What's Buzzing:

Puck Daddy

Further adventures of Tim Peel, terrible NHL referee

Greg Wyshynski
Puck Daddy

View gallery


Tim Peel is a National Hockey League official. He’s abjectly terrible. Let’s find out what he’s been up to, shall we?

Dec. 17, Vancouver Canucks at Minnesota Wild

Canucks rookie defenseman Ryan Stanton was roughed up from behind and into the boards during the second period of Vancouver’s game at Minnesota, and had to be helped from the ice after injuring his ankle. Tim Peel ruled this was a 2-minute minor for Zenon Konopka for tripping; Canucks coach John Tortorella disagreed in an animated discussion during the game.

Said Torts:

“It shouldn’t have been a minor,” Tortorella said. “That’s what I thought. We are trying to get that play out of the game and look at the person who is doing it. I just thought it should have been more than a minor.”

Alas, Torts lost the a-Peel. We’ll give this one two Mario Kart banana peels. Not his worst call, and angering Tortorellla is god's work.

View gallery


Dec. 16, Winnipeg Jets at Columbus Blue Jackets

In the first period, Cam Atkinson of the Blue Jackets drove to the Jets net, made contact with goalie Al Montoya, was taken down by the defense and swiped at the puck. Then Matt Calvert came into the crease and helped push the puck over the line.

A video or other embedded content has been hidden. Click here to view it.

In Tim Peel’s world, Montoya was impeded from making a play on the puck by Calvert, and hence it was waived off for goalie interference. Which, as you know, is not a reviewable play.

Said Calvert:

“(Peel) told me I have to stay out of the crease and let the goalie make a play on it. As you can see the replay – of course it’s easier to watch a replay than to make a call on it – I dodged him the best I could and the puck was clearly in the net. You have to live by that. definitely no excuses there."

It’s clear, as this point in his tenure, that Peel has never gotten as far as the “goalie interference” rule when reading the NHL rulebook (it is rule 61, so that’s a lot of reading) which states:

If an attacking player has been pushed, shoved, or fouled by a defending player so as to cause him to come into contact with the goalkeeper, such contact will not be deemed contact initiated by the attacking player for purposes of this rule, provided the attacking player has made a reasonable effort to avoid such contact.

It’s a call he’s blown pretty much bi-weekly for the last three years. And one he blew again in the Jackets game. This one, we’ll give three banana peels:

View gallery


Dec. 12, Colorado Avalanche at Winnipeg Jets

That time when Tim Peel waived off his own penalty:

Matt Duchene went to the net hard, Tobias Enstrom appeared to trip him. Tim Peel raised his arm to call a penalty, before emphatically waiving off his own penalty call.

This truly is a landmark moment in the history of Tim Peel, as he leaves us wondering whether the initial call was terrible or if reversing that call was actually the terrible call. It’s like throwing a bag of coins in the air to confuse Two-Face before he decides whether to murder you.

That, or Peel's body is rejecting the poor officiating in his mind.

This friends is a four Peel effort:

As always, if you see or hear of any Adventures of Tim Peel, terrible NHL official, hit us at puckdaddyblog@yahoo.com.

Sign up for Yahoo Fantasy Hockey
View Comments (22)
  • NHL Three Stars: Vatrano steals win; crazy Roy move almost works

    NHL Three Stars: Vatrano steals win; crazy Roy move almost works

    The Bruins forward opened the scoring against the Detroit Red Wings with a goal and closed it out with a tip shot followed by a memorable celebration. In between, Detroit dominated, but Vatrano led the Bruins to a 3-2 win. … More »

    Puck Daddy - 3 hours ago
  • Kane's streak at 17, 'Hawks cool Sharks

    Kane's streak at 17, 'Hawks cool Sharks

    When someone like Andrew Desjardins also gets into the act, they are even tougher to beat. Kane had two assists to extend his career-best scoring streak to 17 games, and Desjardins scored his first goal of the season for some third-period insurance … More »

    AP - Sports - 3 hours ago
  • WHL Roundup: Lane Bauer had three points to lead Oil Kings past Pats

    EDMONTON - Lane Bauer had a pair of goals and added an assist as the Edmonton Oil Kings beat the Regina Pats 6-4 on Wednesday night in Western Hockey League action. … More »

    The Canadian Press - 4 hours ago
  • Vermette nets 2, Coyotes top Ducks again

    Vermette nets 2, Coyotes top Ducks again

    Antoine Vermette has been around long enough to know scoring droughts happen from time to time. Vermette scored his first goal of the season in the second period and ended Anaheim's comeback bid with an empty-netter, lifting the Arizona Coyotes to … More »

    AP - Sports - 4 hours ago
  • Filppula lifts Tampa past Kings in SO

    Filppula lifts Tampa past Kings in SO

    Ben Bishop had another strong game, and his Tampa Bay teammates finally found success in a shootout. Valtteri Filppula scored the game-winning goal in the third round of the tiebreaker, Bishop made 37 saves through overtime and the Lightning beat … More »

    AP - Sports - 4 hours ago