NFL needs to publicly release evidence of players' bounty involvement if it exists

Michael Silver
Yahoo Sports

View gallery

.

Jonathan Vilma (top) has been suspended for the entire 2012 season. (US Presswire)

When the Gregg Williams audio tape surfaced last month, it elevated the New Orleans Saints' bounty scandal to a new level of public awareness and lowered the cries of unduly harsh punishment to a murmur.

Sean Pamphilon, the filmmaker who released the recording of the ex-Saints defensive coordinator's speech the night before the team's January playoff defeat to the San Francisco 49ers, called it a "smoking gun," but really, it was more than that: Williams' words took people inside a culture of amplified rhetoric and calls for violence and eliminated any doubt that a line had been crossed.

As a result, the NFL-imposed suspension of Williams – and those of Saints coach Sean Payton, assistant head coach Joe Vitt and general manager Mickey Loomis – became very difficult to dispute. Anyone in a position of authority who tolerated or perpetuated such an environment, let alone who lied to league officials and ignored their directives, was clearly culpable and, for want of a better term, cruisin' for a bruisin' from commissioner Roger Goodell.

[ Dan Wetzel: New Orleans Saints get off relatively light with player bounty suspensions ]

Yet Wednesday's suspensions of current New Orleans defenders Jonathan Vilma and Will Smith, and former Saints Scott Fujita (now with the Cleveland Browns) and Anthony Hargrove (now with the Green Bay Packers), don't rise to that standard. As a result, I can understand why the punished players, many of their peers, NFL Players Association executives and Saints fans are frustrated by the severity of the penalties.

Unless and until the NFL produces unassailable evidence that these men actively participated in a pay-for-injure operation that caused tangible consequences to Saints opponents – or Pamphilon shares another tape implicating the men in question – I'll be somewhat skeptical about the depth of their involvement.

Or, to borrow from an iconic (if fictional) Arizona Cardinals wideout, Show me the money.

"If you have actual evidence of money changing hands and guys actually getting injured – if that exists – then all the suspensions are justified," Saints linebacker Scott Shanle told me Wednesday afternoon. "I think they have nothing to show. If you have evidence to show, at this point, wouldn't you show it? I don't think they have anything."

Shanle, a ninth-year veteran not known for making controversial public statements, may sound to some like a frustrated and semi-delusional player sticking up for his friends, but I wouldn't be so quick to marginalize him. For one thing, I've talked to numerous players on the Saints, and with other organizations, who basically share his sentiments.

[ Related: Jonathan Vilma found out about his year-long suspension from 'SportsCenter' ]

I've also had conversations with several knowledgeable sources who question the way the league conducted its investigation, including one person interviewed by an NFL security official before the league released its report. I've heard stories of disingenuous promises and of investigators who actively sought only information that they deemed incriminating while ignoring any evidence to the contrary.

Obviously, the people with whom I've spoken have an interest in portraying the penalties as unjust, and I'm certainly not in position to judge the legitimacy of the NFL's investigation. The findings could be airtight, paper-thin or somewhere in between.

The league issued a statement Wednesday which declared that "the evidence supporting today's disciplinary decisions is based on extensive documentation and interviews with multiple sources. The information was developed by NFL Security, working with independent forensic analysts, and the disciplinary decisions are each based on evidence that has been independently corroborated by multiple sources."

On Thursday the league trotted out Mary Jo White, a former prosecutor retained by the league to provide an "independent review" of the evidence, to speak to reporters, and she described the investigation as "thorough, fair and robust."

Conversely, Vilma and Smith issued public statements strongly proclaiming their innocence, while sources close to Fujita have done the same to me in prior conversations. (Fujita acknowledged in March to Sports Illustrated's Peter King that he made individual payments to teammates for performance-related bonuses such as interceptions and fumble recoveries.) "Scott Fujita never put up any money to injure anybody," Shanle insisted on Wednesday. "It didn't happen."

[MLB Full Count: Watch live look-ins and highlights for free all season long]

Hargrove, according to the NFL's statement and White's conversation with reporters, provided a signed declaration to the league which acknowledged the existence of a bounty program and his role in it. It is believed that Hargrove's declaration is the key to the NFL's case – but, because the league has not released it to the suspended players or to the public, none of us can be sure what was said and how credible it is.

Given that the players are planning, with the assistance of the NFLPA, to appeal to Goodell (good luck with that) – and reportedly may initiate legal challenges in federal court – the league may eventually have to show its hand. Until then, the commissioner is essentially saying, "They're guilty – take my word for it."

To me, that's not good enough, for a number of reasons:

We have yet to be presented with evidence of an obvious instance of a Saints opponent during the 2009, '10 or '11 seasons sustaining an injury from an unsportsmanlike or inordinately vicious hit – or of any failed attempt to inflict such an injury.

White isn't really independent, given that she was, you know, paid by the NFL for her services. Not surprisingly, the NFLPA's outside counsel, former prosecutor Richard Smith, had a much different assessment of the league's evidence and essentially dismissed her expertise on the issue. I'm not saying Smith's perspective carries any more authority than White's; I'm simply pointing out that there is a serious disagreement between the two sides on the most important issue – whether there's any real evidence of a pay-for-injure scheme.

Smith referenced Joe Hummel, the NFL's director of investigations, who abruptly resigned last Friday. Hummel, who was heavily involved in the bounty probe, left for what NFL spokesman Greg Aiello told profootballtalk.com was "a big career opportunity," but the timing of his departure certainly seemed fishy to men being investigated and those advocating for their interests.

These were not insignificant penalties. Middle linebacker Vilma, who was suspended for the entire 2012 season, is 30 years old with a history of knee problems. For him, this could amount to a career-ending punishment. Smith, who turns 31 in July, Hargrove, who'll be 29 the same month, and Fujita, 33, could face similarly daunting consequences after they return from their respective suspensions. In theory, Smith (four games), Hargrove (eight games) and Fujita (three games) could be waived by the Saints, Packers and Browns, respectively, after serving their suspensions if their employers are satisfied that the younger, cheaper stand-ins are performing capably. Subsequently, the punished players' affiliation with the bounty scandal could cause them to be blackballed by other teams as well.

For now, I'm trying very hard to be level-headed about all of this. While the NFL, which is facing numerous lawsuits from former players alleging that the league didn't do enough to prevent head trauma, has a vested economic interest in making a conspicuous statement demonstrating its support for player safety, I also believe that Goodell sincerely wants to address the issue.

My suspicion is that Wednesday's tragic death of future Hall of Fame linebacker Junior Seau, a suicide which may prove to be linked to the perilous effects of concussions, will increase the commissioner's sense of urgency to create a safer working environment.

[ Jason Cole: Lawsuit could allow Jonathan Vilma toplay in 2012 ]

So no, I don't think Goodell is a self-serving liar with a God complex. And when the league announced the suspensions of Payton, Loomis, Williams and Vitt, I laughed off the vitriolic reactions from Saints fans who screamed that the franchise was being singled out by a vindictive commissioner as being myopic and naïve.

View gallery

.

Roger Goodell (US Presswire)

Now, however, I'm having conversations with men who've actually played for the Saints during that span, and they're expressing similar sentiments. The absence of conspicuous evidence in the public realm makes me hesitant to dismiss them out of hand.

Is Goodell trying to stick it to the Saints?

"It's hard not to feel that way," Shanle said. "When you look at the severity of the suspensions and the lack of hard evidence, it's kind of tough to take. All there is is hearsay. And I feel badly for Jonathan Vilma and the other suspended players, because I feel like they were made an example of. And I just hate how it's almost like everybody is guilty until proven innocent."

And how does Shanle explain the Williams audio tape and the exhortations to injure opponents?

"Guys say crazy things all the time," Shanle said. "Gregg is one of the greatest motivators I've been around, but when he says things like 'kill the head and the body will die,' people don't take it literally. It was more of a device to get guys in a frame of mind to play a violent game at an insanely high level of intensity. It takes you to a place mentally that guys can't go otherwise.

"It's the same with Vilma. If he made statements like that, it was about trying to get guys to play harder and more together than they ever knew they could.

"Let's think about it rationally: If there's $500 in a kitty for taking out [an opponent], do you think I'm gonna intentionally injure someone and risk a $75,000 fine from the league for an illegal hit? It makes no sense."

It's a valid question, and I don't profess to have the answer. At this point, there are a lot of unanswered questions, and they're bringing out my inner Rod Tidwell.

If Goodell is devoted to improving and possibly saving the sport – and I believe he is – I'm ready to do my part for the cause. When it comes to cracking down on coaches whose instructions to injure opponents may or may not be taken literally, and when evidence of such is subsequently broadcast to the masses, the commissioner's swift and severe punishment makes a lot of sense.

So far, I'm not convinced that Vilma, Hargrove, Smith and Fujita's lengthy suspensions were similarly warranted. And before those players turn in their playbooks and fork over the cash, I'd feel a lot better if someone would show me the money.

Other popular content on the Yahoo! network:
Y! Autos: See the country’s fastest street cars hit 200 mph
Shine: The man dress: Coming to a guy near you?
Shine: The secret history of your 10 favorite toys
omg:! Carrie Underwood completely trusts NHL-player husband Mike Fisher

  • Red Wings' Henrik Zetterberg a game-time decision for Game 4 vs. Bruins

    DETROIT - The Red Wings could get a big boost in their playoff series against the Bruins if Henrik Zetterberg is able to return for Game 4 tonight. … More »

    The Canadian Press - 10 minutes ago
  • Lyoto "The Slacker" Machida works on his balance

    Lyoto "The Slacker" Machida works on his balance

    #1 UFC middleweight contender Lyoto Machida apparently likes to use a slackline to help him develop the balance he uses to sprawl and kick in the Octagon. … More »

    Cagewriter - 21 minutes ago
  • Bruins' Bergeron, Blackhawks' Toews, Kings' Kopitar are Selke finalists

    NEW YORK, N.Y. - Patrice Bergeron, Jonathan Toews and Anze Kopitar are the finalists for the NHL's Selke Trophy, awarded to the best defensive forward. … More »

    The Canadian Press - 23 minutes ago
  • Toronto Raptors star DeMar DeRozan shows he can rise to playoff occasion

    Toronto Raptors star DeMar DeRozan shows he can rise to playoff occasion

    TORONTO - After a wobbly playoff debut, Raptors star DeMar DeRozan returned to attack mode for Game 2 against the Brooklyn Nets. The 24-year-old Toronto guard had just 14 points in Game 1, with eight of those coming from the free throw line, in a … More »

    The Canadian Press - 26 minutes ago
  • Wiggins, Froome missing for Team Sky at Giro

    This year's Giro d'Italia will be missing two of cycling's biggest names after Bradley Wiggins and Chris Froome, the last two winners of the Tour de France, were left out of Team Sky's nine-man lineup for the May 9-June 1 race. Wiggins is competing … More »

    AP - Sports - 27 minutes ago
  • Conn Smythe Watch: Who are the leaders for playoff MVP?

    Conn Smythe Watch: Who are the leaders for playoff MVP?

    By popular demand, Puck Daddy takes its Conn Smythe Watch from the evening Three Stars to every morning of the postseason. Keep in mind that we factor in the probability of a long playoff run into these choices. Who are the current favorites for … More »

    Puck Daddy - 52 minutes ago
  • Battalion bask, and an Oil change for Reinhart? The coast-to-coast

    Combing all corners of the country and the blogosphere for your junior hockey headlines ... Chatravaganza at 12 p.m. ET/9 a.m. PT! WHL Terry Jones ponders whether the Edmonton Oilers should deal away their No. 2 overall pick to keep … Continue … More »

    Buzzing The Net - 52 minutes ago
  • Colabello' 4 RBIs power Twins past Rays 6-4 in 12

    Colabello' 4 RBIs power Twins past Rays 6-4 in 12

    ST. PETERSBURG, Fla. (AP) -- - Given an opportunity by the Twins, Chris Colabello is showing his gratitude by driving in runs at a record-setting pace. Colabello's four RBIs carried Minnesota to a 12-inning, 6-4 win over the Tampa Bay Rays on … More »

    AP - Sports - 1 hour 3 minutes ago
  • Sharapova to face Radwanska in quarters

    Sharapova to face Radwanska in quarters

    STUTTGART, Germany (AP) -- Defending champion Maria Sharapova defeated Anastasia Pavlyuchenkova 6-4, 6-3 on Thursday to set up a Porsche Grand Prix quarterfinal clash with top-seeded Agnieszka Radwanska. … More »

    AP - Sports - 1 hour 14 minutes ago
  • Marchand gets ball and then shoe stuck

    Marchand gets ball and then shoe stuck

    NHL Live goes to Overtime to watch Bruins forward Brad Marchand try to get his soccer ball and then his shoe unstuck from the rafters. … More »

    NHL Highlights - 1 hour 18 minutes ago
  • PG Conley wins NBA's sportsmanship award

    PG Conley wins NBA's sportsmanship award

    MEMPHIS, Tenn. (AP) -- Memphis Grizzlies guard Mike Conley has won the NBA's Joe Dumars Trophy for sportsmanship. … More »

    AP - Sports - 1 hour 20 minutes ago
  • Nishikori reaches quarters in Barcelona

    Nishikori reaches quarters in Barcelona

    BARCELONA, Spain (AP) -- Fourth-seeded Kei Nishikori reached the quarterfinals of the Barcelona Open by beating Andrey Golubev of Kazakhstan 6-0, 6-4 Thursday. … More »

    AP - Sports - 1 hour 21 minutes ago
  • NFL draft: Q&A with Colorado State C Weston Richburg

    NFL draft: Q&A with Colorado State C Weston Richburg

    After 50 college starts, Colorado State C Weston Richburg could be drafted as early as the second round in May. He took some time to talk to Shutdown Corner about growing up on a farm, breaking his snapping hand during a game, listening to metal and … More »

    Shutdown Corner - 1 hour 23 minutes ago
  • Heat 12-2 in playoffs when Bosh has 20

    Heat 12-2 in playoffs when Bosh has 20

    In Miami, it's called the Big Three for a reason. LeBron James was stellar for the Heat in Game 2 of their Eastern Conference first-round series against Charlotte, and Dwyane Wade helped save the game with a steal to deny the Bobcats a chance at … More »

    AP - Sports - 1 hour 29 minutes ago
  • Court tosses ex-Oklahoma State player's conviction

    Court tosses ex-Oklahoma State player's conviction

    Oklahoma's criminal appeals court has overturned the conviction of a former Oklahoma State basketball player accused of sexually assaulting two women at an off-campus party in 2010. The Court of Criminal Appeals on Tuesday reversed the conviction … More »

    AP - Sports - 1 hour 30 minutes ago
  • Puck Daddy Power Rankings: Repeat offenders, Lady Byng and overtime thrillers

    Puck Daddy Power Rankings: Repeat offenders, Lady Byng and overtime thrillers

    [Author's note: Power rankings are usually three things: Bad, wrong, and boring. You typically know just as well as the authors which teams won what games against who and what it all means, so our moving the Red Wings up four spots or whatever … More »

    Puck Daddy - 2 hours 3 minutes ago
  • F1 boss Bernie Ecclestone rejects bribery charges, says he was blackmailed as trial opens

    F1 boss Bernie Ecclestone rejects bribery charges, says he was blackmailed as trial opens

    MUNICH - Formula One boss Bernie Ecclestone rejected accusations of bribery as he went on trial Thursday in a case that could threaten his grip on the sport, telling a Munich court that he was blackmailed by a German banker who received a disputed … More »

    The Canadian Press - 2 hours 4 minutes ago
  • F1 boss Bernie Ecclestone rejects bribery charges

    F1 boss Bernie Ecclestone rejects bribery charges

    Formula One boss Bernie Ecclestone rejected accusations of bribery as he went on trial Thursday in a case that could threaten his grip on the sport, telling a Munich court that he was blackmailed by a German banker who received a disputed $44 … More »

    AP - Sports - 2 hours 5 minutes ago
  • Pineda says he'll learn from ejection for pine tar

    Pineda says he'll learn from ejection for pine tar

    The pine tar glistened on Michael Pineda's neck, improving his grip and inviting trouble. The Yankees' right-hander spoke quietly after being ejected in the second inning of the Red Sox' 5-1 win over New York on Wednesday night. And less than two … More »

    AP - Sports - 2 hours 23 minutes ago
  • Phelps launches comeback in 100m fly

    Phelps launches comeback in 100m fly

    Returning to swimming after a 20-month retirement, Michael Phelps is easing back into the sport he once dominated by racing one of his best events. The 18-time Olympic gold medalist will swim the 100-meter butterfly at the Arena Grand Prix on … More »

    AP - Sports - 2 hours 24 minutes ago
  • Quiros, Dyson share lead at China Open

    Quiros, Dyson share lead at China Open

    Alvaro Quiros and Simon Dyson each shot a 5-under 67 to share the lead after the first round of the China Open on Thursday. The pair were a stroke ahead of a group of six golfers that included defending champion Brett Rumford of Australia and … More »

    AP - Sports - 2 hours 30 minutes ago
  • Everest climbing season in disarray after deaths

    Nepal's attempts to salvage the Mount Everest climbing season fell flat Thursday as major expedition companies canceled their climbs and many Sherpas quit the mountain after an avalanche killed 16 of their fellow guides last week. While the season … More »

    AP - Sports - 2 hours 40 minutes ago
  • Comcast's Fandango ticket service buys MovieClips

    (Reuters) - Fandango, a movie ticketing service owned by cable company Comcast Corp, is buying MovieClips from Zefr Inc to boost its film-related content. MovieClips, launched in 2009, licenses movie scenes from various studios, puts them up on … More »

    Reuters - 3 hours ago
  • No rest for weary Atletico as Valencia trip looms

    No rest for weary Atletico as Valencia trip looms

    By Tim Hanlon BARCELONA, April 24 (Reuters) - Atletico Madrid must put their Champions League ambitions to one side when they look to maintain their surprise La Liga title surge in a tough trip to Valencia on Sunday. They are on the verge of … More »

    Reuters - 3 hours ago
  • Dyson enjoys happy return to China, shares lead with Quiros

    (Reuters) - Englishman Simon Dyson, who was handed a suspended two-month ban for cheating in December, fired a five-under-par 67 to grab a share of the first round lead at the European Tour's China Open on Thursday. The Englishman fired six birdies … More »

    Reuters - 3 hours ago
  • Formula One boss denies bribery at German trial

    Formula One boss denies bribery at German trial

    By Keith Weir MUNICH Germany (Reuters) - Formula One chief executive Bernie Ecclestone denied bribery allegations on Thursday when he went on trial in Germany in a case that threatens to break the Briton's decades-long dominance of the motor sport. … More »

    Reuters - 3 hours ago
  • Ajax extend ban on fans travelling to Feyenoord games

    REUTERS - Ajax Amsterdam have extended the ban on their fans attending away league games against arch-rivals Feyenoord in Rotterdam following the riotous behaviour of supporters in Sunday's Dutch Cup final. It ends hopes that a five-year suspension … More »

    Reuters - 3 hours ago
  • Guan, 15, getting used to spotlight

    One year after his stunning debut at the Masters, Chinese 15-year-old golfer Guan Tianlang is growing accustomed to being in the spotlight. The teenager's star has risen quickly in China since his breakthrough at Augusta National, where at the age … More »

    AP - Sports - 3 hours ago
  • Bolton Wanderers to rename the Reebok stadium

    (Reuters) - Bolton Wanderers will change the name of their Reebok stadium to the Macron from July as part of a new deal between the Championship club and an Italian sportswear manufacturer. It will be the first change of name for the second tier … More »

    Reuters - 3 hours ago
  • Protesters rally against FIFA president Blatter

    A handful of protesters holding banners and placards demonstrated peacefully Thursday at an event with FIFA president Sepp Blatter to highlight the plight of migrant workers building stadiums in Qatar for the 2022 World Cup. Blatter was a guest at … More »

    AP - Sports - 3 hours ago
  • Golf-Dyson enjoys happy return to China, shares lead with Quiros

    Englishman Simon Dyson, who was handed a suspended two-month ban for cheating in December, fired a five-under-par 67 to grab a share of the first round lead at the European Tour's China Open on Thursday. The Englishman fired six birdies and a lone … More »

    Reuters - 4 hours ago
  • Postgame: Dirk Nowitzki

    Postgame: Dirk Nowitzki

    Dirk Nowitzki addresses the media following the Game 2 win over the Spurs. … More »

    NBA.com - 4 hours ago
  • Hanyu determined to build on success of Sochi

    Hanyu determined to build on success of Sochi

    Yuzuru Hanyu has barely had time to dwell on the Olympic and world titles he won in the first quarter of 2014, yet he's already thinking about how to improve for next season. Hanyu became the first Japanese man to claim Olympic gold in figure … More »

    AP - Sports - 4 hours ago
  • More teams withdraw, Nepal's Everest season in jeopardy

    By Gopal Sharma KATHMANDU (Reuters) - Several foreign climbing expeditions have called off attempts to scale Everest following an avalanche that killed at least 13 local guides, meaning Nepal faces an entire season without a single ascent of the … More »

    Reuters - 4 hours ago
  • No clubs facing FFP European expulsion - Platini

    No clubs facing FFP European expulsion - Platini

    No clubs can expect to be expelled from European competition next season for breaking financial fair play rules, UEFA president Michel Platini said in an interview on Thursday. UEFA's Financial Fair Play (FFP) policy, designed to stop clubs … More »

    Reuters - 4 hours ago
  • No clubs facing European expulsion - Platini

    No clubs facing European expulsion - Platini

    No clubs will be kicked out of European competition next season for breaking financial fair play rules, UEFA president Michel Platini said in an interview on Thursday. UEFA's financial fair play (FFP) policy, designed to stop clubs spending more … More »

    Reuters - 5 hours ago
  • Fast-breaking Real home in on elusive 10th European crown

    Fast-breaking Real home in on elusive 10th European crown

    By Tim Hanlon BARCELONA (Reuters) - Real Madrid took a step closer to an elusive 10th European Cup with a 1-0 home win over Bayern Munich on Wednesday and the Spanish side will hope to finish off the job in Germany having shown how effective they … More »

    Reuters - 5 hours ago
  • Schalke aiming to seal Champions League spot

    By Karolos Grohmann REUTERS - Schalke 04's season could have a happy ending at home to Borussia Moenchengladbach on Sunday when they hope to claim a Champions League spot after a rollercoaster campaign punctuated by injury problems. Schalke, who … More »

    Reuters - 6 hours ago
  • Sturridge hopeful of returning against Chelsea

    Sturridge hopeful of returning against Chelsea

    REUTERS - Liverpool striker Daniel Sturridge is optimistic of returning from injury for the key clash against former team mates and title rivals Chelsea at Anfield on Sunday in a boost for the Premier League leaders. "Hopefully this weekend I'll be … More »

    Reuters - 6 hours ago
  • Confident Bayern promise home improvements against Real

    Confident Bayern promise home improvements against Real

    Holders Bayern Munich promised a sharp improvement when they host Real Madrid in the second leg of their Champions League semi-final after failing to convert the lion's share of possession into goals in a 1-0 defeat in Spain on Wednesday. Bayern … More »

    Reuters - 6 hours ago