What's Buzzing:

Buzzing The Net

London Knights’ Jake Patterson retiring at 20 a reminder CHL pushes goalies through the system too quickly

Neate Sager
Buzzing The Net

View photo


Patterson was London's backup at the past two Memorial Cup tournaments (Aaron Bell, OHL Images)

Chances are that, if Jake Patterson had toiled for an off-the-beaten path team instead a flagship franchise such as the London Knights, his choice not to subject himself to the vagaries of the market for overage goalies might have escaped notice.

However, the 20-year-old Sault Ste. Marie, Ont., native, did play for London, he apparently did decide not to play and it does fall under a discomfiting pattern. That makes it worthwhile to talk about it. At the start of each season, there is a trickle of major junior players who "caught up in the 20-year-old game and its uncertainties, with each team being allowed to keep only three of them." It seems to apply especially to goaltenders, since the prevailing rule of thumb is that a 20-year-old goalie has to be a drop-dead No. 1 (or someone who can play until he drops).

It's just worth wondering why it has to be that way. It's well-known that goalies mature later than defenceman and forwards, yet they still fall under the same overage rule instead of being exempt.

Doing so does not seem to jibe with either the development or entertainment aspect of major junior hockey. On the first count, when the Canadian Hockey League excluded goalies from the import draft in 2013, I had a long conversation with a former NHL goalie (I won't say whom because I don't feel up to be called a weasel for sharing a private chat) who pointed out the current system pushes goaltenders through too quickly. Allowing a team to carry a pair of 20-year-old 'tenders, his argument went, might give that late bloomer just an extra bit more time, just a little more exposure. Goalies typically don't bloom in full until age 24.

From an entertainment standpoint, the aim should always be to improve the quality of talent. It's hard to say what would happen with a change, but having more 20-year-old 'tenders in the CHL could create more opportunities for younger teens to start at the Junior A level.

As it stands, the OHL, with only three European goalies left in the league (Saginaw's 19-year-old Nikita Serebryakov, Barrie's 19-year-old Daniel Gibl and Ottawa's 17-year-old Leo Lazarez, a 'naturalized netminder'), has a goalie shortage. Only one 19-yearold goalie, Mississauga's Spencer Martin, is a NHL draft pick (no. 63 to the Colorado Avalanche to 2013).

It's no wonder that, as the London Free Press' Ryan Pyette detailed, the going rate to trade for a quality goalie "is two-second-round picks and a third-rounder."

Point being, whatever issue there might be with training goalies in Canada, there seems to be an issue with retention is well. Whatever Jake Patterson's reasons — and he's entitled to his privacy — it is worth noting he had two netminding mates who got shunted aside during their age-20 seasons. In '11-12, Tyson Teichmann was London's backup. Last season, after nine games with Kitchener, he ended up playing out the season with the Junior A Wellington Dukes (albeit close to his hometown).

The following season, Patterson platooned with overage Kevin Bailie. Midway through the season, not long after the Knights had 24-game win streak, Bailie was jettisoned to make room for Philadelphia Flyers prospect Anthony Stolarz. Bailie, a one-time first-rounder in the OHL priority selection, also finished up his season in Junior A. Bailie, who now plays for the Queen's Golden Gaels, is the reigning rookie of the year in Canadian university hockey, which suggests someone was pushed aside too soon.

It does not have to be this way. I know the Ontario, Quebec and Western leagues have to agree as one to tweak the overage rules in order to keep the appearance of a level playing field for Memorial Cup. Whether the rules were a direct contributor to Patterson's choice is none of my business, but they certainly don't help someone feel needed.

Neate Sager is a writer for Yahoo! Canada Sports. Follow him on Twitter @neatebuzzthenet.

View Comments (13)
  • OKC survives big mistakes in wild ending, takes Game 2 over Spurs

    OKC survives big mistakes in wild ending, takes Game 2 over Spurs

    OKC's bounced back from a Game 1 rout in a big way, but San Antonio arguably should have won after a baffling Dion Waiters push and clear fast-break opportunity in the final seconds. … More »

    Ball Don't Lie - 6 minutes ago
  • Twins end Keuchel's 17-game run at home

    Twins end Keuchel's 17-game run at home

    The Minnesota Twins were the first team in over a year and a half to beat Dallas Keuchel in Houston, and they did it with patience. Brian Dozier broke out of a slump with three hits and the Twins snapped Keuchel's 17-game home winning streak with a … More »

    AP - Sports - 17 minutes ago
  • Thunder hold off Spurs, tie series at 1

    Thunder hold off Spurs, tie series at 1

    Russell Westbrook had 29 points and 10 assists, and the Oklahoma City Thunder held on to beat San Antonio 98-97 on Monday night, evening the series at one game apiece when the Spurs failed to score on a wild sequence in the final seconds. Kevin … More »

    AP - Sports - 30 minutes ago
  • Gonzalez sharp as Nats 5-hit Royals

    Gonzalez sharp as Nats 5-hit Royals

    In the meantime, the Nationals manager is content to rely on his pitching to win games. Ryan Zimmerman and Daniel Murphy drove in the only runs in the first inning. Gonzalez (2-1) went just six, but he scattered four hits and a pair of walks in … More »

    AP - Sports - 34 minutes ago
  • Wainwright has 1 of Cards' 5 HRs in win

    Wainwright has 1 of Cards' 5 HRs in win

    Adam Wainwright knew his mammoth home run changed the complexion of Monday night's game. ''Right now, it's all about wins for me,'' Wainwright said. Wainwright pitched six innings and hit a three-run home run - the first of five for St. Louis - as … More »

    AP - Sports - 42 minutes ago