The pair — who have been notoriously private about their relationship — were spotted dancing together at the HBO Emmys after-party on Monday night
The White Lotus stars didn’t walk the red carpet together, but they were seated next to each other at the awards ceremony, with Woodall, 27, joining Fahy, 33, in the front row of the Peacock Theater. Ahead of Monday's ceremony, the former Bold Type star earned her first-ever Emmy nomination for outstanding supporting actress in a drama series for the HBO hit.
After the show ended — and their costar Jennifer Coolidge called back to their White Lotus season thanking the “evil gays” as she won for outstanding supporting actress in a drama series — the couple continued their night at the HBO after party held at the San Vicente Bungalows.
While there, the cast of The White Lotus, including Coolidge, 62, and Sabrina Impacciatore, made their way to the dance floor as the DJ spun their show's theme song.
Throughout much of the night, Grammy-nominated singer Este Haim was behind the DJ booth as mixologist-driven Jello-shots were passed on trays among stars including the Emmy-laden Succession cast, John Oliver, Stephen Colbert, Ali Wong, Bill Hader, Adrien Brody and Quinta Brunson.
Woodall and Fahy stayed close at the festive bash, chatting with friends as Fahy held her beau's arm and the two later danced together. She eventually donned Woodall's suit jacket to stay warm during the chilly L.A. night.
At one point, Woodall had his arms wrapped around Fahy as she wore his jacket, and the sweet moment was captured in a photo.
The actors first sparked romance rumors in September 2022, after Woodall shared a carousel of photos featuring the actress and their White Lotus castmates on Instagram around the time the second season began airing.
In one shot, the pair took a selfie with a polaroid camera. He captioned the post, "That's amore."
"I love you! I love these! I love you! 😘♥❤️," Fahy wrote in the comment section and he replied, "Love you right back 🖤"
In December 2022, Fahy shared her own photo dump from filming the show, and included a selfie with Woodall as well as a photo of him lying on the ground holding a camera.
She remained tight-lipped on the nature of their relationship, though, when Andy Cohen pressed for information on Watch What Happens Live that January.
After being asked by a viewer if there was "any truth" to the speculation of a romance with Woodall, Fahy said, "Oh, I don't kiss and tell. Come on, guys."
Cohen then told Fahy, that a romance between the pair would be "delicious" and "we would all love it."
"You would? For you, I'll say sure," she replied. "I'm just kidding, just because you wanted me to say it, so I said it."
The first public sighting of their romance came in November 2023, when they were photographed sharing a kiss while out on a rainy New York day together.
Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE's free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.
Seasons 1 and 2 of The White Lotus can be streamed on Max.
For more People news, make sure to sign up for our newsletter!
Read the original article on People.