Ex-Royals star Mark Gubicza and broadcast partner unload on MLB for scoring change
First baseman Nolan Schanuel went hitless in five plate appearances Sunday in the Angels’ 12-2 loss to the Red Sox. For some, that’s the first time in Schanuel’s career that he’s failed to reach base.
Schanuel had either a hit or walk in all 29 games last season as a rookie, and he did the same in the first seven games this year. That is, until a scoring change was made Saturday.
A hit by Schanuel in the Angels’ second game of the season at Baltimore was changed to an error six days later.
For those that haven’t seen this yet, this change retroactively ends @Angels Nolan Schanuel’s on-base streak to start his career at 30 games. His walk tonight extends his current streak to five games, not 36.#RepTheHalo #Birdland https://t.co/9Hkr5QTiI9
— MLB Scoring Changes (@ScoringChanges) April 6, 2024
Former Royals pitcher Mark Gubicza, who was part of the 1985 World Series championship team, crushed MLB for allowing the scoring change. Gubicza, who is now an Angels broadcaster, made the comments before Saturday‘s game.
“I marked it in my book right away as a hit and I’m keeping it as a hit by the way,” Gubicza said. “MLB, you gotta remember when you have something like this, it’s special. It’s all over social media. Everyone’s excited about a young player like Nolan Schanuel. ... He started his career and it’s like a magical moment.
“You look at the NBA, you think they would take away an assist from LeBron James if he had a triple-double that break a record? No. You’re never gonna do that. You’re never gonna see that in the NFL. Why baseball decided on this thing at this moment is still mind-boggling.”
The guys give their thoughts on @NSchanuel streak being broken 6 days later @Angels | #RepTheHalo | #AngelsLive pic.twitter.com/5QVJ1eVh60
— Bally Sports West (@BallySportWest) April 7, 2024
Gubicza’s comments were merely an appetizer for what Angels play-by-play broadcaster Wayne Randazzo had to say during the game. Randazzo dropped the hammer on MLB.
“Negative story after negative story, scandal after scandal,” Randazzo said. “A fiasco in Oakland. You have these ridiculous-looking jerseys. You have the MLBPA challenging the league about the pitch clock today because of constant pitcher injuries. Not to mention your global superstar is embroiled in a betting scandal.
“But on top of all of that, you have a young player, trying to make a name for himself, who has come up and reached base safely in every single game that he has played. And the league allows this scoring change to go on to end his streak, kill this story, a positive story that’s happening in Major League Baseball. It is an absurdity.”
Gubicza then reiterated how other pro leagues would not have allowed a similar decision.
Angels play-by-play man Wayne Randazzo goes nuclear on MLB. ️️pic.twitter.com/D568fDsjZI
— Awful Announcing (@awfulannouncing) April 7, 2024
The X account MLB Scoring Changes had a nice breakdown of what happens when there is a scoring change.
(2) Scoring decisions get changed in a couple of ways. The simplest is the Official Scorer (OS) reviews a play after the game ends and changes it. There is a form they fill out, they submit it and it gets sent in and changed.
— MLB Scoring Changes (@ScoringChanges) April 6, 2024
(4) The other way is via appeal, which can come from the player, or the team (never an agent). This was collectively bargained for. The appeals committee is made up of former players (again, collectively bargained for).
— MLB Scoring Changes (@ScoringChanges) April 6, 2024
(6)In the past, appeals have taken anywhere from 5-14 days to get fully taken care of. I’ve noticed this year that window has closed to about 4-6 days tops, where I would think that is where MLB would prefer it (for fantasy and stats purposes).
— MLB Scoring Changes (@ScoringChanges) April 6, 2024
(7) But this isn’t an “MLB did this” (and let me stress this is an independent account), but this is what the MLBPA collectively bargained for, and I believe they would say it’s worked, since they haven’t opted to change it.
— MLB Scoring Changes (@ScoringChanges) April 6, 2024