ans et d’une valeur annuelle moyenne de 6,1 millions $.
— Carolina Hurricanes (@Canes) August 28, 2021
And they just kept 'em coming. It was an onslaught:
— Carolina Hurricanes (@Canes) August 28, 2021
Always Relevant.
Gear Up » https://t.co/Awi87sHBKo pic.twitter.com/JBuiIY6Tbl— Carolina Pro Shop (@CarolinaProShop) August 28, 2021
— Carolina Hurricanes (@Canes) August 29, 2021
— Carolina Hurricanes (@Canes) August 28, 2021
And they finished off their big revenge meal with a couple servings of medium-well Troll D'Aho:
People don’t forget pic.twitter.com/n6ujojWVwk
— Carolina Hurricanes (@Canes) August 28, 2021
Night, y’all pic.twitter.com/8ZDBZsM7eF
— Carolina Hurricanes (@Canes) August 29, 2021
Blessing in disguise for Canadiens?
As aggressively and gleefully as the Hurricanes owner, the team's front office and its social teams went at the Canadiens and their fan base, it might not end up being all bad for the Habs — despite the optics and potential disaster scenario of losing the 2018 third overall pick a year or two before he really develops into an all-world player.
This could go a little sideways for Carolina and work out not too badly for Montreal, as many fans flocked to Twitter to point out.
Is the 'Canes GM an idiot? Or do they think the Canadiens have to match so they're driving up the price. It's only 1 year, so they aren't stuck long term, but a 1st and a 3rd see gone.
— MB (@Bloomy999) August 28, 2021
Waddell is shooting himself in the foot if the Habs don't match. Possible lottery pick.
— Monctonscout (@Monctonscout) August 29, 2021
Montreal is in a lose-lose with this Kotkaniemi offer sheet, but its best option might be a trade. If I'm the Canadiens, I'm taking the next week to see if I can package the 1st and 3rd in a deal for Eichel, Tarasenko, Kuznetsov or Dvorak. #GoHabsGo
— Michael Amato (@amato_mike) August 29, 2021
The case, of course, can be made both ways, though.
Don't let the extraordinary pettiness surrounding the Kotkaniemi offer sheet distract you from what's actually a shrewd hockey move to poach a talented young player from a team in dire salary-cap straits.https://t.co/2qESlfFfj6
— Luke DeCock (@LukeDeCock) August 30, 2021
New for @Sportsnet:
The petty factor is fun, but Carolina's not spending millions for pure spite. Why the Kotkaniemi offer sheet makes sense for the Canes:https://t.co/zslxQEEtdN— Justin Bourne (@jtbourne) August 30, 2021
Twitter: "#Habs can't draft."
Also Twitter: "TAKE THE PICKS!"— Andrew Zadarnowski (@AZadarski) August 30, 2021
We need way more of this sweet, sweet pettiness in this far-too-serious sport.
More from Yahoo Sports