Sources: NFL players' union strong-armed into 'collusion', led to penalties for Cowboys, Redskins

Jason Cole
Yahoo Sports

It's hard to know which is more galling:

The fact that NFL commissioner Roger Goodell is openly promoting the idea of collusion in keeping down player salaries or the fact that NFL Players Association executive director DeMaurice Smith was forced to accept it, according to sources.

As the NFLPA's annual meeting of player representatives takes place this week in Marco Island, Fla., followed by the NFL owners meetings in Palm Beach, Fla., next week, one issue both sides must address is what appears to be an obvious case of collusion on the part of the league.

[ Michael Silver: Roger Goodell will not tolerate lying, disrespect ]

Earlier this month, the league announced penalties for the Washington Redskins and Dallas Cowboys for supposed overspending in the 2010 uncapped year. While the idea that teams could "overspend" when there was no salary cap seems absurd, the league is somehow selling the idea and the union can do little about what appears to be a clear violation of the free-market system.

This is the case because the NFL was essentially able to strong-arm the NFLPA into accepting collusion in exchange for concessions on the salary cap. While some people, including current and former players, believe Smith agreed to it to protect his reputation with the players as he faced re-election this week, the issue runs deeper.

When the league and the union negotiated a new collective bargaining agreement that ended the 2011 lockout, one of the provisions was a "global settlement" of all pending legal issues. One of those was a collusion claim the union had filed against the league.

Fast forward to earlier this month, when the league and the union were negotiating to get the salary cap to $120.6 million, a slight increase over the $120 million it was in 2011. The union was in a bind because the cap really should have come in between $113 million and $117 million based on the complicated revenue-sharing formula.

There was a decrease despite the overall share of money going to the players actually increasing this year. However, the part of the share that went to salaries was affected by a significant increase in long-terms benefits, such as the "Legacy" fund the union created, and increases in insurance benefits. All of that is paid out of the money that goes to players.

Still, the bottom line is the bottom line.

"If the cap had been $113 million, you would have had a lot of really unhappy veterans," a source said. "There are a lot of guys who would have been cut and salaries would have declined. It would have been a fiasco for both the players and the clubs because a lot of teams would have had to cut more players than they already did."

[ Jason Cole: Jeremy Shockey denies snitching on Saints ]

At the last minute, the NFL added one element to the agreement: It would agree to the higher cap only if Washington and Dallas faced a combined penalty of $46 million lost in cap space over the 2012 and 2013 seasons because of their high spending in 2010.

That was the equivalent of a bitter pill the size of golf ball.

In essence, the NFLPA had to weigh the option of keeping the salary cap high for now against the idea of accepting collusion.

NFL spokesman Greg Aiello and NFLPA spokesman George Atallah both declined to discuss the matter. However, sources on both sides say the union agreed to the penalties because it had little choice.

"Why did we agree to it?" a former player said, rhetorically. "Because the league had us over a barrel. If we didn't agree to the penalty for the Redskins and the Cowboys, the cap would have been $113 million, the players would have been [angry] and De would have gotten fired.

"What the league is doing is collusion, plain and simple."

Another source disputed the fact that Smith's job status had anything to do with it. Smith, who was re-elected Thursday, ran unopposed this week. However, he has been subject to criticism in the aftermath of the new CBA. In January, attorney David Cornwell, who has since taken over as the head of the NFL Coaches Association, distributed a lengthy critique of the deal and concluded that Smith should be fired.

In this case, the union was in a difficult position because of the "global settlement." Even if the union had tried to fight the penalties against the Redskins and Cowboys, a judge or arbitrator might have viewed such legal action as a violation of the two sides' agreement.

Beyond that, if the union won after what would have been a lengthy battle (the famous 1988 baseball collusion case took two years to settle), the damages from the $46 million penalty might have been less than the increase in the cap for this season.

After doing a cost-benefit analysis, Smith and the union's executive committee decided to accept the penalties. As a result, Washington lost $36 million in cap space and Dallas lost $10 million. Washington, which maintains it did nothing wrong, is fighting the penalty and may sue the league, multiple sources said.

The league maintains that teams were warned on numerous occasions not to overspend in the uncapped year. The league views the issue as a matter of "competitive balance," even though neither Washington nor Dallas made the playoffs the past two years and there has rarely been a link between spending and winning in the NFL.

More importantly, the action by the league undercuts the idea of an uncapped year not being a threat in labor negotiations.

"This goes against everything that we negotiated for in [the past]" a player said, referring to the previous CBA and subsequent extensions. "The owners were supposed to live with the realities of the uncapped season. That was supposed to make them afraid to go uncapped. Now, they're telling the big spenders, 'You were really bad boys, we're going to punish you.' What the [expletive]? What kind of fear are they going to have in the future?"

The best analogy: If you were trying to sell something at auction and were told just before the sale that the top two spenders in the room had been barred from bidding, you might be pretty upset.

Collusion claims have had serious consequences in the past. In 1990, Major League Baseball owners settled with baseball's union to pay a then-staggering $280 million in damages based to players on three charges filed and won by the union in 1988.

While an NFL source maintained that the salary-cap penalty against the Redskins and Cowboys will be redistributed around the league (every other team except the New Orleans Saints and Oakland Raiders, who were assessed smaller penalties, will get $1.6 million extra on the salary cap this year), that ignores the reality that many clubs will simply not spend the money because there is no team-by-team minimum spending.

"If you give Kansas City or Cincinnati or San Diego an extra $1.6 million or $3 million or $5 million, who cares? They're not going to spend it," an agent said. "When there was no cap and no spending floor, those teams didn't pay anybody. They were way below the spending limits. If Washington and Dallas had the money, they'd spend it and the league knows it."

Furthermore, sources questioned why teams that didn't spend weren't penalized by the league.

[ Dan Wetzel: Tim Tebow, Marrk Sanchez can coexist ]

"Couldn't you argue that teams that saved all this money by not spending are helping themselves out artificially by saving room to spend later?" the agent said. "The only teams being punished are the big spenders and that's because the league wants to hold down salaries."

The spending habits of Dallas and Washington appear to have had a ripple effect throughout the league. For instance, the contract Dallas gave to wide receiver Miles Austin in 2010 contributed to the 2011 "franchise" tag salary of $11.4 million for former San Diego Chargers wide receiver Vincent Jackson.

This year, the Chargers were faced with having to pay $13.7 million if they wanted to franchise Jackson again, and the team declined. Privately, the Chargers blamed Dallas over the Austin contract for causing San Diego to lose Jackson.

Washington, in particular, has been fighting the penalties this week. Although a league source said the team was warned on several occasions not to overspend, a union source said that's just further proof of collusion.

"The Redskins did nothing wrong. All they did was spend money," the union source said.

While one union source said that the organization's executive committee, which is made up of players such as NFLPA president and former player Kevin Mawae, quarterback Drew Brees and cornerback Domonique Foxworth, is in agreement with the strategy, others in and around the union are concerned.

"We have a lot of questions that need to be answered," one player rep said. "We all understood what was happening during the negotiations and how rough it was. But now it's like there's one thing after another that's happening that we don't get explained [to us] until after it's all over."

Another former player preached patience, but was also concerned.

[ Les Carpenter: Tim Tebow gives the Jets so many options ]

"You have to give the deal a couple of years to see where we're really going to be, but things don't seem to be going well when we allow collusion," the former player said. "Now, maybe that was a one-off situation where the union gave up something to get something. That's all part of a bigger negotiation and you understand that when it's explained to you.

"But nobody is really getting an explanation on this stuff. You have collusion going on over here and they're manipulating the salary cap over there. There's a bunch of stuff going on and you don't know if it's good negotiating or if people trying to cover their butts. All I know is, the precedent really bothers me."

Other popular content on Yahoo! Sports:
Video: Russell Westbrook nearly airballs dunk attempt
Cleveland Indians ace Ubaldo Jimenez looks for lost velocity
Don Mattingly could give Los Angeles Dodgers identity during dark time
Unbeaten boxer Vernon Paris fights with a bullet an inch from his spine

  • Blues C Backes scratched for Game 4

    Blues C Backes scratched for Game 4

    St. Louis center David Backes was scratched Wednesday night for Game 4 of the Blues' first-round playoff series against the Chicago Blackhawks due to an upper-body injury. Backes did not participate in St. Louis' morning skate, but coach Ken … More »

    AP - Sports - 11 minutes ago
  • Swimming-'Grandfather' Phelps plays down Rio prospects

    * Phelps plays down expectations * Drops one of three races for comeback meet * Hints that he wants to compete at Rio in 2016 (Recasts with quotes) By Julian Linden PHOENIX, April 23 (Reuters) - Michael Phelps is playing down expectations about … More »

    Reuters - 14 minutes ago
  • Sanchez's slam in 11th helps Giants beat Rox 12-10

    Sanchez's slam in 11th helps Giants beat Rox 12-10

    Backup catcher Hector Sanchez played a starring role in a wild win. Sanchez hit two of San Francisco's six homers, including a grand slam in the 11th inning Wednesday that gave the Giants a thrilling 12-10 victory over the Colorado Rockies. With … More »

    AP - Sports - 17 minutes ago
  • Pau Gasol: 'There'd have to be significant changes' for me to return to Lakers in free agency

    Pau Gasol: 'There'd have to be significant changes' for me to return to Lakers in free agency

    In a post on his personal website, the Spaniard discusses the chances that his time with the Los Angeles Lakers has reached its end. … More »

    Ball Don't Lie - 20 minutes ago
  • Henderson Denies Haslem

    Henderson Denies Haslem

    Gerald Henderson comes from across the lane for the big block on Udonis Haslem at the rim. … More »

    NBA.com - 33 minutes ago
  • McRoberts to Henderson

    McRoberts to Henderson

    Josh McRoberts skips the three-pointer and hits Gerald Henderson with a lob for the alley-oop jam. … More »

    NBA.com - 37 minutes ago
  • Pineda ejected for substance on neck

    Pineda ejected for substance on neck

    New York Yankees pitcher Michael Pineda was ejected from a game against the Boston Red Sox in the second inning Wednesday night after umpires found a foreign substance on his neck. Pineda's ejection occurred 13 days after the right-hander had brown … More »

    AP - Sports - 43 minutes ago
  • Yankees pitcher Michael Pineda ejected from Red Sox game after umpire finds substance on neck

    Yankees pitcher Michael Pineda ejected from Red Sox game after umpire finds substance on neck

    BOSTON - New York Yankees pitcher Michael Pineda was ejected from a game against the Boston Red Sox in the second inning Wednesday night after umpires found a foreign substance on his neck. Pineda's ejection occurred 13 days after the right-hander … More »

    The Canadian Press - 43 minutes ago
  • After 500th HR, Pujols hears from Big Papi, Jeter

    After 500th HR, Pujols hears from Big Papi, Jeter

    In the hours after Albert Pujols hit his 500th career homer, his cellphone kept buzzing early into Wednesday morning. There were texts and calls from the likes of fellow players David Ortiz and Derek Jeter. And there was a conversation with his … More »

    AP - Sports - 44 minutes ago
  • Seahawks to open NFL season vs. Packers

    Seahawks to open NFL season vs. Packers

    As Super Bowl champions, the Seattle Seahawks get to kick off the NFL's regular season by hosting the Green Bay Packers on Sept. 4. It's the third straight season the Packers have traveled to face the defending Super Bowl champions. ''It's a … More »

    AP - Sports - 45 minutes ago
  • Stephen Curry: Warriors aren't 'going to lie down' against Clippers

    Stephen Curry: Warriors aren't 'going to lie down' against Clippers

    After losing by 40 points in Game 2, Stephen Curry vows the Warriors will be more physical with the Clippers in Game 3. … More »

    Yahoo Sports - 47 minutes ago
  • Tracy McGrady makes Sugar Land Skeeters opening day roster

    Tracy McGrady makes Sugar Land Skeeters opening day roster

    Tracy McGrady's baseball dream lives on. … More »

    Big League Stew - 47 minutes ago
  • Yankees pitcher Michael Pineda ejected after foreign substance discovered on his neck

    Yankees pitcher Michael Pineda ejected after foreign substance discovered on his neck

    The Yankees pitcher was involved in a similar controversy against the Red Sox earlier this month. … More »

    Big League Stew - 53 minutes ago
  • M's end skid at 8 on Seager's walkoff HR

    M's end skid at 8 on Seager's walkoff HR

    With one swing, Kyle Seager hopes he ended his personal skid at the plate and the Seattle Mariners' slide. ''Any time you see the ball hit the ground, it's obviously a big confidence booster,'' Seager said. Thankfully.'' Seager hit a three-run … More »

    AP - Sports - 1 hour 1 minute ago
  • James All the Way

    James All the Way

    LeBron James picks up the loose ball and throws down a one-handed slam in transition. … More »

    NBA.com - 1 hour 5 minutes ago
  • Phelps ditches one of his planned comeback events

    Phelps ditches one of his planned comeback events

    By Julian Linden PHOENIX (Reuters) - Michael Phelps has withdrawn from one of the three events he planned to compete in at his eagerly-anticipated return to competitive swimming. Phelps had entered the heats for the 50 metres freestyle, 100m … More »

    Reuters - 1 hour 6 minutes ago
  • 2014 NFL schedule: Thanksgiving will be an NFC party, with some great games

    2014 NFL schedule: Thanksgiving will be an NFC party, with some great games

    It's been a while since every Thanksgiving NFL game was a great matchup. There's always a dud. Not this year. By making a tweak with the networks, the NFL guaranteed three tremendous matchups. The day starts with Chicago at Detroit, followed by … More »

    Shutdown Corner - 1 hour 8 minutes ago
  • Benzema strike gives Real edge over holders Bayern

    Benzema strike gives Real edge over holders Bayern

    By Iain Rogers MADRID (Reuters) - Real Madrid struck early through Karim Benzema and comfortably held Bayern Munich at bay to beat the holders 1-0 on Wednesday and move a step closer to a first Champions League final in 12 years. Chasing a … More »

    Reuters - 1 hour 9 minutes ago
  • Injured players eager to get to work with Colts

    Dwayne Allen spent months envisioning the day he could get back to work for the Colts on the practice field. Pro Bowl receiver Reggie Wayne says he's feeling good about his recovery from a torn ACL in his right knee, though doctors have instructed … More »

    AP - Sports - 1 hour 9 minutes ago
  • 2014 NFL schedule: Packers-Seahawks 'Fail Mary' reunion kicks off season

    2014 NFL schedule: Packers-Seahawks 'Fail Mary' reunion kicks off season

    The NFL isn't messing around with its 2014 schedule, starting off with Green Bay Packers at Seattle Seahawks, a rematch of the Fail Mary game. … More »

    Shutdown Corner - 1 hour 10 minutes ago
  • Ancelotti happy as Real thrive without much from Ronaldo, Bale

    Ancelotti happy as Real thrive without much from Ronaldo, Bale

    By Iain Rogers MADRID (Reuters) - Real Madrid coach Carlo Ancelotti praised his team for beating holders Bayern Munich in Wednesday's Champions League semi-final, first leg without their two biggest names taking a leading role. Cristiano Ronaldo, … More »

    Reuters - 1 hour 11 minutes ago
  • Rangers' Perez gets second straight SHO

    Rangers' Perez gets second straight SHO

    With the Texas rotation ravaged by injuries early in the season, Martin Perez has more than filled the void. Perez pitched his second consecutive shutout to extend his scoreless innings streak to 26 and the Texas Rangers wrapped up a three-game … More »

    AP - Sports - 1 hour 12 minutes ago
  • Kidd-Gilchrist's And-one

    Kidd-Gilchrist's And-one

    Michael Kidd-Gilchrist draws the foul and gets the tough bucket to fall … More »

    NBA.com - 1 hour 14 minutes ago
  • 2014 NFL regular-season schedule - Week by week

    2014 NFL regular-season schedule - Week by week

    The 2014 NFL season schedule was released Wednesday. See who your favorite team faces and when. … More »

    Shutdown Corner - 1 hour 15 minutes ago
  • Seahawks QB Wilson divorcing from wife

    Seahawks QB Wilson divorcing from wife

    Seattle Seahawks quarterback Russell Wilson has announced that he and his wife Ashton are divorcing. Wilson made the announcement in a statement released by the Seahawks on Wednesday. He says decisions like this are not easy and respectfully asks … More »

    AP - Sports - 1 hour 16 minutes ago
  • Should the CFL go to a harder salary cap?

    Should the CFL go to a harder salary cap?

    Wednesday's news that the Saskatchewan Roughriders were the only team to exceed the CFL's salary cap in 2013 (they spent $4,417,975 in salaries, $17,975 over the cap) is interesting for a couple of reasons. First, this breaks one pattern; the … … More »

    55 Yard Line - 1 hour 21 minutes ago
  • A's reject 10-year stadium lease offer

    A's reject 10-year stadium lease offer

    The Oakland Athletics say they are stopping negotiations to extend their lease at the Coliseum. A's President Michael Crowley issued the statement Wednesday after the Oakland-Alameda County Coliseum Authority said the team owes more than $5 million … More »

    AP - Sports - 1 hour 25 minutes ago
  • Ducks without Getzlaf, Selanne vs. Stars

    Ducks without Getzlaf, Selanne vs. Stars

    DALLAS (AP) -- Anaheim Ducks captain Ryan Getzlaf is out of Game 4 against the Dallas Stars because of an upper-body injury. … More »

    AP - Sports - 1 hour 26 minutes ago
  • Heat extend deal in Miami through 2040

    Saying they reaffirm the team's commitment to the city, the Miami Heat announced Wednesday night that they have agreed to extend their partnership with Miami-Dade County another 10 years through 2040. Heat managing partner Micky Arison, whose team … More »

    AP - Sports - 1 hour 33 minutes ago
  • Formula One boss Ecclestone goes on trial in Germany

    Formula One boss Ecclestone goes on trial in Germany

    By Keith Weir MUNICH (Reuters) - Formula One chief executive Bernie Ecclestone goes on trial for bribery in Germany on Thursday in a case that could see the Briton's long dominance of the motor sport ended by a jail sentence. Prosecutors in Munich … More »

    Reuters - 1 hour 38 minutes ago
  • Ryan Getzlaf to miss Game 4 versus Stars with upper-body injury

    Ryan Getzlaf to miss Game 4 versus Stars with upper-body injury

    The Anaheim Ducks will be without captain and first-line centre Ryan Getzlaf for Wednesday night's pivotal Game 4 versus the Dallas Stars. According to the team, Getzlaf will miss the game with an upper-body injury. … More »

    Puck Daddy - 1 hour 39 minutes ago
  • Phelps having fun in his return to swimming

    Phelps having fun in his return to swimming

    Michael Phelps is making a comeback after nearly two years out of the pool for the simplest of reasons: He missed the sport that has been his entire life. ''Looking at a black line for hours on end, I don't know what made me do it,'' he said … More »

    AP - Sports - 1 hour 39 minutes ago
  • Red Sox demote struggling OF Nava

    The Red Sox demoted struggling switch-hitting outfielder Daniel Nava and recalled right-hander Alex Wilson on Wednesday. Nava, 31, was a big part of Boston's run to the 2013 World Series title, but was hitting just .149 with two homers and three … More »

    AP - Sports - 1 hour 45 minutes ago
  • James Spins and Hits

    James Spins and Hits

    LeBron James spins off his defender and lays it in. … More »

    NBA.com - 1 hour 46 minutes ago
  • Maddon: Escobar 4-2 strikeout should be walk

    Maddon: Escobar 4-2 strikeout should be walk

    ST. PETERSBURG, Fla. (AP) -- Tampa Bay Rays manager Joe Maddon has an interesting suggestion after Yunel Escobar's stuck out a pitch with a 4-2 count: give him credit for a walk. Escobar struck out in the fifth inning Tuesday night after the … More »

    AP - Sports - 1 hour 46 minutes ago
  • Horschel aiming to defend Zurich title

    Horschel aiming to defend Zurich title

    There's something about the rhythm of life in the Big Easy that appeals to Billy Horschel, who acknowledges that he can be a little ''hyper'' for even his own liking on the PGA Tour. Horschel earned his first PGA Tour victory at the Zurich Classic … More »

    AP - Sports - 1 hour 46 minutes ago
  • Cubs lose on Wrigley's 100th birthday

    Cubs lose on Wrigley's 100th birthday

    The Chicago Cubs celebrated the 100th anniversary of the first game at Wrigley Field in the most appropriate way: with a gut-wrenching loss. After an error by shortstop Starlin Castro, the Arizona Diamondbacks rallied for five runs in the ninth to … More »

    AP - Sports - 1 hour 48 minutes ago
  • Pujols insists he's not thinking beyond next at-bat

    Pujols insists he's not thinking beyond next at-bat

    By Steve Ginsburg WASHINGTON (Reuters) - One day after joining baseball's exclusive 500 home run club, Albert Pujols insists he is not concerned with reaching another longball milestone. Let the fans and the media talk about 600 or 700 home runs, … More »

    Reuters - 1 hour 50 minutes ago
  • Jones returns to Drake for shuttle hurdle relay

    Jones returns to Drake for shuttle hurdle relay

    Lolo Jones has decided to run the Drake Relays after waffling on a return to her hometown meet a year ago. But rather than compete in the high-profile 100-meter hurdles, Jones will make her transition from the bobsled back to the blue oval in a … More »

    AP - Sports - 1 hour 51 minutes ago
  • Padres RHP Johnson out for season

    Padres RHP Johnson out for season

    San Diego Padres starter Josh Johnson is scheduled to undergo elbow ligament-replacement surgery for the second time and will miss the entire season. He strained his elbow during spring training and the Padres initially thought he would be out … More »

    AP - Sports - 1 hour 57 minutes ago