Carragher: Is Ten Hag Facing the Same End as Rodgers at Liverpool?

Erik ten Hag’s Manchester United Tenure: Echoes of Brendan Rodgers’ Final Days at Liverpool

As Manchester United prepare to host Liverpool at Old Trafford, the pressure on Erik ten Hag continues to mount. The Dutch manager, who has been under scrutiny since last season, faces a crucial test this weekend that could significantly impact his future at the club. According to The Telegraph, Ten Hag’s situation bears striking similarities to Brendan Rodgers’ final days at Liverpool, where uncertainty and inconsistent results eventually led to his departure.

Ten Hag’s Position Under Scrutiny

Erik ten Hag’s tenure at Manchester United has been a rollercoaster ride, filled with moments of promise and periods of intense criticism. Last season, Ten Hag was under trial, and despite being given a new contract, the pressure has not eased. As The Telegraph points out, “When a manager’s position is so heavily scrutinised, and a club of United’s stature decides to provide more financial backing to improve the squad, there is no wriggle room, and there must be an upward trajectory.”

The upcoming clash against Liverpool is a pivotal moment for Ten Hag. A positive result could buy him time and quell the growing doubts among fans and the board. However, a defeat could see him inch closer to the exit door, much like Brendan Rodgers did after a similar vote of confidence from Liverpool’s board nine years ago.

The Liverpool Factor

Interestingly, Liverpool has played a crucial role in Ten Hag’s Manchester United journey so far. His first significant victory as United manager came against Liverpool, a 2-1 win at Old Trafford that helped him gain some early credibility. Last season, too, Liverpool was the team that seemingly rescued Ten Hag during a rough patch, with United managing to avoid defeat against their arch-rivals during a particularly challenging period.

However, not all encounters with Liverpool have gone in Ten Hag’s favour. The 7-0 thrashing at Anfield in March 2023 was a stark reminder of the team’s vulnerabilities, even when confidence was high. This upcoming fixture, therefore, is not just another game; it’s a defining moment that could either cement Ten Hag’s position or push him further towards the brink.

Slot vs. Ten Hag: A Dutch Duel

Adding another layer of intrigue to this fixture is the face-off between two Dutch managers—Erik ten Hag and Liverpool’s new head coach, Arne Slot. While Ten Hag is fighting to solidify his position, Slot is still in the early stages of his Liverpool journey, having secured comfortable wins in his first two Premier League games.

As The Telegraph notes, “Slot is preparing for his first big examination since his appointment, but the jeopardy is not so great in only his third Premier League game.” For Slot, a victory at Old Trafford would be an early statement of intent, signalling that Liverpool is back in the title race and capable of overcoming one of its biggest rivals on their home turf.

Our View – Anfield Index Analysis

The upcoming clash against Manchester United is more than just another fixture; it’s an opportunity to reassert dominance over a rival that has often proved difficult to overcome at Old Trafford. While Jurgen Klopp’s Liverpool enjoyed some memorable victories at United’s home ground, consistency was never guaranteed. Arne Slot’s arrival brings fresh hope that Liverpool can improve their record in this fixture, especially with a more controlled and possession-based approach that contrasts with Klopp’s high-risk, high-reward style.

Liverpool fans will be eager to see how Slot’s tactics fare against Ten Hag’s United, particularly given the defensive lapses that have plagued the Reds in recent trips to Old Trafford. If Slot can achieve greater defensive solidity while maintaining the attacking threat, it could be the perfect recipe for success.

Moreover, a victory would serve as a significant psychological blow to Ten Hag, potentially pushing him closer to the edge. For Liverpool supporters, there’s nothing sweeter than a win that not only boosts their team’s prospects but also adds to the turmoil of their biggest rivals.

In conclusion, this weekend’s match is set to be a crucial encounter for both teams, but particularly for Ten Hag, whose future at Manchester United could hinge on the outcome. For Liverpool, it’s a chance to start a new chapter under Slot with a statement win at Old Trafford.