Edinburgh 10-7 Glasgow Warriors: Your views

We asked for your thoughts on the second leg of the 1872 Cup, which saw Glasgow retain the trophy despite Edinburgh's narrow win.

Here's what some of you had to say:

Bill: Finally a bit of heart from Edinburgh but the flaws are all still there. Ali Price and Ross Thompson are not going to frighten anyone at half-back, and until that weakness is fixed, this team is going nowhere. Ben Healy isn't amazing, but that's twice in a row things have improved when he comes on, and if Sean Everitt cannot see that, he's not the right coach.

Marcus: Glasgow look well coached, coherent and always advance in attack. Edinburgh have no attacking structure it seems. Why can Edinburgh not do this with their squad? It's infuriating.

Doug: I'd class myself a rugby purist and I'm not sure that game was even one for me. Ill discipline and handling errors prevented the record crowd from getting out of their seats. As a Glasgow fan, pretty disappointed with league points left behind. Congrats to Edinburgh, deserved winners, now start playing like that every game and not once a season.

Dave: Very poor game for the 40,000 fans to watch. Glasgow definitely had an issue with the referee's interpretation of the laws and were penalized heavily.

Stair: At long last this Edinburgh team are living upbto expectations. I thought that Hamish Watson was immense. It was unfortunate that took an HIA to Ritchie to bring him onto the field. Every forward played well .It is a shame that this coach can't work out how to involve our electric three-quarter line. Never mind a win is a win. Well done.

Ben: Frustrating loss for Glasgow. Felt in the most part we were comfortable defending Edinburgh, we were just not clinical at all at the other end. Once we finally got the score, we should kick on against 14 men but gave up such a soft score which cost us. Ultimately six points and the 1872 cup is a decent return for the last two games.

Steve: It was a game for the purists and none the less for it. Great to see that both Scottish outfits have the ability to defend but given Scotland use a similar attacking approach to Glasgow that might also be cause for concern come the Six Nations. It's the least inventive I've seen Glasgow since week one of the URC.

Martin: Edinburgh won today, woohoo. It only papers over cracks. There were times today we couldn't pass the ball wide as the whole team were between the 15m lines, very narrow. If we were going to kick points why was Ben Healy not on from the start? Our attack is very blunt , still not convinced by Mosese Tuipolotu at all.

Rob: Plenty of comments on social media about how boring the game was. I think Edinburgh deserve some credit for turning it into an arm-wrestle, because that was the only chance they had to win it. Still huge problems at Edinburgh, but fair play for fronting up and shutting down Glasgow's expansive game with some organised defence.