What's Buzzing:

55 Yard Line

Arbitrator upholds Khalif Mitchell’s two-game suspension, suggesting CFL discipline has teeth

Andrew Bucholtz
55 Yard Line

View photo

.

Khalif Mitchell won't be celebrating on a CFL field for a while.

The B.C. Lions are going to be without one of their key defensive pieces for a little while, as defensive tackle Khalif Mitchell's two-game suspension was upheld by an arbitrator Wednesday. However, while that may hurt the Lions, it could well be a good thing for the league. Mitchell picked up the suspension for hyperextending the arm of Edmonton offensive lineman Simeon Rottier in July, and he was widely criticized for his actions, but decided to appeal anyway, putting off his suspension until now. While Mitchell may have delayed the suspension, he couldn't escape it with an appeal; that's a significant change for the CFL, and one that might actually make the league's disciplinary process appear to have enough teeth to discourage such actions in future.

The history of CFL suspensions hasn't exactly been a stunning one, and the few suspensions that have been issued have often come undone at the appeal stage. Only three players have actually served one-game suspensions since commissioner Mark Cohon took office in 2007, with several others (such as former B.C. and Hamilton offensive lineman Jason Jimenez) initially being handed suspensions that were later reduced to fines on appeal. Mitchell's case thus marks the most notable suspension of Cohon's tenure, and it also signifies another important point; a case where the arbitrator didn't reduce the league-mandated discipline. To date, those have been rare, and a move like this might convince some players to be more careful on the field. Now, fines can be a significant punishment as well, and there are plenty of cases where they're deserved, but a suspension has a much more notable on-field impact on both the player and his team, and it sets down more firmly that there are some lines the league won't tolerate players crossing.

That's not to say that CFL discipline has reached a perfect stage. Just this week, two further questionable plays (a late hit Montreal linebacker Rod Davis delivered on Winnipeg quarterback Alex Brink Aug. 3, and a chop-block Toronto offensive lineman Chris Van Zeyl gave B.C.'s Keron Williams Aug. 6) were determined to only be worthy of fines, and that had plenty (including Brink himself) questioning the process. In fact, there's generally a strong argument to be made that CFL discipline is too weak; no one's asking for an NFL-style system that gives Cohon Roger Goodellesque powers of judge, jury and executioner, as that can prove excessive the other way, but the Canadian league's recent history suggests that players can get away with most things with only a little light punishment.

That's a problematic perception, considering how player safety's becoming one of the pivotal issues at all levels of football. Mitchell's suspension being upheld could be the first step towards changing that trend, however, and that's a good thing. The Lions will certainly miss one of their most crucial players up front, but Mitchell's actions against Edmonton clearly crossed a line between a legitimate football play and a vicious, outside the lines action with the potential to compromise another player's health. With this suspension being upheld, the league's finally been able to implement discipline with some teeth, and hopefully that will send a message to Mitchell and the rest of the league's players that actions that threaten other players' safety won't be tolerated. It's a vital message, and one that may finally be heard in the CFL.

View Comments (0)
  • Bucs select Florida CB Vernon Hargreaves III No. 11 overall

    Bucs select Florida CB Vernon Hargreaves III No. 11 overall

    The Tampa Bay Buccaneers are counting on Vernon Hargreaves III to be a big part of the solution for a porous secondary. ''I have confidence and I'm not afraid to show it,'' the All-American and three-time All Southeastern Conference performer said … More »

    AP - Sports - 2 hours 22 minutes ago
  • Bears trade up 2 spots, take LB Floyd with 9th pick in draft

    Bears trade up 2 spots, take LB Floyd with 9th pick in draft

    The Chicago Bears were looking for playmakers on defense and someone who could take down quarterbacks. The Bears took Floyd with the ninth pick in Thursday's draft after trading up two spots in a deal with Tampa Bay. Chicago sent the 11th pick … More »

    AP - Sports - 2 hours 49 minutes ago
  • Video drops Tunsil to Dolphins at No. 13

    Video drops Tunsil to Dolphins at No. 13

    Tackle Laremy Tunsil's surprising and costly slide in the NFL draft ended with the 13th pick Thursday, where he was taken by the Miami Dolphins. Tunsil was once considered a potential No. 1 overall pick, but he fell after a bizarre video was posted … More »

    AP - Sports - 2 hours 20 minutes ago
  • Carson Wentz heads to Philly with thick skin in tow

    Carson Wentz heads to Philly with thick skin in tow

    The Eagles gave up the farm to get Carson Wentz, so he'd better be good. … More »

    Yahoo Sports - 4 hours ago
  • Hacked: After bizarre video Tunsil's NFL draft stock drops

    Hacked: After bizarre video Tunsil's NFL draft stock drops

    Laremy Tunsil tumbled down the NFL draft board Thursday night after a bizarre video of him was posted on his Twitter account minutes before the start of the proceedings, potentially costing the offensive lineman millions of dollars. The … More »

    AP - Sports - 1 hour 0 minutes ago