What's buzzing:

Buzzing The Net

WHL adopts NHL’s division-based playoff format; here’s the pros and cons

Neate Sager
Buzzing The Net

View photo

.

Top NHL draft prospect Sam Reinhart and Kootenay would have been a cross-over team under the new format (CP)

The Western Hockey League, in installing a NHL-style playoff format it calls a "hybrid of the WHL’s previous Conference and Divisional formats," probably missed a golden opportunity to win major points for intellectual honesty.

It would have, forgive the editorializing, been refreshing if the WHL had come right out and said, "we're a feeder league to the NHL; this is what it does and what is good for goose is good for the goslings." Be that as it may, there is a lot to like, especially from a standpoint of potentially reducing travel time for tired young athletes during early round matchups. There is also, as Daniel Nugent-Bowman put it, "potential for series between fierce rivals with minimal travel." What would have been better for the bottom line of both coastal B.C. franchises this spring — a first-ever affray between the Vancouver Giants and three-year-old Victoria Royals, or what actually happened, which was Vancouver being swept by Portland while the Royals faced the Spokane Chiefs?

For demonstration purposes, here's the first round from 2014 re-sorted.

Eastern Conference

Central Division — Prince Albert (second wild card) vs. Edmonton, Medicine Hat vs. Calgary; East Division — Kootenay (first wild card) vs. Regina, Brandon vs. Swift Current

Western Conference

U.S. Division — Spokane (first wild card) vs. Portland, Everett vs. Seattle; B.C. Division — Tri-City (second wild card) vs. Kelowna, Vancouver vs. Victoria.

Kootenay actually tallied only two fewer points than East-winning Regina. Presumably the Sam Reinhart-led Ice, who ousted 103-point Calgary, probably would have also advanced, and possibly even come out of a division they don't actually play in.

And, for grins, 2013:

Eastern Conference

Central Division — Kootenay (second wild card) vs. Edmonton, Red Deer vs. Calgary; East Division — Medicine Hat (first wild card) vs. Saskatoon, Swift Current vs. Prince Albert.

Western Conference

U.S. Division — Everett (second wild card) vs. Portland, Tri-City vs. Spokane; B.C. Division — Seattle (first wild card) vs. Kelowna, Victoria vs. Kamloops.

Six of the eight matchups would have been the same; Red Deer played Prince Albert and Calgary played Swift Current in '13. This retcon preserves the 2013 Medicine Hat-Saskatoon matchup, where the Tigers swept the Memorial Cup-host Blades. Is that a load off anyone else's mind?

Whether this actually makes the playoffs more "fair and competitive" depends on one's working definitions. It means, had this been used in 2014, 92-point Medicine Hat would not have home ice for the first round whereas 85-points-apiece Regina and Swift Current did. Granted, a full-season record isn't a measure of a team's true strength.

The league also certainly has a gap to address between its big-market teams such as Calgary and Edmonton and clubs in smaller centres across the Prairies. Maybe, for instance, it is fairer to try to use a format that gives the Saskatchewan teams some encouragement. Only one team based in the province has made the Eastern final in the past five post-seasons.

The NHL generally has greater competitive balance than any major junior league, so time will tell how applying the former's format to the latter will pan out. At the very least, though, a niche league should strive to be more relatable for the general public, so cribbing from the NHL format has its merits.

Parity cannot be legislated and any new playoff format is bound to create unintended consequences, which actually seems like part of the fun of following a junior hockey league.

Neate Sager is a writer for Yahoo! Canada Sports. Follow him on Twitter @neatebuzzthenet.

View Comments (0)
  • Froome pulls out of Spanish Vuelta with broken foot

    Chris Froome pulled out of the Spanish Vuelta on Thursday after fracturing a bone in his right foot. The two-time Tour de France champion - and two-time Vuelta runner-up - said on his Twitter account that the navicular bone in his foot was … More »

    AP - Sports - 8 minutes ago
  • Pirelli inquiry reveals 'unusual number of cuts' in F1 tires

    Pirelli inquiry reveals 'unusual number of cuts' in F1 tires

    Pirelli says that ''a highly unusual number of cuts'' were reported by the Formula One tire supplier's engineers at the Belgian Grand Prix, one of which caused the failure on Nico Rosberg's car. While Rosberg's incident occurred in practice, the … More »

    AP - Sports - 16 minutes ago
  • Samoan lock to miss World Cup opener after punch

    Samoan lock to miss World Cup opener after punch

    LONDON (Reuters) - Samoan lock Kane Thompson will miss his nation's first Rugby World Cup clash against the United States in Brighton on Sept. 20 through suspension after punching an opponent, World Rugby said on Thursday. The 33-year-old was … More »

    Reuters - 23 minutes ago
  • Los Angeles mayor pitches 2024 Olympic bid to IOC president

    Los Angeles mayor pitches 2024 Olympic bid to IOC president

    Los Angeles Mayor Eric Garcetti took his city's newly-launched bid for the 2024 Summer Games to IOC headquarters on Thursday, saying it's time ''to bring the Olympics back home'' to the United States after an absence of nearly three decades. … More »

    AP - Sports - 24 minutes ago
  • Chelsea ties up with India's Wipro in digital, fan engagement drive

    Chelsea ties up with India's Wipro in digital, fan engagement drive

    Reigning English Premier League champions Chelsea FC will team up with Indian IT services group Wipro Ltd to help improve its digital media strategy, the two said a day after rival Manchester United made a similar announcement. Wipro will work to … More »

    Reuters - 33 minutes ago