What's Buzzing:

NFL owner admits that the confidence in replacement officials is eroding

Yahoo Sports

Let me start off by admitting I was shortsighted about one problem with the NFL's replacement refs: Their decided lack of experience with the procedures of running a game are so bad that it's affecting everyone's confidence.

And by everyone, I mean fans, coaches, players and at least one owner who spoke Tuesday morning on the condition of anonymity.

View gallery


Broncos head coach John Fox (L) speaks to officials during the first half of Monday night's game. (AP)

"I'm not comfortable with what I saw last night," the owner said after watching the Atlanta Falcons' 27-21 victory over the Denver Broncos. "It wasn't professional. It wasn't our standards of what a game is supposed to look like … it's not the calls themselves and it's not player safety. That's a silly argument.

"It's the competence and control of the game officials. The officials are supposed to be in control. They're supposed to run the game. Last night after the fumble [by Denver in the first quarter], they didn't have control. They looked like … I don't want to say what they looked like."

Last night's poorly run game capped a long Week 2 in which two conflict-of-interest issues further eroded the confidence in the replacement refs.

[More: Peyton Manning says lack of arm strength not to blame for interceptions]

The NFL revealed in a memo last week that one official in the Week 1 Seattle-Arizona game had worked some practices and had been paid in the offseason by the Seahawks. Another ref was yanked from the New Orleans-Carolina game on Sunday morning when it was discovered he is a diehard Saints fan.

In a third matter, Philadelphia Eagles running back LeSean McCoy claimed that a ref told him Sunday that he had McCoy on his fantasy team. However, McCoy later said he was joking.

Oy vey. While neither of these first two issues may have ultimately determined the outcome of a game, but that's not the point. Power is often about appearance, not reality.

That was the essence of the one owner's sentiments. It's also what Washington Redskins coach Mike Shanahan was hinting at Sunday after his team lost to the St. Louis Rams. Shanahan said the refs were dangerously close to "losing control of the game."

On Monday night, the refs did lose control of the game in the first quarter when they couldn't keep control of a scrum after a fumble. The six-minute delay in action made the refs look helpless. They confirmed that again later in the first half when they marched off 11 yards on a defensive holding call that was supposed to be only five yards.

Year Penalties per game Player-safety related penalties Passing game penalties Instant replay reviews Overturned Percentage
2011 15.2 74 48 46 21 45.7
2012 14.7 75 51 62 23 37.1
Again, this is not about the actual calls. Yes, there have been plenty of mistakes in that regard. The Ravens-Eagles game featured a missed pass interference call. In New England's loss to the Cardinals, the Patriots had a last-minute touchdown called back because of a highly questionable holding call against tight end Rob Gronkowski.

But questionable calls happen all the time, whether they are replacement refs or the regular guys.

The real issue is how the game is handled. Right now, there are critical stoppages in play where everyone is staring at the officials. The question running through everybody's minds (if not over their lips) is simply, "Do these guys know what they're doing?"

[More: Greg Schiano sparks great debate over unwritten rules in sports]

That's not just bad, it's unacceptable. The one owner wouldn't quite go that far, but it wouldn't take much more to push him over that edge.

View gallery


LeSean McCoy celebrates his TD in the Eagles' won over the Ravens. (Getty)

"I know that we feel good about the offer we've made to the officials, but we can't have another week like this if we don't settle soon," the owner said. "The amount of money we're talking about is not worth the embarrassment. This is our product."

That comment is the first major crack in the wall of solidarity the owners have had as they hold the line on salaries for officials. To an extent, both the NFL and the NFL Referees Association are right in how they are handling this negotiation.

The NFL believes, not wrongly, that the salary offer it has made is adequate. "We are ready to negotiate at any time," NFL spokesman Greg Aiello wrote in an email to Yahoo! Sports."

Last season, the average NFL official made $149,000 and the league is offering roughly a five percent increase. There are other issues in play, such as the league's desire to change the pension plan to a 401K.

[More: Falcons' Michael Turner charged with DUI after MNF game ]

On the flipside, the NFLRA is perfectly within its rights to wait out the negotiation to get as much as it can. Currently, the difference amounts to roughly $1 million per year as part of a 10-year deal. In the grand scheme of the NFL business, that doesn't seem like much.

Then again, it's always easy to spend somebody else's money. Bottom line, it's a negotiation and the two sides will figure it out.

In the meantime, you can't help but wonder if the replacement refs are going to figure it out.

Other popular content on the Yahoo! network:
Golden Tate hopes to avoid fine for his block on Sean Lee
Bears defender D.J. Moore goes off on Jay Cutler
Week 2 NFL Sunday winners/losers
Y! News: Boy Scouts' secret files hid sex abuse allegations, newspaper reports

  • Twins end Keuchel's 17-game home win streak, beat Astros 6-2

    Twins end Keuchel's 17-game home win streak, beat Astros 6-2

    The Minnesota Twins were the first team in over a year and a half to beat Dallas Keuchel in Houston, and they did it with patience. Brian Dozier broke out of a slump with three hits and the Twins snapped Keuchel's 17-game home winning streak with a … More »

    AP - Sports - 6 minutes ago
  • Thunder hold on beat Spurs 98-97, even series at 1-1

    Thunder hold on beat Spurs 98-97, even series at 1-1

    Russell Westbrook had 29 points and 10 assists, and the Oklahoma City Thunder held on to beat San Antonio 98-97 on Monday night, evening the series at one game apiece when the Spurs failed to score on a wild sequence in the final seconds. Kevin … More »

    AP - Sports - 20 minutes ago
  • Gonzalez, Nationals blank Royals 2-0 to win 4th straight

    Gonzalez, Nationals blank Royals 2-0 to win 4th straight

    In the meantime, the Nationals manager is content to rely on his pitching to win games. Ryan Zimmerman and Daniel Murphy drove in the only runs in the first inning. Gonzalez (2-1) went just six, but he scattered four hits and a pair of walks in … More »

    AP - Sports - 23 minutes ago
  • Wainwright has 1 of Cards' 5 HRs in win

    Wainwright has 1 of Cards' 5 HRs in win

    Adam Wainwright knew his mammoth home run changed the complexion of Monday night's game. ''Right now, it's all about wins for me,'' Wainwright said. Wainwright pitched six innings and hit a three-run home run - the first of five for St. Louis - as … More »

    AP - Sports - 31 minutes ago
  • Penguins top Capitals 3-2 to take 2-1 series lead

    Penguins top Capitals 3-2 to take 2-1 series lead

    Outhit, outshot and largely outplayed, Pittsburgh grabbed control of its Eastern Conference semifinal against Washington anyway. Matt Murray made 47 stops and the Penguins did just enough counterpunching to edge the Capitals 3-2 on Monday night for … More »

    AP - Sports - 32 minutes ago