Terry Baddoo: Hair-trigger refereeing is ruining the game

Goal.com
Terry Baddoo: Hair-trigger refereeing is ruining the game
.

View photo

Terry Baddoo: Hair-trigger refereeing is ruining the game

Another "Super Sunday," another marquee match laid low by the laws of the game. 

Don’t get me wrong, when referee Mike Dean pointed to the spot following Laurent Koscielny’s 10th-minute bear hug of Edin Dzeko during the English Premier League clash between Arsenal and Manchester City, I had no issue with the decision. It was what soccer pundits like to call "a stonewall penalty." What I didn’t agree with was the red card.

I felt even more aggrieved some 65 minutes later when the ref decided to "even things up" by sending City’s Vincent Kompany for an early bath. No foul. No card, in my opinion, which the FA apparently agreed with when it overturned the card two days later.

Of course, both dismissals were judgment calls. IFAB, the International Football Association Board, which is responsible for making the laws, stipulates that using foul play to deny an obvious goal-scoring opportunity is a red-card offense. The operative word is "obvious," and clearly that’s open to interpretation. But, in Mike Dean’s eyes, Koscielny’s action was blatant. So, despite already conceding a penalty, the Frenchman was made to suffer the double whammy.  

Similarly, in Dean’s view, Kompany's tackle either fell into the category of serious foul play or violent conduct, which, under the laws, gave the ref carte blanche to issue a carte rouge, so to speak.  

So, technically, even though I didn't see the undeniable need for a red card, Dean was not wrong. However, as a fan, I still felt hard done by. Let me elaborate. Whether in the stadium or at home, soccer fans pay to watch a "match." That term, at the very least, implies equality of opportunity for both sides -- a level playing field, if you like. However, when the ref sends someone off he creates nothing but inequality and imbalance, and that's not what it says on the ticket.

Of course, no one wants to sanction foul play. Goals are the game's biggest attraction and violent conduct is one of its biggest turn-offs. But while it's incumbent on the officials to promote one and discourage the other, I also believe the game has a responsibility to honor its contract with the paying customer.

Soccer is in the business of entertainment, yet all too often the audience is shortchanged because the main protagonists are kicked off the stage well before the curtain comes down. Regardless of your allegiance, did the game benefit as a spectacle from Arsenal being depleted for an hour? No, it didn't. It changed what could have been a fascinating cut-and-thrust encounter into a training ground attack-against-defense drill. By the time the odds were evened by Kompany’s card, the game was dead and the drama lost for good.

Especially in tough economic times, providing value for money is paramount for any business (a requirement endorsed by the furor over ticket prices for Sunday’s game at the Emirates). Unfortunately, nowadays I don't believe soccer fans always get that bang for their buck due to hair-trigger refereeing and laws that allow little space between harshness and leniency.

So here’s my suggestion: Fouls in the box result in a penalty but no red card. If some feel that's insufficient punishment, I propose the idea of benching the culprit in a sin-bin for a prescribed period of time, or, and this is my preference, imposing a mandatory substitution of the offender. That way the player pays the price for his action, as does the team by losing its first-choice lineup, but the integrity of the match isn't permanently ruined for the fans.

For denying a goal-scoring opportunity outside the box, or committing a serious or violent foul anywhere in the attacking half of the field, the same punishment should apply, alongside the awarding of a "penalty" from a second spot 18 yards out. That would act as a deterrent to foul play while maintaining the ref's right to make judgment calls. Crucially, though, it would still preserve the match as a fair fight for the audience.

I'm open to variations, but whatever the fine details, the aim should be to punish the guilty and compensate the victims, while keeping 22 players on the field whenever ethically possible.

A red card should be the last resort, used only for ultra-violent or repeat offenses. After all, we pay to see a match, not a mismatch, don't we?

Follow TERRY BADDOO on Twitter

View Comments
  • Suns' Dragic voted league's most improved player

    Suns' Dragic voted league's most improved player

    (Reuters) - Phoenix Suns guard Goran Dragic, whose breakout campaign helped his team to a 23-win improvement, was named the National Basketball Association's most improved player, the league said on Wednesday. Dragic received 408 of a possible … More »

    Reuters - 3 minutes 55 seconds ago
  • NBA-Suns' Dragic voted league's most improved player

    Phoenix Suns guard Goran Dragic, whose breakout campaign helped his team to a 23-win improvement, was named the National Basketball Association's most improved player, the league said on Wednesday. Dragic received 408 of a possible 1,134 points, … More »

    Reuters - 8 minutes ago
  • FIFA advisers urge support for Garcia probe to resolve allegations about Qatar World Cup bid

    FIFA advisers urge support for Garcia probe to resolve allegations about Qatar World Cup bid

    GENEVA - FIFA's reputation depends on resolving allegations about Qatar's selection as the 2022 World Cup host, according to the governing body's anti-corruption advisers. The expert panel chaired by Swiss law professor Mark Pieth gave its full … More »

    The Canadian Press - 10 minutes ago
  • Robert Griffin III will drive the pace car at Richmond thanks to Dale Earnhardt Jr.'s tweet

    Robert Griffin III will drive the pace car at Richmond thanks to Dale Earnhardt Jr.'s tweet

    When you're Dale Jr. and RGIII, you can make things happen in a hurry. … More »

    Shutdown Corner - 11 minutes ago
  • 4 WNBA teams to play 2-game preseason tourney

    NEW YORK (AP) -- Four WNBA teams will take part in a preseason tournament in Orlando over Mother's Day weekend. … More »

    AP - Sports - 11 minutes ago
  • Suns' Dragic honored as NBA's Most Improved Player

    Suns' Dragic honored as NBA's Most Improved Player

    NEW YORK (AP) -- Goran Dragic has been honored as the NBA's Most Improved Player after his career year helped lead the Suns to 23 more wins this season. … More »

    AP - Sports - 12 minutes ago
  • Grey Cup-champion Roughriders lone CFL team to exceed $4.4-million salary cap

    TORONTO - The Grey Cup-champion Saskatchewan Roughriders were the only team to surpass the CFL's 4.4-million salary cap in 2013, the league announced Wednesday. According to the CFL, the Roughriders' spent $4,417,975 in salaries last year. As per … More »

    The Canadian Press - 15 minutes ago
  • 30 top prospects to attend NFL draft in New York

    30 top prospects to attend NFL draft in New York

    NEW YORK (AP) -- The NFL says 30 top prospects, including Texas A&M quarterback Johnny Manziel and South Carolina defensive end Jadeveon Clowney, will attend the draft next month in New York. … More »

    AP - Sports - 19 minutes ago
  • Ferrer ousted, Nadal wins at Barcelona Open

    Ferrer ousted, Nadal wins at Barcelona Open

    Second-seeded David Ferrer was ousted from the Barcelona Open by a Russian opponent for the second straight year and defending champion Rafael Nadal labored to victory on Wednesday. Ferrer was unable to find his rhythm in losing 6-4, 6-2 to … More »

    AP - Sports - 20 minutes ago
  • Calder Trophy Finalists: Nathan MacKinnon vs. Tyler Johnson vs. Ondrej Palat

    Calder Trophy Finalists: Nathan MacKinnon vs. Tyler Johnson vs. Ondrej Palat

    Forwards Tyler Johnson and Ondrej Palat of the Tampa Bay Lightning and Nathan MacKinnon of the Colorado Avalanche are the three finalists for the 2013-14 Calder Memorial Trophy, which is awarded “to the player selected as the most proficient in his … More »

    Puck Daddy - 21 minutes ago
  • Cardinals player gets probation for assault plea

    PHOENIX (AP) -- A judge in Phoenix has sentenced Arizona Cardinals linebacker Daryl Washington to a year of supervised probation for assaulting a former girlfriend who is the mother of his daughter. … More »

    AP - Sports - 25 minutes ago
  • Another gut-check for the Blues, another determined defending champion standing in the way of the Stanley Cup

    Another gut-check for the Blues, another determined defending champion standing in the way of the Stanley Cup

    The St. Louis Blues have been down this road before, with an early series lead on a defending Stanley Cup champion. This time, the Blues believe they're ready to knock off the Chicago Blackhawks and take a run at the Cup themselves. … More »

    Yahoo Sports - 35 minutes ago
  • Ethiopia appoint Portugal's Barreto as coach

    Ethiopia appoint Portugal's Barreto as coach

    By Aaron Maasho ADDIS ABABA (Reuters) - Ethiopia have named Portugal's Mariano Barreto as coach, the head of the Ethiopian Football Federation (EFF) said on Wednesday. Barreto, a former Ghana coach and assistant manager of Dynamo Moscow, was given … More »

    Reuters - 40 minutes ago
  • Peng, Peer reach Morocco quarterfinals

    MARRAKESH, Morocco (AP) -- Peng Shuai of China beat Ukrainian qualifier Maryna Zanevska 6-4, 7-6 (5) on Wednesday to reach the quarterfinals of the Grand Prix SAR. … More »

    AP - Sports - 45 minutes ago
  • Raw: Violence Erupts in Rio Near Olympic Venue

    Raw: Violence Erupts in Rio Near Olympic Venue

    Violence erupted late Tuesday in a main tourist area of Rio de Janeiro following the killing of a popular local figure near where 2016 Olympic swimming events are expected to take place. (April 23) … More »

    AP Canada Videos - 52 minutes ago
  • Europe split by financial iron curtain, says Champagne

    Europe split by financial iron curtain, says Champagne

    By Brian Homewood BERNE (Reuters) - European football is more divided today than it was during the Cold War because of the unequal distribution of wealth among its clubs, FIFA presidential candidate Jerome Champagne said. "During the Cold War, … More »

    Reuters - 1 hour 1 minute ago
  • Lightning teammates, MacKinnon named finalists for Calder Trophy as top rookie

    Lightning teammates, MacKinnon named finalists for Calder Trophy as top rookie

    NEW YORK, - The Calder Trophy voting for the NHL's top rookie will have a Tampa Bay Lightning flavour to it. Lightning forwards Tyler Johnson and Ondrej Palat were named as finalists for the trophy along with Nathan MacKinnon of the Colorado … More »

    The Canadian Press - 1 hour 9 minutes ago
  • Regina Pats’ sale imminent, Battalion shoot for sweep: the coast-to-coast

    Combing all corners of the country and the blogosphere for your junior hockey headlines ... WHL Edmonton will need a "short memory" about its Game 3 loss, where it outshot the Medicine Hat Tigers 44-21. (Edmonton Sun, Medicine Hat News) … Continue … More »

    Buzzing The Net - 1 hour 11 minutes ago
  • Valverde wins Walloon Arrow Classic for 2nd time

    Valverde wins Walloon Arrow Classic for 2nd time

    Alejandro Valverde of Spain timed his climb on the closing Wall of Huy to perfection to win the Walloon Arrow classic ahead of Daniel Martin of Ireland and Michal Kwiatkowski of Poland on Wednesday. Pre-race favorite Philippe Gilbert, who won the … More »

    AP - Sports - 1 hour 33 minutes ago
  • Rosol beats Nieminen to reach quarters

    BUCHAREST, Romania (AP) -- Defending champion Lukas Rosol reached the Nastase Tiriac Trophy quarterfinals with a 6-2, 6-4 victory over eighth-seeded Jarkko Nieminen of Finland on Wednesday. … More »

    AP - Sports - 1 hour 35 minutes ago
  • Ron MacLean makes awkward apology after French-Canadian ref conspiracy theory

    Ron MacLean makes awkward apology after French-Canadian ref conspiracy theory

    Again, for the record: MacLean was worried about the perception of assigning a French-Canadian referee for the game immediately following one in which a French-Canadian referee made a controversial call. He’s TOTALLY cool with a French-Canadian … More »

    Puck Daddy - 1 hour 38 minutes ago
  • Ferrer suffers early defeat in Barcelona

    Ferrer suffers early defeat in Barcelona

    By Tim Hanlon BARCELONA (Reuters) - Four-time finalist David Ferrer crashed out in the second round of the Barcelona Open on Wednesday, producing a rusty performance to lose 6-4 6-2 to Georgia's Teymuraz Gabashvili. The world number five, who beat … More »

    Reuters - 1 hour 46 minutes ago
  • Jefferson in walking boot, plans to play

    Jefferson in walking boot, plans to play

    Al Jefferson was still in his walking boot when the Charlotte Bobcats arrived for their shootaround hours before facing the Miami Heat in Game 2 of an Eastern Conference first-round series. Bobcats coach Steve Clifford says the team was planning to … More »

    AP - Sports - 1 hour 46 minutes ago
  • Bulls suffer blow as Van der Merwe picks up ban

    Bulls suffer blow as Van der Merwe picks up ban

    Bulls captain Flip van der Merwe was suspended for three weeks on Wednesday after being found guilty of striking Waratahs prop Paddy Ryan, further deepening the crisis the South African franchise is facing among its second rowers. The Springbok … More »

    Reuters - 2 hours 11 minutes ago
  • Blake Bortles, Teddy Bridgewater raising concern over basic skills

    Blake Bortles, Teddy Bridgewater raising concern over basic skills

    What are the yellow and red flags over QB prospects Teddy Bridgewater and Blake Bortles? It comes down to delivering the football. … More »

    Yahoo Sports - 2 hours 16 minutes ago
  • Yamanaka defends WBC bantamweight title with TKO

    Yamanaka defends WBC bantamweight title with TKO

    Shinsuke Yamanaka of Japan successfully defended his WBC bantamweight crown for the sixth time with a technical knockout of Stephane Jamoye of Belgium on Wednesday. Yamanaka sent Jamoye to the canvas with a powerful blow to the abdomen and the … More »

    AP - Sports - 2 hours 22 minutes ago
  • Tennis-Ferrer suffers early defeat in Barcelona

    By Tim Hanlon BARCELONA, April 23 (Reuters) - Four-time finalist David Ferrer crashed out in the second round of the Barcelona Open on Wednesday, producing a rusty performance to lose 6-4 6-2 to Georgia's Teymuraz Gabashvili. The world number … More »

    Reuters - 2 hours 27 minutes ago
  • Sri Lanka players resolve pay dispute

    The pay dispute between Sri Lanka Cricket and its 13 contracted players ended on Wednesday when the latter agreed to accept 10 percent of the participation fees from ICC and Asian Cricket Council (ACC) events. The players had demanded 20 percent of … More »

    Reuters - 2 hours 33 minutes ago
  • Singaporean fixer arrested in Helsinki

    Singaporean Wilson Raj Perumal, convicted in 2011 for fixing football matches, has been arrested in Helsinki, according to Finland's National Bureau of Investigation. "Wilson Raj Perumal was arrested last week in Helsinki, and we are studying the … More »

    Reuters - 2 hours 35 minutes ago
  • A's reject 10-year stadium lease offer

    A's reject 10-year stadium lease offer

    The Oakland A's have rejected a deal to play at its ballpark for the foreseeable future, saying the 10-year lease extension offer doesn't meet all their requirements. The Oakland Tribune reports (http://bit.ly/1notDIE ) the team's rejection came … More »

    AP - Sports - 2 hours 38 minutes ago
  • Jimmy Fallon presents NHL Playoff Awards, basically ruins Matt Niskanen for us

    Jimmy Fallon presents NHL Playoff Awards, basically ruins Matt Niskanen for us

    Last May, Fallon attempted an “NHL Awards” bit on his late night show and basically tripped over the pronunciation of every name. And while we’re still not sure how a guy who nails the Boston sports stereotype like Fallon has in the past … More »

    Puck Daddy - 2 hours 39 minutes ago
  • Sacked Moyes thanks Ferguson for Man Utd opportunity

    Sacked Manchester United manager David Moyes thanked his predecessor Alex Ferguson on Wednesday for having given him the opportunity to lead the Premier League club. In a statement issued through the League Manager's Association (LMA), the Scot … More »

    Reuters - 2 hours 42 minutes ago
  • Popovich wins NBA Coach of Year award

    Popovich wins NBA Coach of Year award

    The San Antonio Spurs, the model for stability and sustained success in the modern NBA, were still a shaken team when they showed up for training camp in October, less than four months after a devastating loss to Miami in the NBA Finals. Gregg … More »

    AP - Sports - 2 hours 43 minutes ago
  • Pujols becomes 26th to reach 500 homers

    Pujols becomes 26th to reach 500 homers

    Albert Pujols smiled as he explained why he felt the need to apologize to his wife for hitting homer No. 500 so quickly after No. 499. Pujols became the first major leaguer to get his 499th and 500th homers in the same game, connecting twice … More »

    AP - Sports - 2 hours 46 minutes ago
  • Course changes to Hoylake for British

    Course changes to Hoylake for British

    There will be a horseshoe grandstand around the 18th green for the first time at a British Open as part of a number of course changes for this year's tournament at Hoylake. Organizers say the Royal Liverpool course will be extended by 54 yards … More »

    AP - Sports - 2 hours 46 minutes ago
  • Bills cheerleaders file suit against team over pay, harassment

    Bills cheerleaders file suit against team over pay, harassment

    The Buffalo Jills are not happy with their working conditions. … More »

    Shutdown Corner - 2 hours 46 minutes ago
  • Why Wrigley Field's 100th birthday feels a bit empty on the North Side

    Why Wrigley Field's 100th birthday feels a bit empty on the North Side

    The Chicago Cubs are advertising the 100th anniversary of Wrigley Field’s opening as the “Party of the Century” and that would be all well and good if the label didn’t sound so familiar. … More »

    Big League Stew - 2 hours 54 minutes ago
  • Cyclist Rogers cleared to race after doping case

    Former world time trial champion Michael Rogers can race again after cycling's governing body accepted that meat he ate in China likely caused his positive doping test. Rogers, an Olympic bronze medalist, helped persuade the International Cycling … More »

    AP - Sports - 3 hours ago
  • 15 unusual facts that make Wrigley Field one of a kind

    15 unusual facts that make Wrigley Field one of a kind

    Wrigley Field is celebrating its 100th birthday. In one hundred years, you can imagine the stories this stadium has to tell. We’ve tracked down 15 interesting facts that will give you a deeper appreciation for this venue and its prolific history.

    More »

    3 hours ago
  • World Cup rush leaves gaps in Brazil cell network

    Brazil had trounced the Spanish world champions. The final of the 2013 Confederations Cup, a dress rehearsal for this year's World Cup, was a promising 3-0 victory for Brazil's national team but a bad omen for its cellphone network. Despite costly … More »

    Reuters - 3 hours ago