Hilton Botha, lead detective in Oscar Pistorius case, faces his own attempted murder charges

Yahoo Sports

Oscar Pistorius' murder case took a sensational twist Thursday when it was revealed that the chief investigator who analyzed the scene of Reeva Steenkamp's fatal shooting faces seven counts of attempted murder charges himself.

Hilton Botha, whose stumbling and at times incoherent evidence on day two of Pistorius' bail hearing gave the Blade Runner's case a serious boost, was allegedly one of three drunk police officers who opened fire on a mini-bus taxi full of passengers in 2011, according to South Africa's Eyewitness News.

According to Botha, the shooting took place as part of the investigation into the murder of Denise Stratford, a Girl Scout leader whose body was discovered stuffed into a drain in 2011. Botha and colleagues were tracking the suspect and as part of their inquiries fired at the mini-bus when it failed to pull over when requested.

Botha was arrested at the time due to the charges, which were subsequently dropped, before it emerged Thursday that they had been reinstated.

"There was a decision taken by the director of public prosecution's office to charge the members, each one of them, with seven counts of attempted murder," said police spokesman Neville Malila. "That was the number of people that were in the taxi."

View photo


Hilton Botha sits inside the court witness box during the Oscar Pistorius bail hearing. (AP)

Botha denied he was drunk during the alleged incident and told South African legal journalist Karyn Maughan on Thursday morning that the reinstatement of the charge is "beyond my comprehension."

"I can only think it is linked to my work on the Oscar Pistorius case," he said.

In a statement, however, the South African National Prosecuting Authority revealed the murder charge against Botha was reinstated before the Pistorius incident, reportedly as early as Feb. 4. Botha insisted to the media that he only learned of the reinstatement after the Valentine's Day killing of Steenkamp. According to Malila, Botha is scheduled to appear in court in May to face the charges.

[Related: Without bail, Pistorius faces time in brutal South African prison]

Thursday, Botha was taken off the Pistorius case.

"If we have an investigating officer that is facing such serious charges, it cannot happen that he continues with this case," an NPA spokesperson said.

Botha had become one of the major characters in the Pistorius case as it has unfolded with a bail hearing that stretched into a third day and resembled a mini-trial with detailed evidence being given from both sides.

The reason for the elongated hearing is a product of both the vagaries of the South African legal system and the desire of both the prosecution and defense to gain a positive result on bail.

During his testimony Wednesday, Botha unraveled under cross-examination from defense attorney Barry Roux, admitting that he couldn't find anything to contradict Pistorius' claim that he mistook Steenkamp for an intruder. Botha also opened himself to allegations he had contaminated the crime scene by revealing he had not worn protective shoes and was forced to admit one of his witnesses, a neighbor, was more than a quarter mile away from the scene.

Yet his blundering under oath was nothing compared to the damage that Thursday's bombshell may have done to the case, with Botha's credibility as an investigator pivotal.

Alex Eliseev, the Eyewitness News journalist who broke the Botha story, told 567 The Cape radio on Thursday that he contacted Botha following the publication of the report and that the senior policeman with 24 years of experience insisted the allegations against him were false.

"[Botha] says he was involved in an absolutely legitimate case," Eliseev said. "He says they tried to pull over the taxi, they were not drunk, they shot at the wheels and tried to get it to stop. He thought the case had been withdrawn."

The bail hearing continues Thursday.

NASCAR video from Yahoo! Sports:

Other popular content on Yahoo! Sports:
Rockets trade for fifth overall pick in the 2012 draft
Kansas guard redeems himself for poor game with shot to beat Oklahoma State
Danica Patrick flying high personally and professionally

View Comments (2240)
  • Djokovic's right arm troubles him at US Open; Keys wins

    Djokovic's right arm troubles him at US Open; Keys wins

    Novak Djokovic double-faulted, then shook his right arm and grimaced. Seconds later Monday night, a weak serve produced a wince from the U.S. Open's defending champion, then was followed by a missed forehand that gave away a set - the first set … More »

    AP - Sports - 1 hour 23 minutes ago
  • The Latest: Keys rallies for late-night win at US Open

    The Latest: Keys rallies for late-night win at US Open

    Eighth-seeded Madison Keys rallied from down a set and a break to outlast fellow American Alison Riske in a first-round U.S. Open match that ended at 1:48 a.m. Tuesday morning. Keys, who took a medical timeout in the second set to have a trainer … More »

    AP - Sports - 1 hour 26 minutes ago
  • Djokovic into second round but new concerns over fitness

    Djokovic into second round but new concerns over fitness

    By Steve Keating NEW YORK (Reuters) - Novak Djokovic opened defense of his U.S. Open title with a labored 6-3 5-7 6-2 6-1 win over Poland's Jerzy Janowicz on Monday that brought new concerns about the world number one's fitness. After a sizzling … More »

    Reuters - 3 hours ago
  • Serena's US Open begins with tough matchup vs Makarova

    Serena's US Open begins with tough matchup vs Makarova

    Serena Williams hadn't played much coming into the Grand Slam tournament. The victory fueled Makarova's surge up the rankings, and by the 2014 U.S. Open, she was in the top 20 and facing the American in the semifinals. In her last outing, a … More »

    AP - Sports - 3 hours ago
  • Olympic gold medalist Monica Puig out in US Open 1st round

    Olympic gold medalist Monica Puig out in US Open 1st round

    Sure, Monica Puig would have loved another week between the Olympics and the U.S. Open to ''come down from the high'' of becoming Puerto Rico's first gold medalist. Puig realizes that if she wants to climb back to those heights, she'll need to … More »

    AP - Sports - 6 hours ago