What's buzzing:

Shutdown Corner

Steve Smith, whom Golden Tate likes a lot, says that Golden Tate ‘didn’t have that ball’

Doug Farrar
Shutdown Corner

View gallery


Did Golden Tate catch that ball? Steve Smith thinks it's funny you should ask. (Getty Images)

It's generally nice when your heroes talk about you. When you get in the game, you're always looking for validation, if you can get it, from those who came before you and showed the way. For Seattle Seahawks receiver Golden Tate, one of the main guys who showed him how you should catch footballs in the NFL has been Carolina Panthers receiver Steve Smith. Tate, a third-year NFL player from Notre Dame, very much likes the five-time Pro Bowler and two-time First-Team All-Pro, who had one of his best seasons in 2011 at age 32.

"Yeah, definitely — he's a guy I like to model my game after," Tate told me in 2010, when I asked him about Smith's influence on his receiving style. "He's a very physical guy with the same kind of build — same kind of speed, also. I think that we play alike. I want to have the kind of swagger he has on the field, and also make the big plays that he makes. I'm not sure that he might not be even shorter than me, but he plays very tall. I'm not sure that at my height [5-foot-10], there are many players like me."

However, Smith was not impressed by the apparent touchdown Tate was gifted in the Seahawks' 14-12 win over the Green Bay Packers on Monday night. When Tate came down with the ball, or was ruled to have done so, and the replacement officials missed a blatant example of offensive pass interference when Tate pushed off on Shields, Smith saw what most of the NFL-watching country saw.

View gallery


It's still in doubt. (Getty Images)

"Hey, I'm a wide receiver, and I'm always rooting for a wideout, but that wasn't no catch," Smith told the Carolina media on Wednesday. "I think Golden Tate's a great player, he went up, he did the best he could, he's coming down, [but] he's got amnesia now, I mean, I don't blame him, but at the end of the day, come on.

"That was not a catch that he possessed. He didn't have that ball."

"I'm gonna keep preaching it -- I can't control what other people say or do," Tate told me before Wednesday's practice, when I asked him about Smith's comments. "I had the ball at the time, and looking back, and just from what I remember, I felt like I had the ball in my hands. We both competed for the ball, and the call ended up going our way, and we won the game, We're 2-1 now, and it's time to move forward."

Of course, as Smith then went on to detail, the real issue was the refs calling the game, not whether Tate had the ball. After all, there was an uncalled offensive pass interference moment that would have negated the touchdown and ended the game.

"They gotta do something. The integrity of the game, the shield, all that stuff, all the things they said in the lockout. At the end of the day this is about numbers. It's about what everyone else wants -- It's about money ... If we start just doing stuff as players, just doing stuff outside the rules, we get fined. Where's the accountability for Roger Goodell and these guys who are inadequate at their jobs, who aren't doing what they're supposed to do, who are making just flat out bad calls? And it sucks, cause it cost a team a game." [...]

"I would like them to actually do something more than just send out press releases, to do exactly what they expect players to do. To have integrity, to have safety of the game ... You've got to have competent people and if they're incompetent, get them out of there."

At this time, there are multiple reports indicating that the NFL and NFL Referees Association are close to an agreement in their ongoing labor impasse. That would be good news for the league, which can't take too many more embarrassments in this case.

View Comments (168)
  • Legendary trainer Cummings dies aged 87

    Legendary trainer Cummings dies aged 87

    Bart Cummings, one of Australia's most successful and celebrated horse racing trainers, died on Sunday, aged 87. "His final moments were spent with his family and wife of 61 years, Valmae, with whom he celebrated their anniversary on Friday," … More »

    Reuters - 12 minutes ago
  • Dodgers score 4 runs in 7th to beat Cubs 5-2

    Dodgers score 4 runs in 7th to beat Cubs 5-2

    Andre Ethier singled in a pair of go-ahead runs in the seventh inning, helping the Dodgers rally past the Chicago Cubs 5-2 Saturday night for their fifth consecutive victory. The Dodgers have their third winning streak of five or more games for the … More »

    AP - Sports - 13 minutes ago
  • Fan dies after fall from upper deck at Atlanta Braves game

    Fan dies after fall from upper deck at Atlanta Braves game

    A fan died after falling from the upper deck into the lower-level stands at Turner Field on Saturday night during a game between the Atlanta Braves and New York Yankees. Lt. Charles Hampton of the Atlanta Police Department homicide unit confirmed … More »

    AP - Sports - 14 minutes ago
  • Horse racing-Legendary trainer Cummings dies aged 87

    * Cummings dies in his sleep aged 87 * Cummings trained record 12 Melbourne Cup winners * Tributes flow in from the racing world (Adds tribute from Australian Prime Minister) SYDNEY, Aug 30 (Reuters) - Bart Cummings, one of Australia's most … More »

    Reuters - 14 minutes ago
  • Manning on the run in Denver's 19-12 win over 49ers

    Manning on the run in Denver's 19-12 win over 49ers

    Sure, Peyton Manning said, he'd like to have played more this summer - and better. ''I think we can still win games as we're developing the identity,'' Manning said Saturday night when Denver rode its stifling defense and good ground game to a … More »

    AP - Sports - 14 minutes ago