What's Buzzing:

Puck Daddy

Will Ryan Suter stay in Nashville after all?

Greg Wyshynski
Puck Daddy

View photo


Getty Images

The notion that Ryan Suter could become an unrestricted free agent must make anyone that handed out a 10-year contract to Christian Ehrhoff furious. Here's an all-star, minutes-hording defensive stalwart who'd be considered a franchise defenseman were it not for playing in the shadow of Shea Weber's beard. They don't come around often at 27 years old.

So there's going to be heightened attention given to Suter over the next two weeks, as he allows the frustration of the Preds' loss to Phoenix subside and begins sussing out his future with David Poile.

From The Tennessean:

"I haven't really had time to sit back and talk with my family and figure out what we want to do. This morning I had a meeting with David (Poile) and we talked about everything and the future, and how everything will go, and I think we're going to meet again in a couple of weeks and kind of make a decision."

… "Wherever I sign I want to be there for the rest of my career , and that affects my family, my wife, my kid, if we have more kids, everything plays into it."

Cynically, one might read this as "I'll let Poile know where they should trade my UFA negotiating rights." It becomes even more cynical when you read this in The Province, in a wishful thinking post about Shea Weber coming to the Vancouver Canucks, on Suter:

"Those around his situation claim he has a list of teams he wants to play for and Nashville isn't on it."

So are we ready to write off Suter as a Predator or is there still a chance he'll finish his career in Smashville?

If it's about wins and losses, the Predators have as good a case to make as any. Pekka Rinne is signed long term. Poile is among the League's top GMs, and ditto Barry Trotz as a coach. With ownership having been aggressive in adding some pricy talent in the last two seasons, it's clear that the Predators are no longer content with making the playoffs and instead want to advance.

If Suter goes to the Detroit Red Wings, does he have a better chance to win a Stanley Cup than in Nashville? Considering the miles on that franchise's top talent, it might be a wash.

Craig Custance of ESPN praised Nashville's intangibles:

In Nashville, the Predators have done a good job of erasing all the other concerns from the equation. It's a great place to play hockey, with a passionate, growing fanbase. There's now stability with an ownership that has been very public in its willingness to spend and backed it up with the huge contract given to Pekka Rinne. Despite the shortcomings this spring, GM David Poile and coach Barry Trotz remain one of the most respected duos in the game. If Poile retires anytime soon, the Predators have arguably the best assistant GM in the game in Paul Fenton ready to take over.

For Suter, it could be as simple as deciding if that combination of factors is enough to equal a consistent chance at a Stanley Cup for the next decade.

One more factor: Even if they did bring back Suter and Weber at their expected asking prices, they still might not be hamstrung against the cap.

I'd count the Predators among the top suitors for Suter, along with the Red Wings (depending on how their run at Zach Parise turns out), the open-checkbook Carolina Hurricanes (ditto), the Minnesota Wild (near Suter's native Madison, WI, but might have some cap concerns) and the Philadelphia Flyers (who covet him but would need to cut salary for him).

He's going to have long-term contracts with a high price tag thrown at him if he hits the market. But as he makes this decision, and considers the future for his family, we think back to his words at the All-Star Game when trade winds were swirling:

"Nashville is a great place to live and raise a family."

Sign up for Yahoo Fantasy Hockey
View Comments (80)
  • Broncos bring in Christian Ponder to add depth at QB

    With Peyton Manning out until at least mid-December, the Denver Broncos bolstered their depth at quarterback by signing Christian Ponder on Wednesday. Ponder can't have the number he wore at Florida State or in Minnesota - No. 7 - which belongs to … More »

    AP - Sports - 4 minutes 22 seconds ago
  • Frank Gifford's family says CTE found in his brain

    Frank Gifford's family says CTE found in his brain

    The family of Pro Football Hall of Famer Frank Gifford says signs of the degenerative disease chronic traumatic encephalopathy were found in his brain after his death. In a statement released through NBC News on Wednesday, the family says Gifford … More »

    AP - Sports - 5 minutes ago
  • A look at some of the more memorable Civil War games

    A look at some of the more memorable Civil War games

    Oregon senior defensive lineman DeForest Buckner's favorite Civil War was in 2013 when the Ducks won at home, 36-35. Marcus Mariota threw a 12-yard touchdown pass to a leaping Josh Huff with 29 seconds left, and the defense held for the victory. … More »

    AP - Sports - 5 minutes ago
  • No. 10 Gonzaga rolls past Washington 80-64 in Bahamas

    No. 10 Gonzaga rolls past Washington 80-64 in Bahamas

    Kyle Wiltjer had 24 points and Domantas Sabonis added 17 Wednesday, sending No. 10 Gonzaga past Washington 80-64 in the first round of the Battle 4 Atlantis tournament. The Bulldogs led by 17 at halftime and were ahead by 24 early in the second … More »

    AP - Sports - 8 minutes ago
  • Final kickoff changed after Tunis blast

    The kickoff for Sunday's African Confederation Cup final has been brought forward by more than five hours after a state of emergency was declared following a bomb blast that killed at least 12 people in Tunisia. The game between Etoile Sahel and … More »

    Reuters - 9 minutes ago