Liverpool’s Transfer Moves: Strategic Patience or Missed Opportunities?

Liverpool’s recent transfer activity—or rather, the lack of it—has raised eyebrows among fans and pundits alike. As the club navigates the evolving landscape under new manager Arne Slot, questions are swirling about the decisions being made at Anfield. A recent article by James Pearce in The Athletic sheds light on the club’s current strategy, which seems to be one of patience and long-term planning. But is this the right approach for a club that prides itself on competing at the highest level?

Long-Term Planning with Mamardashvili

Liverpool’s interest in Valencia goalkeeper Giorgi Mamardashvili highlights a commitment to planning for the future. The 23-year-old Georgia international is valued at around €45 million, and while Liverpool have engaged in talks, any potential deal is geared towards a 2025 or 2026 arrival. This move indicates that Alisson’s position as the club’s number one is secure for now, but Liverpool is already laying the groundwork for his eventual successor.

Pearce notes that “possible loan options for Mamardashvili have been discussed,” yet Premier League rules prevent Liverpool from immediately loaning him to Bournemouth, one of the clubs interested in his services. This development suggests that Liverpool are keen on ensuring Mamardashvili gains Premier League experience before joining them, aligning with the club’s careful, methodical approach to squad building.

Midfield Reinforcements: Zubimendi and the No. 6 Dilemma

One of the most intriguing aspects of Liverpool’s transfer dealings this summer has been their pursuit—or lack thereof—of a new holding midfielder. The club’s top target, Martin Zubimendi, opted to stay at Real Sociedad, leaving Liverpool without a clear alternative. As Pearce reports, Liverpool considered Zubimendi to be a “rarity in terms of fitting the profile of what Slot wants in a No. 6.” His decision to remain in Spain has seemingly left Liverpool at a crossroads.

Slot’s comments reflect the challenge of finding the right player: “It’s not easy to find players who can help us or strengthen the squad,” he said. The reliance on Ryan Gravenberch, who impressed in the season opener, may suggest that Slot is willing to gamble on internal options rather than settling for a less-than-ideal external recruit. However, with Wataru Endo sliding down the pecking order, questions remain about whether Liverpool have sufficient depth in this crucial position.

Attacking and Defensive Options: Deals That Didn’t Happen

Liverpool’s failed attempt to sign Anthony Gordon from Newcastle, and the subsequent collapse of a deal that would have sent Joe Gomez the other way, underscores the club’s struggles in the transfer market. Pearce’s article highlights that Liverpool’s “admiration for Gordon remains strong,” but Newcastle’s decision to pull out of the deal has left Liverpool without a key attacking reinforcement.

Meanwhile, the defensive situation is also fluid, with Joel Matip’s departure creating a gap that has yet to be filled. Joe Gomez’s uncertain future further complicates matters, especially with several Premier League clubs reportedly interested in his services. As Liverpool continue to weigh their options, it’s clear that the final days of the transfer window could be critical for Slot and his team.

Our View – Anfield Index Analysis

Liverpool’s current transfer strategy feels more like hesitation than tactical patience. The long-term planning with Mamardashvili is commendable, but it does little to address immediate concerns, especially with Alisson’s occasional injury woes. Fans are rightly asking why Liverpool haven’t moved for a new number six after missing out on Zubimendi. The decision to stick with Gravenberch could backfire if he struggles against tougher opposition than Ipswich.

The collapse of the Anthony Gordon deal is another point of frustration. For a club with Liverpool’s ambitions, failing to secure a key attacking target when the need is clear feels like a missed opportunity. Gomez’s situation adds to the uncertainty, leaving fans wondering whether the club is prepared for the rigours of a long season with an ageing and injury-prone backline.

In essence, while the club’s cautious approach has its merits, there’s a growing sense that Liverpool may be falling behind in a rapidly evolving Premier League. The next few days will be telling, but as it stands, many fans are left feeling uneasy about the road ahead.