What's Buzzing:

The Eh Game

Ottawa Gee-Gees men’s hockey team, whose coach didn’t report sexual assault complaint, shut down for 2014-15

Neate Sager
Eh Game

View photo


uOttawa president Allan Rock says he suspending the hockey program, not the team (Sean Kilpatrick, The Canadian …

A cover-up is often worse than an alleged crime. That might not be literally true when the allegations concern accusations as serious as sexual assault, but at the end of the day, that is why there is no realistic way that the University of Ottawa could go forward with icing a men's hockey team in the Ontario University Athletics conference this season.

The Gee-Gees men's hockey program was initially suspended on March 3, one week after uOttawa administrators were told about a Thunder Bay, Ont., police investigation into an incident involving three players and a young woman that happened on Feb. 1. (They learned of it from "a friend of the victim.") On Wednesday, the university stated that coach Réal Paiement did not properly follow the chain of command in reporting it to superiors. As a result, Paiement has been fired and the program's suspension has been extended throughout the entire 2014-15 season. Not unlike the University of Waterloo football players whose 2010 season due to an uproar over players being busted for illegally selling steroids, Gee-Gees players are contemplating legal action.

From Michael Woods (@michaelrwoods):

Rock said that head coach Réal Paiement’s response to the alleged incident “did not meet university expectations” because he failed to report the allegations to the university.Rock said the coach learned of the allegations within hours and took his own disciplinary action, but didn’t inform university authorities.

Several University of Ottawa hockey players have retained a lawyer and are threatening to sue.

Lawyer Lawrence Greenspon said the university and its president have defamed, punished and even ended the careers of some 'innocent' players who have done absolutely nothing wrong.

"You've got a team of 24 players. My information is that, at the absolute most, there were three that are alleged to have been involved in misconduct," Greenspon said. (Ottawa Citizen)

Rock, a former federal cabinet minister, employed some interesting semantics during a news conference, stating: "We're suspending the program, not the team." That should make it clear where the burden lies: on the authority figures who, in the milieu of a university, went rogue. It also arguably makes it harder for the players to seek redress since they haven't been suspended; their program has just ceased to be for a while.

No charges have been laid, but uOttawa is reacting to how this was handled and not what might/might not be established by a police investigation. Anyone who thinks there needs to be a conviction in order to justify the suspension is missing the point. It's about accountability; it's on coaches to show it doesn't put players being named in a sexual assault complaint on the same level with, say, missing practice. That is how it looks with Paiement, a former national junior team coach, trying to discipline players internally.

Moreover, uOttawa is obligated first and foremost to helping its entire student population feel safe. Continuing to ice a men's hockey team would send the wrong message. It's also worth wondering, with the program having been suspended, how it was possibly able to recruit and retain players for this season.

I am no Lawrence Greenspon, but the affected players might not have much to stand on legally. The university's bylaws give it the power to say whether there will be a season. Every player presumably also signed a code of conduct before donning his garnet-and-grey jersey, and there appears to be proof that was violated, too ("an independent review of events in Thunder Bay revealed that the behaviour of some players was 'unacceptable' ").

Any Gee-Gees player who is in school to primarily to play high-performance hockey — and yes, they do exist in Canadian Interuniversity Sport, where a handful of players every year sign minor pro and European contracts — is free to find a new team. Typically, CIS allows any student-athlete on a team that was suspended or discontinued to play for another school right away without first sitting out a season.

Collective sanctions are inevitably unpopular, and always suck for those affected. In the big picture, Rock and uOttawa made the right call.

Neate Sager is a writer for Yahoo! Canada Sports. Follow him on Twitter @neatebuzzthenet.

Sign up for Yahoo Fantasy Hockey
Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.
    • NHL-National Hockey League roundup

      Bernier, 31, had six points (one goal, five assists) in 24 games with the Islanders last season. - - The Boston Bruins recalled goaltender Malcolm Subban on an emergency basis from Providence of the American Hockey League. Bruins starting goalie … More »

      Reuters - 13 minutes ago
    • Friedman: No back surgery expected for Clayton Kershaw

      Friedman: No back surgery expected for Clayton Kershaw

      Clayton Kershaw is unlikely to need back surgery for the herniated disk that sidelined the Dodgers ace for 2 + months during the season, according to president of baseball operations Andrew Friedman. ''Like all of our guys, we have exit physicals … More »

      AP - Sports - 17 minutes ago
    • Patriots rolling as they prepare for Round 2 against Bills

      Patriots rolling as they prepare for Round 2 against Bills

      As excited as Buffalo Bills coach Rex Ryan was about his team's 16-0 win over the Patriots earlier this month - his first in Foxborough in eight tries - he was quick to acknowledge it came with an asterisk. The Patriots enter the week playing well … More »

      AP - Sports - 20 minutes ago
    • Cavs begin title defense vs. Knicks

      The city of Cleveland has waited 52 years to celebrate a championship, yet on the night the Cavaliers will receive their rings and the banner is raised to the rafters, somehow this team has become a bit of an afterthought within its own hard-luck … More »

      AP - Sports - 30 minutes ago
    • Mike Commodore finds retirement fun in Uber driving

      Mike Commodore finds retirement fun in Uber driving

      Mike Commodore finds retirement fun in Uber driving … More »

      Puck Daddy - 29 minutes ago