Trent Alexander-Arnold’s Role with England: A Tactical Conundrum for Gareth Southgate

In a recent episode of the Media Matters podcast on Anfield Index, host Eddie Gibbs and guest David Lynch delved into the intricate dynamics surrounding Trent Alexander-Arnold’s role within the England squad under Gareth Southgate. This discussion highlighted several key points about Alexander-Arnold’s utilisation, or lack thereof, in the national team setup, revealing a complex interplay of tactical preferences and player capabilities.

The Experiment with Trent Alexander-Arnold

Gareth Southgate’s decision to experiment with Alexander-Arnold in midfield during the early games of the tournament has been a topic of significant debate. As David Lynch pointed out, Southgate himself referred to this as an “experiment,” one that was quickly abandoned after only a couple of matches. “He took him off in both of those games to end that experiment,” Lynch noted, underscoring the brevity and perhaps the lack of conviction behind the attempt.

This swift reversion raises questions about Southgate’s tactical vision and understanding of Alexander-Arnold’s unique skill set. Traditionally a right-back, Alexander-Arnold’s ability to influence the game from deeper positions with his exceptional crossing and passing range is well-documented. However, Lynch speculated that Southgate might have set up Alexander-Arnold for failure, particularly when he was positioned in a midfield role unfamiliar to his club duties.

Tactical Decisions and Player Confidence

One of the most contentious decisions was Southgate’s choice not to utilise Alexander-Arnold as a right wingback, a position that many, including Lynch, believe suits him perfectly in a back-three formation. Instead, Southgate opted for other players, further sidelining Alexander-Arnold.

This decision-making process not only impacts the team’s tactical flexibility but also potentially affects player morale and confidence. Lynch emphasized that Alexander-Arnold must compartmentalize these experiences, recognizing that Southgate’s lack of trust in his abilities is a temporary hurdle. “The likelihood is win or lose this tournament; whatever England do, Southgate will be gone at the end of it,” Lynch suggested, offering a silver lining that a change in management could revitalize Alexander-Arnold’s international career.

The Pressure of Penalties and Media Narratives

A pivotal moment for Alexander-Arnold came when he was called upon to take a decisive penalty in a shootout. Despite the pressure, he delivered a powerful strike, a testament to his composure and technical prowess. Lynch and Gibbs both pondered the implications if Alexander-Arnold had missed, especially considering Southgate’s own historical baggage with penalty shootouts.

“It’s just like, I do not know what it is I’ve done to myself,” Gibbs mused, reflecting the anxiety and scrutiny surrounding Alexander-Arnold’s every move under Southgate. However, Lynch was quick to dispel any conspiracy theories, asserting that Alexander-Arnold’s willingness to take the penalty was a sign of his confidence and capability.

Looking Ahead: Post-Southgate Era

As the discussion wrapped up, both Gibbs and Lynch expressed cautious optimism about Alexander-Arnold’s future with England post-Southgate. The general consensus was that a new manager with a different tactical outlook could harness Alexander-Arnold’s talents more effectively, offering him a fresh start and a chance to cement his place in the national team.

Until then, Lynch advised that Alexander-Arnold “just got to take it for what it is” and focus on performing to the best of his abilities whenever called upon. With Liverpool, Alexander-Arnold has consistently demonstrated his class and influence, attributes that will undoubtedly continue to shine through regardless of his international tribulations.

In conclusion, the tactical saga of Trent Alexander-Arnold and Gareth Southgate encapsulates the complexities and pressures of international football. As the tournament progresses, the hope remains that both player and manager can find common ground, leveraging Alexander-Arnold’s exceptional abilities to benefit the team.