3 Blue Jays win Gold Gloves, Bassitt calls Varsho's snub 'pure stupidity'

The Toronto Blue Jays were one of the best defensive teams in baseball in 2023 and three of their players were recognized for their individual greatness at their respective positions.

Matt Chapman (third base), Kevin Kiermaier (centre field) and Jose Berrios (pitcher) earned Gold Gloves on Sunday, which honour the best defenders at each position in each league. Fellow Blue Jays Alejandro Kirk (catcher) and Daulton Varsho (left field) were finalists but came up short.

Chapman won his fourth Gold Glove thanks to his reliable play at the hot corner. He finished with 12 defensive runs saved (DRS), per FanGraphs, which placed him well ahead of other finalists Alex Bregman (5) and Jose Ramirez (1). Anyone who watched the Blue Jays in 2023 can attest to the number of spectacular plays Chapman made look routine.

Kiermaier beat out Julio Rodríguez and Luis Robert Jr. en route to his fourth Gold Glove. Kiermaier held the advantage over his competitors in DRS, as his 18 were the second-highest in the majors among centre fielders. Kiermaier and Robert drew even in outs above average (+12) and fielding run value (+12), with Rodríguez (+12 OAA, +9 FRV) just a hair behind.

Berrios was a finalist for the second consecutive season and earned the honour for the first time in his career, beating Twins starters Sonny Gray and Pablo Lopez. Berrios topped American League pitchers with five DRS and surpassed his two Twins counterparts in both putouts (15) and infield assists (26).

Blue Jays pitcher Chris Bassitt was appalled that Varsho didn't walk away a winner, citing the fact the 27 year-old topped Fielding Bible's DRS rankings. Varsho accumulated 18 DRS in centre field and another 11 in left. Left field winner Steven Kwan finished with 16 DRS, all of which came at the position.

"The fact you can lead in defensive runs saved and not win a Gold Glove is pure stupidity only baseball can pull off," Bassitt wrote on X, the platform formerly known as Twitter.

Both Chapman and Kiermaier are free agents this winter, so the Blue Jays could be losing two of their defensive linchpins. Varsho would be a more-than-capable replacement in centre field, as he logged 64 games at the position in 2023 and was arguably MLB's best defender, as Bassitt alluded to. There's no obvious solution at third base, but Toronto has some intriguing options in the minors in highly-ranked prospects Addison Barger and Orelvis Martinez.

Gabriel Moreno, who the Blue Jays traded to the Arizona Diamondbacks last offseason in exchange for Varsho, won the National League's Gold Glove at catcher.

Yahoo Sports Canada's Thomas Hall contributed to this article