Advertisement

Relative Is Angry After L.A. Innocence Project Takes Scott Peterson's Case: We'd Like to 'Take Him on a 1-Way Fishing Trip'

Laci Peterson and her unborn son were murdered Christmas Eve 2002, and husband Scott Peterson was convicted. Now, the L.A. Innocence Project says he may be innocent

<p>AP Photo/Paul Sakuma</p> Laci and Scott Peterson pictured in a memorial January 10, 2003.

AP Photo/Paul Sakuma

Laci and Scott Peterson pictured in a memorial January 10, 2003.
  • Scott Peterson was convicted of his wife’s and unborn son’s murder in 2004 and placed on death row the following year.

  • In 2021, Peterson’s death sentence was vacated and he was re-sentenced to life behind bars.

  • With the Los Angeles Innocence Project saying they are “investigating” Peterson’s “claim of actual innocence,” family members react to the possibility that Scott could go free decades after his conviction.

At the 2004 murder trial, Scott Peterson claimed through his lawyers that he had been on a lone fishing trip when his eight-months pregnant wife disappeared from their Modesto, Calif., home Christmas Eve 2002. Scott was later convicted of the murder of Laci Peterson and their unborn son and sentenced to death row.

But in recent years, Scott has scored some legal victories, and new developments have opened the door to the possibility that Scott's fate isn't sealed.

In 2021 Scott was taken off death row and later, he was re-sentenced to life in prison.

Then, last week, the Los Angeles Innocence Project said in a statement to PEOPLE that it was "investigating” Scott's “claim of actual innocence."

<p>Modesto Police Dept/ZUMAPRESS.com</p> Laci and Scott Peterson

Modesto Police Dept/ZUMAPRESS.com

Laci and Scott Peterson

And now, in interviews with PEOPLE, family members on both sides of the couple, are reacting to the news that Scott's case could be reopened.

Related: Where Is Scott Peterson Now? Inside His Life in Prison Amid L.A. Innocence Project Case

“They’re barking up the wrong tree trying to set that criminal loose,” says Stan Bonds, a cousin by marriage to Laci. He adds: “Scott was a spoiled rich boy that got caught.”

<p>AP Photo/Ann Johansson</p> Scott Peterson (R) hands out missing person posters to volunteers during a search for his eight-months pregnant wife, Laci Peterson, January 19, 2003.

AP Photo/Ann Johansson

Scott Peterson (R) hands out missing person posters to volunteers during a search for his eight-months pregnant wife, Laci Peterson, January 19, 2003.

Bonds recalls a candlelight vigil shortly after Laci’s death in which he approached Scott to speak, only to find the man on his phone throughout the service.

Related: Here's the Evidence Prosecutors Presented that Led to Scott Peterson's Murder Conviction in 2004

“As far as we’re concerned it’s a done deal: He killed Laci,” says Bonds. “I say turn him loose: We’ll take him on a one-way fishing trip.”

<p>Debbie Noda/Modesto Bee/Tribune News Service via Getty Images</p> Scott Peterson talking to investigators, February 18, 2003.

Debbie Noda/Modesto Bee/Tribune News Service via Getty Images

Scott Peterson talking to investigators, February 18, 2003.

Scott, now 51, who has always maintained his innocence, claimed at the time that he believed his wife to have been killed after witnessing a home invasion next door.

Related: L.A. Innocence Project Takes Scott Peterson's Case, Says New Evidence 'Supports' Claim He Didn't Kill Wife Laci

The L.A. Innocence Project argues that Scott's state and federal rights were violated in the original case, alleging deficiencies in police reports, tip sheets and other evidentiary material at trial.

<p>California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation/AP</p> Scott Peterson in a prison photo, October 21, 2022.

California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation/AP

Scott Peterson in a prison photo, October 21, 2022.

“This thing just keeps rearing its head, doesn’t it?” Karin Bird says in an interview with PEOPLE. (Bird is related by marriage to Scott’s birth half-sister, Anne, who was placed for adoption as a child but later reconnected with her birth family.)

Bird met the young Laci and Scott at a family wedding, which she described as “a little Hallmark-y.”

Related: Here Was Scott Peterson's Defense at His 2004 Murder Trial in Death of Pregnant Wife Laci

<p>David Paul Morris/Getty Images</p> A memorial is placed near where Laci Peterson and her unborn fetus were found dead, in a photograph dated April 19, 2003.

David Paul Morris/Getty Images

A memorial is placed near where Laci Peterson and her unborn fetus were found dead, in a photograph dated April 19, 2003.

Bird noted that the L.A. Innocence Project is known for working on cases of low-income defendants, and says for the organization taking on Scott's case is “huge.”

“I found it interesting that an organization as credible as the Innocence Project was getting involved,” Bird says. “There's a ton of people who are reaching out for help — the kind that get railroaded, and Scott just doesn't seem to fit.”

“Maybe that’s because I believe he’s guilty,” she adds. “Maybe that’s the problem.”

For more People news, make sure to sign up for our newsletter!

Read the original article on People.