What's buzzing:

Shutdown Corner

NFL Draft Under the Microscope: Texas A&M quarterback Johnny Manziel

Frank Schwab
Shutdown Corner

Leading up to the NFL draft on May 8-10, Shutdown Corner will examine some of the most interesting prospects in the class, breaking down their strengths and weaknesses.

Johnny Manziel
Quarterback
Texas A&M

5-foot-11-3/4, 207 pounds
2013 stats: 300-of-429 (69.9 percent), 4,114 yards, 37 touchdowns, 13 interceptions, 144 rushing attempts, 759 rushing yards, 9 rushing touchdowns
40-yard dash: 4.68 seconds at pro day (official time at combine)

The good: I like Johnny Football, and think he's going to be an excellent NFL quarterback.

It has to be one or the other, right? You can't ride the fence on Manziel. Either you're Camp Johnny or a Johnny Hater, who thinks the first freshman to win the Heisman Trophy is going to be a colossal NFL flop. No in-between.

Here's why I'm in Camp Johnny: If he was 6-5 he'd be one of the most can't-miss draft prospects in recent years. And Russell Wilson and Drew Brees have shown that quarterbacks of Manziel's size can make it in the NFL, so what's holding him back? Manziel has a fantastic arm, can throw on the move, put up incredible numbers against the NFL's junior varsity known as the SEC, is a great athlete and has a tremendous feel for the game. He's also tremendously competitive and, despite the sideshow around his off-field activities, has shown the desire to get better. What struck me about Manziel was when I watched him put up 516 yards at the Cotton Bowl was he was playing on a different level than everyone else on the field that day. Whatever he wanted to do, he could do. You don't see that very often on the major college or pro level. And while that Oklahoma defense wasn't anything Sooners fans want to remember, it's not like Oklahoma doesn't have top-flight athletes. Manziel just made them all look two steps slow. It was phenomenal.

College success doesn't always translate to the NFL, of course. But there's nothing in his skill set that indicates he can't be an impact player on the next level.

View photo

.

(USA Today Sports Images)

The bad: He's short. That's where this conversation has to start. Manziel measured 5-foot-11-3/4 inches at the combine, and 207 pounds. Michael Vick and Rex Grossman are the only quarterbacks in the modern era to be drafted in the first round at 6-1 or shorter, according to the Fort Worth Star-Telegram. Manziel would be the shortest, a record held by Vick at exactly 6-0. There are reasons the NFL prefers tall quarterbacks, and players like Brees, Wilson and Vick are exceptions. There's the concern that Manziel won't be durable enough in the NFL, and that's valid considering his playing style. He'll have to be smarter in the NFL with his running if he wants to survive. There's also the worry if he can transition from relying on his scrambling to operate as a pocket passer, which all NFL quarterbacks have to do if they want to succeed.

The other criticisms of Manziel typically center around the attention he has gotten off the field. He had one incident before his redshirt freshman season in which he got into a fight and giving a fake ID to police. That's not ideal but in the grand scheme of things, it's fairly minor. The rest has basically been about Manziel posting photos of himself seemingly drinking champagne in a club before he was 21 or flashing a stack of cash at a casino, or sitting courtside at basketball games and hanging out with Drake or LeBron James. Is any of that stuff really that bad? It seems to be more of a modern-day mania of the 24/7 news cycle than a character issue. ESPN's in-depth profile of Manziel revealed he saw an alcohol counselor during the 2012 season, and that's something teams have surely asked him about. Aside from an autograph-selling hullabaloo last year that NFL teams don't care about, Manziel hasn't done much off the field to make any headlines since last summer. But, people will point to Bill Parcells' old comment about not wanting a "celebrity quarterback" and make no mistake, Manziel is as much a celebrity as almost anyone already playing in the NFL. He has shown he's willing to work on his game, most notably with quarterback guru George Whitfield and also speed coach Ryan Flaherty before running a great 40-yard dash at the combine, but there will be questions about if he's willing to dedicate himself to being great.

[Click here to browse through all of Shutdown Corner's pre-draft coverage.]

The verdict: Has there been another draft prospect quite like Manziel? The gap of opinions on his NFL future are wider than anyone before him. For every analyst you find who thinks he'll be a star, you'll find another that doesn't think he deserves to be anywhere near the first round. He's obviously turned some off with his act, but there are legitimate reasons he might fail other than the nonsense over him sitting front row of a Heat game. Maybe he is too short to be a franchise quarterback, and his desire to tuck the ball and run won't work in the NFL. Perhaps the spread offense he played in at Texas A&M won't prepare him for what he faces in the pros. But I'd be willing to gamble on him transitioning from one of the best college quarterbacks ever to a very good NFL quarterback. I don't think he should go any later than No. 2 to St. Louis. The same reasons he was great in college are the ones that will make him a very good and exciting pro, health willing.

- - - - - - -

Frank Schwab is the editor of Shutdown Corner on Yahoo Sports. Have a tip? Email him at shutdowncorner@yahoo.com or follow him on Twitter!

Sign up for Yahoo Fantasy Hockey
View Comments (7)
  • Red Sox parting gift for Ortiz: a chance at another ring

    Red Sox parting gift for Ortiz: a chance at another ring

    David Ortiz has completed his retirement tour around the major leagues, collecting farewell tributes from the opponents who watched him dismantle yet another late-inning lead (or dugout telephone ). The gift he received from his Boston teammates … More »

    AP - Sports - 7 minutes ago
  • Wild rally propels Canada to another World Cup crown; Crosby named MVP

    Wild rally propels Canada to another World Cup crown; Crosby named MVP

    For more than 57 minutes on Thursday evening Team Canada's run of perfection was threatened for the very first time. "Just crazy the way everything worked out," Sidney Crosby said. It took two goals in just over two minutes time at the end of … More »

    The Canadian Press - 8 minutes ago
  • Cardinals top Reds on Molina's disputed double in 9th inning

    Cardinals top Reds on Molina's disputed double in 9th inning

    There was no dispute the St. Louis Cardinals shouldn't have won on Yadier Molina's double. A game with playoff implications turned on a missed call Thursday night when Molina got credit for a winning double with two outs in the ninth inning to beat … More »

    AP - Sports - 9 minutes ago
  • Canada wins World Cup, rallying to beat Europe 2-1

    Canada wins World Cup, rallying to beat Europe 2-1

    Canada was not the best team on the ice until it mattered. Down two goals with 3 minutes left, the high-powered Canadians kicked it up a notch and Team Europe simply couldn't stop them. Brad Marchand scored a short-handed goal with 43.1 seconds … More »

    AP - Sports - 19 minutes ago
  • Case of the Mondays? Manning has struggled vs. Minnesota

    Case of the Mondays? Manning has struggled vs. Minnesota

    As a rookie with the New York Giants in 2004, a few weeks before taking over for good as the starting quarterback, Eli Manning was on the sideline while Kurt Warner helped lead a midseason victory at Minnesota. In seven career starts against them, … More »

    AP - Sports - 21 minutes ago