NFL Winners and Losers: What would it take for the Browns to finally bench Deshaun Watson?

The Washington Commanders are doing a lot of things well this season, but playing defense hasn't been one of them. The Commanders were near the bottom of the NFL in most defensive categories through four weeks: 25th in points allowed, 26th in yards allowed, 30th in defensive DVOA, 31st in yards per play allowed and 32nd in EPA allowed per play.

And Deshaun Watson couldn't do anything against that defense.

When the Commanders took a 24-3 lead late in the second quarter, Watson's line against one of the worst defenses in the NFL was 6 of 14 for 37 yards. And it looked even worse than that.

You'd think that at some point the Cleveland Browns would give up the idea that it's smarter to cater to the feelings of a quarterback who has sunk their franchise than actually trying to win games, but it hasn't happened yet. The Browns fell to 1-4 with an uncompetitive 34-13 loss to the Commanders. It's worth wondering how bad Watson would have to be for the Browns to finally consider a quarterback change. Watson, who was taken out very late with the game completely out of reach, finished with 125 passing yards against one of the NFL's worst defenses.

Watson is one of the NFL's worst starting quarterbacks and has been for a while. It's almost unheard of for a quarterback to be as good as Watson was with the Houston Texans and then become one of the NFL's worst by the age of 30, but it has happened. And Browns head coach Kevin Stefanski refuses to acknowledge it.

The Browns have become an assembly line of excuses for Watson, trying to protect the quarterback from any criticism. And yes, the Browns have issues like offensive line injuries, but when a QB makes $230 million he has to overcome some obstacles. He can't play like one of the worst starters in the NFL week after week and expect to keep his job, unless he plays for the Browns it seems.

Don't worry, they'll have an excuse for his poor play this week, too. Watson hasn't been held accountable for his play up to this point, so why start now?

Stefanski said after the game that Watson is still his quarterback. That shouldn't be a surprise based on how the Browns have coddled Watson, but it still has to be disheartening for Browns fans and probably Browns players too.

The Browns' only hope to make Sunday's game competitive came early in the third quarter. They recovered a fumble deep in Washington territory. Then Watson was sacked, threw incomplete on second down, threw it away on third down, the Browns took a delay of game after that and sent on the field-goal team for a mostly useless three points. The old saying is quarterbacks make their money near the goal line and on third downs, and Watson did neither. Cleveland went 0-for-12 on third downs when he was in the game. Apparently $230 million doesn't get you what it used to.

After the failure near the goal line, the Commanders took a 31-6 lead and the Browns still refused to try another quarterback. Then Watson held the ball too long, was hit from behind and a loose ball was intercepted. And still there was no QB change. Watson might be one of the worst quarterbacks in the NFL but he might be among the league leaders in job security.

It's long past time for the Browns to throw in the towel and admit defeat on Watson. They made arguably the worst trade in NFL history and compounded that by giving Watson arguably the worst contract, from a team's standpoint, in NFL history. It's hard to feel sympathetic for the team, since it was aware of Watson's off-field issues and figured it would blow over after a little bit of criticism. The Browns turned themselves into the most unlikeable team in the NFL and continue to dig a deeper hole by acting like Watson is still a viable option and the offense's issues are everyone else's fault.

Here are the rest of the winners and losers from Week 5 of the NFL season:

WINNERS

Defensive Player of the Year candidate Patrick Surtain II: T.J. Watt has been good, Xavier McKinney has been a great addition for the Packers, but at some point Surtain is going to get his rightful attention as the best defensive player in the NFL so far this season.

Surtain has been shutting down opposing receivers and on Sunday he got a couple of interceptions. His 100-yard interception return for a touchdown gave the Broncos some much needed momentum and they cruised after that to a 34-18 win over the Las Vegas Raiders. It was Denver’s first win over the Raiders since 2019.

Surtain has been one of the NFL’s best cornerbacks for a while, and he seems to be hitting his peak this season. After Sunday, more people will start to take notice of the year he’s having.

Green Bay Packers: The season didn't start as the Packers wanted it to.

They lost to the Philadelphia Eagles in Brazil to open the season and near the end of the game Jordan Love injured his knee. It seemed Green Bay could be in some trouble.

They're not where they'd like to be yet, but we can see the seeds of a very good team.

The Packers overcame a terrible pick-6 from Love and held on at the end to beat the Los Angeles Rams 24-19. The Packers gifted the Rams six points and still win on the road is a good sign.

Love played well other than a pick-6 in which he flipped it wildly before he hit the ground for a safety. He threw for 224 yards and two touchdowns. Tight end Tucker Kraft continues to emerge as another weapon; he caught both of Love's touchdowns on Sunday. The Packers still need the rest of the NFC North to stop winning just about every week, but they should be back on track after Sunday's road win.

Jesse Luketa: Luketa isn’t a household name around the NFL, but he might have saved the Arizona Cardinals’ season.

Luketa, a third-year linebacker playing in his first game of this season, had a massive forced fumble against the San Francisco 49ers. With the Cardinals trailing 23-21 in the fourth quarter and the 49ers inside the 10-yard line, Luketa had a great punch out on 49ers running back Jordan Mason, knocking the ball loose. The Cardinals recovered, went on a long drive after that and kicked the go-ahead field goal with less than two minutes remaining. Instead of going to 1-4 with a loss, the Cardinals are 2-3 after the 24-23 win.

The 49ers are 2-3 after the loss, and that’s the bigger story around the NFL. But thanks to a huge playby a former seventh-round pick at linebacker, the Cardinals should feel their season is still alive.

Game of the year?: It's barely October, but the Baltimore Ravens' game against the Cincinnati Bengals will be tough to top this season.

Joe Burrow and Lamar Jackson were both incredible, combining for more than 700 yards passing and nine touchdowns, and a key AFC North game went to overtime on Justin Tucker's late field goal. In overtime, the Ravens seemingly gave the game away on a fumbled shotgun snap that was recovered by Cincinnati. But a bad hold on Evan McPherson's game-winning field goal try led to a miss. Derrick Henry, who is having a huge positive impact for the Ravens in his first season with the team, had a long run downfield and Tucker won it with a field goal. The Ravens had a 41-38 win.

The Bengals needed a win badly after a 1-3 start. But they blew a fourth-quarter lead and a field-goal snap and are down to 1-4. The Ravens are 3-2 after an exhilarating win. There won't be many more games this season as exciting as that Ravens' win.

Jaguars offense, finally: When the Indianapolis Colts, who didn't have Anthony Richardson, Jonathan Taylor or DeForest Buckner on Sunday, took a 7-0 lead, it seemed like Jacksonville might not make it to London next week with its coaching staff intact.

But the Jaguars snapped out of it, at least on offense. Trevor Lawrence had his best game of the season, first-round draft pick Brian Thomas Jr. and Tank Bigsby had long touchdowns and the Jaguars finally got their first win of the season, beating the Colts. The Colts tied it in the fourth quarter but the Jaguars responded with a long drive and a field goal with 17 seconds left. They won 37-34.

That win doesn't mean the Jaguars are going to get on a winning streak. Indianapolis' defense is bad and the biggest reason for the Jaguars' offensive output. Jacksonville's defense got shredded by Joe Flacco and Trey Sermon. But a loss would have been inexcusable, and at least Jacksonville avoided that.

LOSERS

Seattle Seahawks: The San Francisco 49ers are struggling. And the Seahawks aren’t taking advantage.

Seattle suffered a brutal loss on Sunday, dropping a game to a shorthanded New York Giants team. When Seattle had a chance to tie the game with less than two minutes to go, Giants linebacker Isaiah Simmons leaped over the line and blocked a field goal, which was returned for a touchdown. The Giants got a 29-20 win, which was especially surprising to the 40.3% of Yahoo Survival Football players who picked Seattle to win on Sunday.

Seattle’s legitimacy was questioned during its 3-0 start because it hadn’t beat anyone of note. The Giants were another beatable opponent. But Seattle, which fell to 3-2, took a loss it will regret for a while.

Sean McDermott: It'll be a long, long week for the Buffalo Bills and their head coach.

The Bills seemed to have sent Sunday's game to overtime, coming back from a 20-3 deficit and forcing a punt after a C.J. Stroud intentional grounding penalty. The Texans' punt was downed at the Buffalo 3-yard line with 32 seconds left.

What happened next was inexplicable. Instead of running and likely taking the game to overtime, the Bills threw the ball incomplete three times. Buffalo had to punt. The Texans completed a short pass and because they had all their timeouts left — that was a reason Buffalo was passing, but not a good one — they called a timeout and Ka'imi Fairbairn hit a 59-yard field goal as time expired for a 23-20 Texans win.

The Texans probably shouldn't have had that chance at the end of the game, but they did thanks to the Bills being aggressive from their own 3. After such a great comeback to tie it, that's a deflating loss.

Viewers of Dolphins-Patriots: If you watched the Miami Dolphins-New England Patriots game in its entirety, you should be commended. That wasn't easy to sit through.

The Patriots and Dolphins might be the two most unwatchable teams in the NFL. The Patriots were expected to be one of the NFL's worst teams coming into the season. The Dolphins got there after Tua Tagovailoa's concussion. It ended fittingly, with the Patriots completing a pass downfield but short of the end zone, and time ran out after Hunter Henry was tackled in bounds. The Dolphins won 15-10.

The Dolphins did just about everything to give Sunday's game away. They had a punt blocked. They had a terrible snap on a field-goal attempt and couldn't get the kick off. They lost 22 yards on a bad shotgun snap, knocking them out of field-goal range. Every sloppy play you can imagine, the Dolphins pulled it off. But Miami needed just one touchdown in the fourth quarter, then a key stop late in the game that was aided by Patriots receiver Ja'Lynn Polk's heel being just out of bounds on what looked like a touchdown catch.

The Dolphins won, but it wasn't pretty.

Carolina Panthers: How bad were the Las Vegas Raiders in Week 3?

It looked that day like the Panthers might be a viable team after a quarterback switch as they beat the Raiders. It turns out, that was just the Raiders looking bad.

The Panthers continue to be one of the NFL's worst teams no matter who their quarterback is. On Sunday they got blown out 36-10 by the Chicago Bears. Caleb Williams looked great, with 200 yards and two touchdowns in the first half, but that has more to do with the play of the Panthers' defense than anything else. Williams finished with 304 yards.

The Panthers are a lost cause this season. The offense is better with Andy Dalton replacing Bryce Young, but it's not good enough to overcome a terrible defense or win many games. At least they have that one win on the board.

Aaron Rodgers: Rodgers isn't the first quarterback whom Minnesota Vikings defensive coordinator Brian Flores has confounded this season. He won't be the last either.

But the New York Jets signed up for more than a 2-3 record with a Sunday of 4.5 yards per attempt and three interceptions in a 23-17 loss to the 5-0 Vikings. Rodgers attempted 54 passes and had just 244 yards, an interception returned for a pick-6 early and in the final minute he threw a game-clinching interception with the Jets needing a touchdown to win.

Rodgers still doesn't look like he has much cohesion with his receivers and he has missed more throws than usual. He has also been hobbling around, including during the second half Sunday after his knee got twisted underneath him. He is 40 years old, and it has shown at times.

The schedule doesn't clear up either. They host the Buffalo Bills on Monday night in Week 6, then play at the Pittsburgh Steelers. A 2-3 start could get a lot worse. There could be pressure to make major changes if the Jets go on a long losing streak. This was the Jets' all-in season with Rodgers, and they were hoping for much better.