Mike Trout vs. Bryce Harper: Fellow All-Stars are asked to choose their preferred rookie phenom

Jeff Passan
Yahoo Sports

KANSAS CITY, Mo. – In the annals of great battles, Harper vs. Trout may not stand the test of time like Lincoln vs. Douglas or be as sadly one-sided as Robinson Cano vs. Royals fans. Yet it's the most simplistically complex question in sports, the choice between a power-hitting, pressure-swatting man-child and a kid who's a double-barreled Leatherman: the pocket-sized implement overflowing with tools and the guy in center field using a hide glove to rob batters simultaneously of their hits and self-worth.

View gallery

.

Bryce Harper reached the break with a seven-game hit streak. (AP)

They ask it everywhere, too. At bars. On message boards. Throughout the stands. And in clubhouses. Especially in clubhouses. All 30 have, at one point or another, housed the debate: Who would you take first, Bryce Harper or Mike Trout?

Sometimes it evolves into a question of why as well, though brevity often suffices within the clubhouse walls. An answer is an answer, and it's good enough, even if it might pique the world's curiosity on what the minds inside locker rooms think about one of their own.

Perhaps the greatest testament to their instantaneous stardom is that in this All-Star game in which neither Harper nor Trout will start – because not only were they not on the All-Star ballot, they weren't even on their teams' opening-day rosters – they are the chief attraction. It's about the Washington Nationals' 19-year-old wunderkind and the Los Angeles Angels' 20-year-old MVP candidate. It's about a new generation of baseball stars whose similarities may end at the respect they've engendered among their peers, Trout through his quiet brilliance and Harper through sheer force of persona.

So, who you got?

"That question right there is the one every clubhouse argues," San Diego closer Huston Street says. "You've got American League, National League. West Coast and East Coast. Speed and power."

[Also: Prince Fielder showcases power in winning second Home Run Derby]

It is different than the Mantle vs. Mays debate that persisted throughout the 1950s and well into the '60s. Mickey Mantle and Willie Mays were similar players. Harper vs. Trout is more Tupac vs. Biggie, a contrast of size, of strength, of style, similar only in an unmistakable brilliance.

"I can't answer it," Chipper Jones says, and he's not the only one. Of the 15 players to whom Yahoo! Sports posed the Harper-vs.-Trout question, nearly half copped out without a choice.

Jones, however, mulled the idea for a few seconds. If he was going to waffle, he wanted to at least add some chocolate chips.

"I love Mike Trout," Jones says. "But I have a man-crush on Bryce Harper."


Nobody else to this point has encapsulated the Harper-Trout debate in such perfect fashion. Chipper Jones is right: It's easy to admire Mike Trout, and it's just as easy to swoon over Bryce Harper. Every baseball fan appreciates both. The level of adoration depends more on the body part with which you do your thinking: the head or the heart.

You love Mike Trout with your head. You love his athleticism, 6-foot-1 and 220 pounds of muscle wound with the precision of a Swiss timepiece. You love how he makes the best catch of the first half look so ordinary. You love his speed, you love his bat, you love his power. You don't love his arm, but that's OK, because if you love with your head, you see the flaws in a man and accept him for what he is.

You love Bryce Harper with your heart. Your heart sees through prescription glasses. Blemishes don't exist. Harper's arrogance is endearing, his long swing fixable, his over-aggression something out of which he'll grow. He hustles like Larry Flynt, hits balls a mile, parlays his different sort of athleticism – a longer, lither kind – into playing outfield like a natural despite having spent all of a season and a half there. He'll hit for average. He'll play Gold Glove defense. The heart wants.

Harper is the id, Trout the ego and their peers tried to play the super-ego, balancing the two, arduous though the task was. We are, after all, talking about two players who still can't even drink legally.


Bryce Harper's story makes him more acceptable. Sports Illustrated introduced him to the country as a Sweet 16 present, boasting of his 500-foot home run power, and then he dropped out of his school to play junior college ball, where he broke all kinds of records, which preceded Washington taking him with the top selection and guaranteeing him nearly $10 million, followed by a rapid ascent that will see him spend his entire age-19 season in the major leagues.

View gallery

.

Mike Trout and Bryce Harper at Monday workouts in Kansas City. (US Presswire)

And he's normal. Excuse the occasional fit of immaturity – slamming a bat against the wall in frustration and getting bloodied by the richochet, say – and recognize the list of athletes on whom the world was thrust as a teenager. Tiger Woods. LeBron James. Bryce Harper.

"You give me all that talent and put me on the cover at 16, I'm gonna be one of the biggest pricks ever," Atlanta second baseman Dan Uggla says. "Knowing I'm gonna be the first pick in a year and in the big leagues at 19. I think he has handled it unbelievably. I don't know how anybody can say they'd act if they got that much attention and was that talented."

Among the most amazing things about Harper is just how quickly he has sold his peers on his game. His hustle isn't false. His retorts are tinged with just the sort of obnoxiousness that goes over well in a baseball clubhouse; the commingling of "clown question" and "bro" was met with smirking approval. When Philadelphia starter Cole Hamels hit Harper with a pitch on purpose in early May, Harper embarrassed him by stealing home that same inning.

On the player ballot for the All-Star team, Hamels voted for Harper.

"You look into his eyes and see something there," Street says. "The It Factor that so few big leaguers carry. He has that ability. And that's why I'd pick Bryce: because he came up with so much of the fanfare, came up with so much of the expectations, because he's done it in the nation's capital. He has succeeded with all that, and with a relative amount of humility. He's got his flair. But good for him."

[Also: Tony La Russa goes with Matt Cain as NL starter over R.A. Dickey]

While Harper's admirers lauded his success vis-à-vis his history, the lovefest for Trout had everything to do with his first half, in which, despite missing nearly the first month, he made a compelling case for the AL MVP. He leads the league with a .341 batting average and 26 steals. His .959 OPS ranks behind only Josh Hamilton, David Ortiz and teammate Mark Trumbo, none of whom can match his value patrolling center field.

The greatest thing anyone can say about Mike Trout is that they have nothing bad to say about him. If Harper has swag, Trout has presence, a buttoned-down version, not bereft of charisma but with it on mute. His love emanates as much from feat as aura.

"It's like LeBron vs. Kobe," New York Yankees pitcher CC Sabathia says. "I've seen Mike Trout hit a triple down the third-base line. That's impressive. I might go with him because of the speed."

Yes, there is the speed, pure and natural, not Billy Hamilton fast but close. Trout disrupts. He annoys. The mere knowledge that he's standing on first base disassociates a pitcher from his standard mindset. Keeping him close and sacrificing stuff with a slide step and … dammit, he's just 20 years old, so it's not like he's slowing down anytime soon.

View gallery

.

Matt Holliday went to bat for Trout without hesitation. (Getty Images)

"Trout," says St. Louis outfielder Matt Holliday, the only of the 15 players to answer without a hedge or at least a pause. He seemed such a likely candidate to go in the other direction, too, because Holliday hits for power and surely appreciates how, in a depressed run-scoring environment, power remains the game's greatest premium. There are but a handful of hitters with Harper's raw power. Seven of his eight home runs have traveled at least 406 feet. Scouts and executives are almost universal in their belief he'll soon hit 40 a year.

"It's easy to say he's going to hit 40 home runs," Holliday says. "Hitting 40 home runs in the big leagues is not easy."

Very easy was the tack taken by seven players when given the Harper-or-Trout ultimatum. "Both," conceded the indecisive and inoffensive. One pitcher didn't want to aggrieve the hitter in his league he'd have to face. Another was truly torn, almost painfully so, to the point he was offered "both" as an answer just to put him out of his misery.

Turns out there was a time when they were together. During the 2010 Arizona Fall League, for the game's most advanced prospects, Trout and Harper patrolled the Scottsdale Scorpions outfield together. The team finished 14-22. That mattered not. Mike Trout led off. Bryce Harper batted second or third. The prospect world salivated at the very sight of these two teenagers, knowing they were going to be so very much more.


Turns out there were two more players we asked to answer the Harper-vs.-Trout question: Bryce Harper and Mike Trout.

Trout, as he is wont to do, was short with his answer: "Obviously, I'm gonna pick myself." Maybe it was obvious. Athletes do adore themselves.

[ Tim Brown: Cole Hamels headlines what could be a hot trade market]

It took some prodding for Harper to make his selection. He didn't want to answer the question, perhaps for fear of sounding too arrogant, perhaps because to his ears it had a tinge of Bozo. When informed Trout had chosen himself, Harper didn't hesitate.

"I'm taking myself, too," Harper says. "I come into this game and I play it hard. I play it the right way."

The peers were close to an even split. They leaned 5-3 Trout, mostly along league lines. The vote was unscientific, of course, the sample size too small to determine anything but the sort of feel people in baseball have for two stars whose fates are tied together by more than the cosmos.

View gallery

.

Bryce Harper with fellow All-Stars Carlos Ruiz and Pablo Sandoval. (US Presswire)

It was a coincidence that on the day Trout rejoined the Angels, April 27, the Nationals announced Harper was being called up. It's not coincidence that they're thriving. While there is no certainty with prospects, transcendent talent rarely fails to disappoint.

The only harm here is anointing them so soon, and it's not a judgment as much as an assessment. Health permitting, Bryce Harper and Mike Trout will play long and vibrant careers. They'll be linked because of who they are and what they are and how they did, even if Harper is technically a year younger and a better comparison to him production-wise will be 2013 to Trout's 2012. It doesn't quite work that way.

"It's gonna be Mike Trout this, Bryce that," Trout says, and he is learning quickly the circus into which his life is turning. Mike Trout, son of schoolteachers, humble Jersey boy drafted 26th overall in the scouting whiff of the century, is one of baseball's best players. And Bryce Harper, son of an iron worker, brash Vegas kid paid more than any high schooler ever, is just the same.

Turns out there is a clear winner in Harper vs. Trout.

Everyone.

Other popular content on Yahoo! Sports:
Pat Forde: NCAA needs to leave Penn State situation for the courts
Adrian Wojnarowski: Nets working on complex deal to get Dwight Howard
Michael Phelps discusses his lack of motivation following 2008 Olympics

  • When Bosh steps up, Heat reap benefits

    When Bosh steps up, Heat reap benefits

    In Miami, it's called the Big Three for a reason. LeBron James was stellar for the Heat in Game 2 of their Eastern Conference first-round series against Charlotte, and Dwyane Wade helped save the game with a steal to deny the Bobcats a chance at … More »

    AP - Sports - 7 minutes ago
  • Court tosses ex-Oklahoma State player's conviction

    Court tosses ex-Oklahoma State player's conviction

    Oklahoma's criminal appeals court has overturned the conviction of a former Oklahoma State basketball player accused of sexually assaulting two women at an off-campus party in 2010. The Court of Criminal Appeals on Tuesday reversed the conviction … More »

    AP - Sports - 8 minutes ago
  • Nishikori reaches quarterfinals at Barcelona Open

    Nishikori reaches quarterfinals at Barcelona Open

    BARCELONA, Spain (AP) -- Fourth-seeded Kei Nishikori reached the quarterfinals of the Barcelona Open by beating Andrey Golubev of Kazakhstan 6-0, 6-4 Thursday. … More »

    AP - Sports - 2 minutes 36 seconds ago
  • Puck Daddy Power Rankings: Repeat offenders, Lady Byng and overtime thrillers

    Puck Daddy Power Rankings: Repeat offenders, Lady Byng and overtime thrillers

    [Author's note: Power rankings are usually three things: Bad, wrong, and boring. You typically know just as well as the authors which teams won what games against who and what it all means, so our moving the Red Wings up four spots or whatever … More »

    Puck Daddy - 42 minutes ago
  • F1 boss Bernie Ecclestone rejects bribery charges, says he was blackmailed as trial opens

    F1 boss Bernie Ecclestone rejects bribery charges, says he was blackmailed as trial opens

    MUNICH - Formula One boss Bernie Ecclestone rejected accusations of bribery as he went on trial Thursday in a case that could threaten his grip on the sport, telling a Munich court that he was blackmailed by a German banker who received a disputed … More »

    The Canadian Press - 43 minutes ago
  • F1 boss Bernie Ecclestone rejects bribery charges

    F1 boss Bernie Ecclestone rejects bribery charges

    Formula One boss Bernie Ecclestone rejected accusations of bribery as he went on trial Thursday in a case that could threaten his grip on the sport, telling a Munich court that he was blackmailed by a German banker who received a disputed $44 … More »

    AP - Sports - 44 minutes ago
  • Pineda says he'll learn from ejection for pine tar

    Pineda says he'll learn from ejection for pine tar

    The pine tar glistened on Michael Pineda's neck, improving his grip and inviting trouble. The Yankees' right-hander spoke quietly after being ejected in the second inning of the Red Sox' 5-1 win over New York on Wednesday night. And less than two … More »

    AP - Sports - 1 hour 2 minutes ago
  • Phelps launches comeback in 100m fly

    Phelps launches comeback in 100m fly

    Returning to swimming after a 20-month retirement, Michael Phelps is easing back into the sport he once dominated by racing one of his best events. The 18-time Olympic gold medalist will swim the 100-meter butterfly at the Arena Grand Prix on … More »

    AP - Sports - 1 hour 3 minutes ago
  • Quiros, Dyson share lead at China Open

    Quiros, Dyson share lead at China Open

    Alvaro Quiros and Simon Dyson each shot a 5-under 67 to share the lead after the first round of the China Open on Thursday. The pair were a stroke ahead of a group of six golfers that included defending champion Brett Rumford of Australia and … More »

    AP - Sports - 1 hour 8 minutes ago
  • Radwanska rolls into Stuttgart quarters

    Radwanska rolls into Stuttgart quarters

    STUTTGART, Germany (AP) -- Top seed Agnieszka Radwanska defeated Italy's Roberta Vinci 6-3, 6-2 to book her quarterfinal place at the Porsche Grand Prix on Thursday. … More »

    AP - Sports - 1 hour 8 minutes ago
  • Everest climbing season in disarray after deaths

    Nepal's attempts to salvage the Mount Everest climbing season fell flat Thursday as major expedition companies canceled their climbs and many Sherpas quit the mountain after an avalanche killed 16 of their fellow guides last week. While the season … More »

    AP - Sports - 1 hour 19 minutes ago
  • Comcast's Fandango ticket service buys MovieClips

    (Reuters) - Fandango, a movie ticketing service owned by cable company Comcast Corp, is buying MovieClips from Zefr Inc to boost its film-related content. MovieClips, launched in 2009, licenses movie scenes from various studios, puts them up on … More »

    Reuters - 1 hour 41 minutes ago
  • No rest for weary Atletico as Valencia trip looms

    No rest for weary Atletico as Valencia trip looms

    By Tim Hanlon BARCELONA, April 24 (Reuters) - Atletico Madrid must put their Champions League ambitions to one side when they look to maintain their surprise La Liga title surge in a tough trip to Valencia on Sunday. They are on the verge of … More »

    Reuters - 2 hours 5 minutes ago
  • Dyson enjoys happy return to China, shares lead with Quiros

    (Reuters) - Englishman Simon Dyson, who was handed a suspended two-month ban for cheating in December, fired a five-under-par 67 to grab a share of the first round lead at the European Tour's China Open on Thursday. The Englishman fired six birdies … More »

    Reuters - 2 hours 14 minutes ago
  • Formula One boss denies bribery at German trial

    Formula One boss denies bribery at German trial

    By Keith Weir MUNICH Germany (Reuters) - Formula One chief executive Bernie Ecclestone denied bribery allegations on Thursday when he went on trial in Germany in a case that threatens to break the Briton's decades-long dominance of the motor sport. … More »

    Reuters - 2 hours 15 minutes ago
  • Ajax extend ban on fans travelling to Feyenoord games

    REUTERS - Ajax Amsterdam have extended the ban on their fans attending away league games against arch-rivals Feyenoord in Rotterdam following the riotous behaviour of supporters in Sunday's Dutch Cup final. It ends hopes that a five-year suspension … More »

    Reuters - 2 hours 16 minutes ago
  • Guan, 15, getting used to spotlight

    One year after his stunning debut at the Masters, Chinese 15-year-old golfer Guan Tianlang is growing accustomed to being in the spotlight. The teenager's star has risen quickly in China since his breakthrough at Augusta National, where at the age … More »

    AP - Sports - 2 hours 18 minutes ago
  • Bolton Wanderers to rename the Reebok stadium

    (Reuters) - Bolton Wanderers will change the name of their Reebok stadium to the Macron from July as part of a new deal between the Championship club and an Italian sportswear manufacturer. It will be the first change of name for the second tier … More »

    Reuters - 2 hours 25 minutes ago
  • Protesters rally against FIFA president Blatter

    A handful of protesters holding banners and placards demonstrated peacefully Thursday at an event with FIFA president Sepp Blatter to highlight the plight of migrant workers building stadiums in Qatar for the 2022 World Cup. Blatter was a guest at … More »

    AP - Sports - 2 hours 26 minutes ago
  • Golf-Dyson enjoys happy return to China, shares lead with Quiros

    Englishman Simon Dyson, who was handed a suspended two-month ban for cheating in December, fired a five-under-par 67 to grab a share of the first round lead at the European Tour's China Open on Thursday. The Englishman fired six birdies and a lone … More »

    Reuters - 2 hours 39 minutes ago
  • Postgame: Dirk Nowitzki

    Postgame: Dirk Nowitzki

    Dirk Nowitzki addresses the media following the Game 2 win over the Spurs. … More »

    NBA.com - 2 hours 44 minutes ago
  • Hanyu determined to build on success of Sochi

    Hanyu determined to build on success of Sochi

    Yuzuru Hanyu has barely had time to dwell on the Olympic and world titles he won in the first quarter of 2014, yet he's already thinking about how to improve for next season. Hanyu became the first Japanese man to claim Olympic gold in figure … More »

    AP - Sports - 3 hours ago
  • More teams withdraw, Nepal's Everest season in jeopardy

    By Gopal Sharma KATHMANDU (Reuters) - Several foreign climbing expeditions have called off attempts to scale Everest following an avalanche that killed at least 13 local guides, meaning Nepal faces an entire season without a single ascent of the … More »

    Reuters - 3 hours ago
  • No clubs facing FFP European expulsion - Platini

    No clubs facing FFP European expulsion - Platini

    No clubs can expect to be expelled from European competition next season for breaking financial fair play rules, UEFA president Michel Platini said in an interview on Thursday. UEFA's Financial Fair Play (FFP) policy, designed to stop clubs … More »

    Reuters - 3 hours ago
  • No clubs facing European expulsion - Platini

    No clubs facing European expulsion - Platini

    No clubs will be kicked out of European competition next season for breaking financial fair play rules, UEFA president Michel Platini said in an interview on Thursday. UEFA's financial fair play (FFP) policy, designed to stop clubs spending more … More »

    Reuters - 3 hours ago
  • Fast-breaking Real home in on elusive 10th European crown

    Fast-breaking Real home in on elusive 10th European crown

    By Tim Hanlon BARCELONA (Reuters) - Real Madrid took a step closer to an elusive 10th European Cup with a 1-0 home win over Bayern Munich on Wednesday and the Spanish side will hope to finish off the job in Germany having shown how effective they … More »

    Reuters - 4 hours ago
  • Schalke aiming to seal Champions League spot

    By Karolos Grohmann REUTERS - Schalke 04's season could have a happy ending at home to Borussia Moenchengladbach on Sunday when they hope to claim a Champions League spot after a rollercoaster campaign punctuated by injury problems. Schalke, who … More »

    Reuters - 4 hours ago
  • Sturridge hopeful of returning against Chelsea

    Sturridge hopeful of returning against Chelsea

    REUTERS - Liverpool striker Daniel Sturridge is optimistic of returning from injury for the key clash against former team mates and title rivals Chelsea at Anfield on Sunday in a boost for the Premier League leaders. "Hopefully this weekend I'll be … More »

    Reuters - 4 hours ago
  • Confident Bayern promise home improvements against Real

    Confident Bayern promise home improvements against Real

    Holders Bayern Munich promised a sharp improvement when they host Real Madrid in the second leg of their Champions League semi-final after failing to convert the lion's share of possession into goals in a 1-0 defeat in Spain on Wednesday. Bayern … More »

    Reuters - 5 hours ago
  • Be optimistic about Brazil, says Blatter

    Be optimistic about Brazil, says Blatter

    By Stefanie McIntyre HONG KONG (Reuters) - FIFA president Sepp Blatter has encouraged fans to be optimistic that the World Cup in Brazil will be a success, amid growing concerns over security and public unrest as workers scramble to finish stadiums … More »

    Reuters - 5 hours ago
  • Announcer relishes role as voice of Kentucky Derby

    Announcer relishes role as voice of Kentucky Derby

    From his perch with a panoramic view of the world's most famous racetrack, the new voice of Churchill Downs will sit out one of the most anticipated moments of the tradition-soaked Kentucky Derby. Larry Collmus will try to tune out ''My Old … More »

    AP - Sports - 6 hours ago
  • Confident Bayern promise home improvements against Real Madrid

    Confident Bayern promise home improvements against Real Madrid

    By Karolos Grohmann REUTERS - Holders Bayern Munich promised a sharp improvement when they host Real Madrid in the second leg of their Champions League semi-final after failing to convert the lion's share of possession into goals in a 1-0 defeat in … More »

    Reuters - 6 hours ago
  • Wednesday's Sports In Brief

    BOSTON (AP) -- Yankees pitcher Michael Pineda was ejected for using pine tar less than two weeks after appearing to get away with using a foreign substance in another game against Boston, and the Red Sox beat New York 5-1 on Wednesday night. … More »

    AP - Sports - 6 hours ago
  • Flyers lack punch at home on power play

    Flyers lack punch at home on power play

    Back on their home ice, the Philadelphia Flyers fizzled on the power play. The Flyers ranked 25th in the NHL in power-play efficiency at home during the regular season, scoring on 15.1 percent of their chances. In Tuesday's 4-1 loss to the New … More »

    AP - Sports - 6 hours ago
  • Lions welcome new faces at minicamp

    Lions welcome new faces at minicamp

    Their new coach has been to Super Bowls and the Detroit Lions how have two new players who have championship rings. Free-agent acquisitions Golden Tate and James Ihedigbo - who played on the winning side of the last two Super Bowls - finished their … More »

    AP - Sports - 6 hours ago
  • Iowa's offense looking to match defense

    Iowa's offense looking to match defense

    Iowa's defense was back among the nation's elite last season. The Hawkeyes' offense failed to follow suit. Getting both units to play at an equally high level will likely be crucial to Iowa's hopes of competing for a Big Ten West title. The … More »

    AP - Sports - 6 hours ago
  • Mike Trout robs Bryce Harper with impressive diving catch

    Mike Trout robs Bryce Harper with impressive diving catch

    One phenom robs another. … More »

    Big League Stew - 6 hours ago
  • Stars even with Ducks after 4-2 win in Game 4

    Stars even with Ducks after 4-2 win in Game 4

    The young Dallas Stars keep overcoming early 2-0 deficits. With their latest comeback in Game 4, they are now even with the top-seeded Anaheim Ducks. Down in the series after losing the first two games in Anaheim, the Stars trailed by two goals in … More »

    AP - Sports - 7 hours ago
  • Jets returning to SUNY Cortland for training camp

    The New York Jets are holding training camp at SUNY Cortland again this summer, returning to central New York for the fifth time in the last six years. The team trains on the school's campus, located about three hours from the Jets' facility in … More »

    AP - Sports - 7 hours ago
  • Road teams off to fast start in playoffs

    Road teams off to fast start in playoffs

    Here's the list of teams that had home-court advantage entering the opening round of these NBA playoffs: Indiana, Miami, Toronto, Chicago, San Antonio, Oklahoma City, Houston and the Los Angeles Clippers. Here's the list of teams that still held … More »

    AP - Sports - 7 hours ago