What's Buzzing:

Puck Daddy

Capitals, Rangers and their shot-blocking: Troubling sign for the NHL playoffs?

Harrison Mooney
Puck Daddy

View photo

.

AP

Through the first four games of their Eastern Conference semifinal, the Washington Capitals and New York Rangers have combined for 182 blocked shots.

If you're one of the many living in ever-present fear that the Dead Puck Era has just been laying dormant in the waters of the deep, waiting to rise once more like the phoenix (perhaps in Phoenix), watching scoring chances die on players' ribs and shinpads with regularity in this series has to alarm.

On Monday, Larry Brooks likened this strategic emphasis on sacrificing the body to the trap, that most evil of evils. From the New York Post:

The Rangers and Capitals will play a pivotal Game 5 tonight at Madison Square Garden in an eastern semifinal matchup that might otherwise be known as the Blocked Shot Series. Next to nothing gets through on either side, with both sides committed to doing whatever is necessary to prevent the puck from reaching the goaltender and in that way minimize scoring chances.

[...] The increase in blocked shots around hockey does not equate to an increase in commitment toward winning the Stanley Cup. It's just the latest strategy devised to negate talent, like the trap before the lockout that everyone hated with a passion.

Shot-blocking is indeed on the rise in the NHL, at least in the postseason. The total number of playoff blocked shots has risen every year since 2006-07, when the 16 teams combined for 1,140. In 2010-11, they combined for 1,522.

But 2005-06, the first year after the lockout, bucks that trend.

There were 1,305 total blocked shots that postseason, more than any of the three playoffs that followed.

Exactly 838 of those 1,305 came from the Carolina Hurricanes and the Edmonton Oilers, who blocked 420 and 418, respectively, and met in the Stanley Cup Final. These remain the two highest team totals for blocked shots in the postseason since the lockout.

Even though the Oilers and Hurricanes had success with this approach, they didn't convince anybody that this was the way to go. The following three postseasons saw a massive regression in shot blocks, as skilled teams like the Detroit Red Wings, who don't need to block many shots since the puck isn't in their end all that often, got through the grinding teams.

But now the Capitals and Rangers are taking us back. Like the Hurricanes and Oilers of six years ago, they're blocking shots at an unprecedented level. Through 11 playoff games, Washington and New York have gotten in front of 244 and 232 shots, respectively, just over 22 and 21 a game.

(Sure, these stats are juked, Baltimore Police-style, by the 81 they blocked in Game 3, but it's worth noting that Game 3 was effectively the length of two games, so it would make sense that they block about twice what they average.)

To put this into perspective, only one other team has ever averaged 21 blocked shots per game in the playoffs: the 2009-10 Montreal Canadiens, the only group of skaters to let 400 postseason shots hit them without seeing the Final.

No doubt the 2009-10 Montreal Canadiens aren't a team to emulate (because their success isn't repeatable, as their following two seasons proved). In the Canadiens' case, they blocked a lot of shots because the play was in their end most of the time. The Rangers and Capitals are just great at it.

In short, it's not worth wringing your hands over what the Capitals and Rangers are doing because, like the 2006 Stanley Cup Final, you're not watching the future of hockey. You're just watching two excellent shot-blocking teams go head to head.

View Comments (39)
  • Bucs select Florida CB Vernon Hargreaves III No. 11 overall

    Bucs select Florida CB Vernon Hargreaves III No. 11 overall

    The Tampa Bay Buccaneers are counting on Vernon Hargreaves III to be a big part of the solution for a porous secondary. ''I have confidence and I'm not afraid to show it,'' the All-American and three-time All Southeastern Conference performer said … More »

    AP - Sports - 2 hours 19 minutes ago
  • Bears trade up 2 spots, take LB Floyd with 9th pick in draft

    Bears trade up 2 spots, take LB Floyd with 9th pick in draft

    The Chicago Bears were looking for playmakers on defense and someone who could take down quarterbacks. The Bears took Floyd with the ninth pick in Thursday's draft after trading up two spots in a deal with Tampa Bay. Chicago sent the 11th pick … More »

    AP - Sports - 2 hours 47 minutes ago
  • Video drops Tunsil to Dolphins at No. 13

    Video drops Tunsil to Dolphins at No. 13

    Tackle Laremy Tunsil's surprising and costly slide in the NFL draft ended with the 13th pick Thursday, where he was taken by the Miami Dolphins. Tunsil was once considered a potential No. 1 overall pick, but he fell after a bizarre video was posted … More »

    AP - Sports - 2 hours 18 minutes ago
  • Carson Wentz heads to Philly with thick skin in tow

    Carson Wentz heads to Philly with thick skin in tow

    The Eagles gave up the farm to get Carson Wentz, so he'd better be good. … More »

    Yahoo Sports - 4 hours ago
  • Hacked: After bizarre video Tunsil's NFL draft stock drops

    Hacked: After bizarre video Tunsil's NFL draft stock drops

    Laremy Tunsil tumbled down the NFL draft board Thursday night after a bizarre video of him was posted on his Twitter account minutes before the start of the proceedings, potentially costing the offensive lineman millions of dollars. The … More »

    AP - Sports - 58 minutes ago