Starting Pitcher Shuffle Up: Max Scherzer shows the way

Roto Arcade
<a class="link rapid-noclick-resp" href="/mlb/players/8193/" data-ylk="slk:Max Scherzer">Max Scherzer</a> has been a 200-inning man for five straight years (AP Photo/Jeff Roberson)
Max Scherzer has been a 200-inning man for five straight years (AP Photo/Jeff Roberson)

We roll along in the Shuffle Up series.

You’ll have to season the prices to taste. The numbers don’t matter in a vacuum; what matters is how the player prices relate to one another. Assume a 5×5 scoring system, as always. Everyone listed here has starting pitcher eligibility in the Yahoo game entering 2018. Players at the same cost are considered even.

Scroll to continue with content
Ad

[Batter up: Join a Yahoo Fantasy Baseball league for free today]

Have some disagreements? Have some major disagreements? That’s good! That’s why we have a game. I welcome your respectful disagreement anytime: @scott_pianowski on Twitter.

Just the prices for now. Comments will be added on the weekend. Check status on the asterisk players; I am not going to argue the merits of the injured (especially when it comes to injured pitchers). They’re worth whatever you want them to be.

Game on.

Note: Shortly after this initial posting, the Madison Bumgarner injury news broke. I’ve removed the lefty from the ranks for now, and will re-evaluate when more information is available. If I were drafting tonight, unless the price were silly low, I’d just let someone else have Bumgarner. That’s how I generally handle long-term injuries. 

$40 Max Scherzer
$39 Clayton Kershaw
$39 Chris Sale
$39 Corey Kluber
$33 Jacob deGrom
$33 Carlos Carrasco
$31 Justin Verlander
$31 Noah Syndergaard
$29 Stephen Strasburg
$26 Luis Severino
$24 Zack Greinke
$22 Yu Darvish
$22 Carlos Martinez
$21 Chris Archer
$21 Robbie Ray
$21 Aaron Nola
$19 James Paxton
$18 Dallas Keuchel
$18 Jose Quintana
$18 Gerrit Cole
$16 Masahiro Tanaka
$16 David Price
$14 Jake Arrieta
$14 Lance McCullers
$13 Shohei Ohtani
$13 Kyle Hendricks
$12 Jon Lester
$12 Alex Wood
$11 Luis Castillo
$11 Zack Godley
$11 Jose Berrios
$11 Sonny Gray
$10 Rich Hill
$10 Luke Weaver
$10 Garrett Richards
$10 Jameson Taillon

$10 Johnny Cueto
$10 Trevor Bauer
$9 Marcus Stroman
$9 Danny Duffy
$9 Taijuan Walker
$8 *Jeff Samardzija
$8 Jonathan Gray
$8 Chase Anderson
$7 Michael Clevinger
$7 Michael Fulmer
$7 Gio Gonzalez
$7 Charlie Morton
$7 Kenta Maeda
$7 Drew Pomeranz
$7 Dylan Bundy
$7 Blake Snell
$7 Dinelson Lamet
$7 Lance Lynn
$7 Julio Teheran
$6 Kevin Gausman
$6 J.A. Happ
$6 Jacob Faria
$6 Rick Porcello
$6 Aaron Sanchez
$5 Danny Salazar
$5 Sean Manaea
$5 Michael Wacha
$5 Cole Hamels
$5 Tanner Roark
$5 Patrick Corbin
$5 Jake Odorizzi
$4 Jordan Montgomery
$4 Lucas Giolito
$4 Brad Peacock
$4 Joe Musgrove
$3 Marco Estrada
$3 *Ervin Santana
$3 *Jimmy Nelson
$3 Tyler Chatwood
$2 Alex Cobb
$2 Felix Hernandez
$2 *Eduardo Rodriguez
$2 Zach Davies
$2 Miles Mikolas
$2 Hyun-Jin Ryu
$2 Matt Shoemaker
$2 Sean Newcomb
$2 CC Sabathia
$2 Brandon McCarthy
$2 Luis Perdomo
$1 *Carlos Rodon
$1 Daniel Straily
$1 Jake Junis
$1 Matt Harvey
$1 Steven Matz
$1 Ivan Nova
$1 Vincent Velasquez
$1 Michael Foltynewicz
$1 Tyler Skaggs
$1 Kyle Gibson
$1 Chad Kuhl
$1 Walker Buehler
$1 Jack Flaherty
$1 Nick Pivetta
$1 Andrew Triggs
$1 Brandon Woodruff
$1 Kendall Graveman
0 *Jerad Eickhoff
0 Mike Leake
0 Tyler Glasnow

What to Read Next