Mailbag: Why the MMA lightweight division is top-notch

Kevin Iole
Yahoo Sports

There is a lot going on the mixed martial arts world, so I thought I'd go with an expanded edition of the MMA mailbag this week.

Let's get right into your comments.

READERS ALWAYS WRITE

Great athletes fight above lightweight, too

Regarding your comment, "The lightweight division is so strong because it's where the perfect combination of speed, skill and power reside," I'm afraid I don't understand your reasoning. UFC light heavyweight champion Jon Jones isn't athletic? Middleweight champion Anderson Silva isn't athletic? Welterweight champ Georges St. Pierre isn't athletic? Each of those fighters contain a higher level of athleticism than Frankie Edgar. I'm afraid you are interpreting cardiovascular conditioning as athleticism. Yes, Clay Guida, Edgar and new lightweight champion Benson Henderson can go five rounds at a frenetic pace. But that isn't athleticism; that's just physiology. Worse, though, was your comment about power. How many knockouts does Edgar have? How about Guida? [Gray] Maynard? Kenny Florian? Henderson? Now, how many knockouts does featherweight champion Jose Aldo have? I believe if you count Aldo's entire body of work, he has more knockouts than all of those lightweights.

Michael McWilliams
Houston

Michael, of course Jones, Silva and St. Pierre (among many others) are great athletes. I never said they were not. I was talking about them as a group. When you factor in the group of athletes in a division from top to bottom, I believe my comments are accurate. Of course, it's an opinion. You may think that, top to bottom, there are more athletes and better fights at, say, 170 or 205. That's fine. But my larger point was that the division is stacked with great athletes and great fighters and there are more top-level fights to be made at lightweight than anywhere else.

[Related: Kevin Iole's UFC 144 breakdown]

Edgar would handle Aldo

Frankie Edgar and Jose Aldo are the same size. Aldo has a weight problem. Who really cares what they weigh when Edgar kicks Aldo's overrated butt all over the ring?

Daniel Bernard
Mexico City

I'll disagree with your point about Aldo being overrated, but forgetting that for a second, I'll answer your question: Aldo and Edgar would care, among others. If they fought at lightweight now, it wouldn't be for a title since Edgar is no longer the champion. If they fight at featherweight it would be a championship match so they clearly would care. Edgar is an interesting case study because he chooses to fight at lightweight when he could easily make featherweight (one of his camp members said he thought he could make bantamweight, though I'm not so sure I believe that). Unlike most fighters who work extremely hard to fight at the lowest possible class, Edgar cuts almost no weight. He feels it doesn't deplete his body and it's hard to argue with him, given his success. A 10-pound cut shouldn't take much of a toll on him and could set up a fascinating fight for the featherweight title against Aldo, if he chooses to go that way.

White is erring by paying win bonuses to fighters who lose

Mixed Martial Arts has grown so fast that judging, and judges, already seems antiquated. Fans and fighters both are confused on what criteria a given judge is using on any event. What plays well one week doesn't play at all the following. There needs to be an updated, consistent set of criteria that judges use to score (and not just assuming the guy on the bottom is losing). But, when is UFC president Dana White going to realize that frequently disagreeing with the judges and giving win bonuses to fighters who lost on the judges' cards is a harmful thing? Why have judges if Dana is going to unofficially reverse the decision and/or very openly criticize judges (and to some extent, referees)? He likes to say, "Don't leave it in the hands of the judges," but given his actions, why not? If you think you can't knock someone out or submit them, isn't the next best course of victory to let it go to the judges? If you lose and it's close, you might just get paid anyway.

Ben
Nashville, Tenn.

There is a set criteria judges use, but how each judge views things is a personal decision. As for your point about White, I don't get it. First of all, if a fighter can't knock someone out or submit him, what other choice does he have other than to let it go to a decision? I suppose the other choice is getting knocked out or submitted himself. But why would you not want fighters to get paid for fighting well? If White can incentivize the fighters to compete harder (and thus put on better shows for the fans) by paying them extra when they do well, why would you oppose that? I would object if the UFC stripped a champion who won a decision according to the judges and White objected. He hasn't done that, though. He's simply rewarded fighters he, as an owner of the company, thought performed well. There's nothing wrong with that. I'd much rather a promoter pay a fighter more than he has to rather than less.

Who employs the officials in MMA bouts?

Who do the referees and judges work for when they work in the UFC? Do they work for the state athletic commission where the fight is held or do they work for the UFC? I have seen some of the same referees when they hold events in different states or countries. I believe if the referee works for the organization, there can be manipulation for fight outcomes.

Jose Corral
Las Vegas

Jose, there is a twofold answer here. When the UFC (or any promoter) holds an event where there is an athletic commission that regulates MMA, the officials work for that commission. So, if you see Herb Dean refereeing a bout in Nevada, he's paid by the Nevada Athletic Commission and reports to executive director Keith Kizer. But when the UFC travels internationally, it often holds events where there is no commission. In those events, the UFC appoints its vice president of regulatory affairs, Marc Ratner, to serve as the de facto commissioner of those events. Ratner then chooses the referees and the judges and they are, in fact, paid by the UFC. That's not ideal, but if it didn't work that way, the UFC couldn't go to places like Japan and the U.K., for examples, which don't have a body that regulates the sport.

[ Related: Weight flop proves costly as 'Rampage' loses to Ryan Bader ]

'Rampage wasn't motivated'

Once I heard that Rampage Jackson didn't make weight for his UFC 144 bout against Ryan Bader, I wondered what he was doing. I feel he didn't show up to the event and after finding out the results the next day, it didn't surprise me to find out he lost. The only thing the fans in Japan got to show for it was his signature slam move, when he slammed Bader. To me, he showed up to get paid and didn't show up to fight. Rampage has always been my fighter of choice, but for some reason I knew he wasn't going to win as soon as I heard he missed weight. It makes me wonder if he even trained for the fight, like when he trained hard when he fought Jon Jones.

Jeff
Greensburg, Ky.

That's been the knock on Rampage for a long time now, that he's not always motivated. He certainly seemed lethargic in the fight against Bader, which he blamed on a knee injury that prevented him from doing cardiovascular training.

Will Edgar's loss bring Penn back to lightweight?

Losing twice to Frankie Edgar forced B.J. Penn to move up in weight. He subsequently said he was going to consider whether to fight again after a couple of lackluster performances. A few weeks back, I read that those ever-reliable "unnamed sources close to" B.J. have said that he's got the fire back and will fight again. Does Benson Henderson's win open the door for Penn to come back as a lightweight?

Scott
Omaha, Neb.

I'm not sure it impacts it at all, Scott. If B.J. is hungry and motivated, he's one of the best fighters in the world whether he fights at lightweight or welterweight. When he's not, he's just another guy. He hasn't decided if he wants to fight any longer. If he does want to fight and chooses to go to lightweight, he'd be a contender but would be behind a number of guys like Nate Diaz, Jim Miller, Anthony Pettis and, of course, Edgar, who have won fights and looked impressive while Penn has been away.

[ Related: Benson Henderson's win solidifies lightweight division as UFC's strongest ]

Edgar deserved the victory

I don't know why there isn't more outrage about Benson Henderson's "victory" at UFC 144 over Frankie Edgar. First, Frankie was fighting a guy who was probably a welterweight, not a lightweight. But if you tell me you think Henderson won four of the five rounds, like two of the judges' did, I'm going to show you someone who knows nothing about MMA. Frankie won that fight without a doubt and anyone who knows MMA knows that.

Shannon
Kailua, Hawaii

Edgar and Henderson each weighed 154, so they were both lightweights. As I said previously, Edgar chooses to fight at a class in which he doesn't have to cut weight. He probably weighed no more than 160 in the ring after he rehydrated. Henderson had to cut a lot of weight and probably rehydrated to more than 170, but that's the way it is when the weigh-in is the day before. As for the fight, I had it 3-2 for Henderson, giving Henderson rounds 2, 3 and 4 and Edgar rounds 1 and 5. It was close and I don't have an argument with how it was judged. I wouldn't have had an argument if it was 3-2 Edgar, as Dana White had it, either. In those kinds of fights, there is going to be a lot of disagreement.

QUOTEWORTHY

"This isn't my first rodeo, and this won't be a walk in the park, but the jitters won't be on my side." – UFC flyweight Demetrious Johnson, talking about his opening-round tournament fight Friday against UFC newcomer Ian McCall

Other popular content on Yahoo! Sports:
Forde Minutes: College basketball's five remaining big questions
Ex-coach: Tiger Woods considered leaving golf to become a Navy SEAL
The Daytona 500 was anything but ordinary

  • NLRB to review Northwestern union ruling

    NLRB to review Northwestern union ruling

    Northwestern University's football players will cast ballots Friday on whether to form the nation's first union for college athletes - a potentially landmark vote that will be kept sealed for months and possibly years. The National Labor Relations … More »

    AP - Sports - 14 minutes ago
  • Column: 'There's better ways to conceal it.'

    Column: 'There's better ways to conceal it.'

    The thing that has baseball folks riled up about Michael Pineda isn't that he was trying to cheat. It had to qualify as the grossest violation ever of Rule 8.02(b), which says, ''The pitcher shall not ... have on his person, or in his possession, … More »

    AP - Sports - 14 minutes ago
  • Whisenhunt looks forward to Titans' minicamp

    New Tennessee Titans coach Ken Whisenhunt looks forward to discovering just how many holes the team filled through free agency. Whisenhunt said Thursday he's eager to see his team and begin an evaluation process that could affect the Titans' draft … More »

    AP - Sports - 14 minutes ago
  • Bolsinger earns 1st MLB win, Diamondbacks top Cubs

    Bolsinger earns 1st MLB win, Diamondbacks top Cubs

    Pitching only 8 miles from where he grew up, Mike Bolsinger had more nerves than usual when he stepped on the mound at Wrigley Field against the Chicago Cubs. In front of about 20 family and friends, some of whom he hadn't seen in a long time after … More »

    AP - Sports - 18 minutes ago
  • Silver: Premature to say union will opt out of CBA

    NBA Commissioner Adam Silver says he has ''no expectation'' that players will opt out of the collective bargaining agreement in 2017, potentially leading to another lockout. … More »

    AP - Sports - 18 minutes ago
  • Richmond hoping track access boosts fan experience

    Richmond hoping track access boosts fan experience

    They are calling it ''Track Takeover'' at Richmond International Raceway, and track President Dennis Bickmeier hopes allowing fans onto the racing surface a few hours before race time on Saturday night will not only improve their experience at the … More »

    AP - Sports - 21 minutes ago
  • Pineda banned 10 games for pine tar, won't appeal

    Pineda banned 10 games for pine tar, won't appeal

    New York Yankees pitcher Michael Pineda was suspended for 10 games Thursday after being caught using pine tar. ''I accept it,'' Pineda said before Thursday night's game at Fenway Park. Pineda was ejected in the second inning of Wednesday night's … More »

    AP - Sports - 25 minutes ago
  • Cal Poly baseball team is toast of the West Coast

    Cal Poly has long been known for turning out great engineers and architects. The San Luis Obispo school that produced Hall of Famer Ozzie Smith in the 1970s is enjoying its finest season since joining Division I in 1995. At 35-5, the Mustangs … More »

    AP - Sports - 27 minutes ago
  • Raptors ready for road test in Game 3 in Brooklyn

    Raptors ready for road test in Game 3 in Brooklyn

    NEW YORK (AP) -- If Dwane Casey has any concerns coming to Brooklyn, they aren't about his players. … More »

    AP - Sports - 28 minutes ago
  • Some rules regarding Northwestern union vote

    In the wake of a ruling by a regional director of the National Labor Relations Board that they qualify as employees under federal law, Northwestern football players are voting Friday on whether to form the nation's first union for college athletes. … More »

    AP - Sports - 29 minutes ago
  • The 10-man rotation, starring a very cool time-lapse drawing of LeBron James (Video)

    The 10-man rotation, starring a very cool time-lapse drawing of LeBron James (Video)

    A look around the league and the Web that covers it. It's also important to note that the rotation order and starting nods aren't always listed in order of importance. That's for you, dear reader, to figure out. … More »

    Ball Don't Lie - 29 minutes ago
  • Benfica and Sevilla secure Europa League wins

    Benfica and Sevilla secure Europa League wins

    By Toby Davis LONDON (Reuters) - A stunning late goal from Benfica's Lima left Juventus's hopes of reaching a home Europa League final hanging in the balance after a 2-1 first-leg defeat, while Sevilla won 2-0 against Valencia in Thursday's … More »

    Reuters - 30 minutes ago
  • NFL draft's most precarious pick: Jadeveon Clowney

    NFL draft's most precarious pick: Jadeveon Clowney

    If the South Carolina standout doesn’t live up to his potential, it's more than possible the blame will fall on his coaching staff for not fully unlocking his immense talent. They will get the burden of proof, because look at how talented Clowney … More »

    Yahoo Sports - 30 minutes ago
  • Dice-K 1st save since 2000; Mets top Cards 4-1

    Dice-K 1st save since 2000; Mets top Cards 4-1

    Daisuke Matsuzaka pinched his eyelids, clenched his teeth and thought back. After 123 starts during seven seasons in Major League Baseball, the 33-year-old right-hander was turned into a reliever by the New York Mets when they brought him up from … More »

    AP - Sports - 32 minutes ago
  • NCAA proposal for governance change

    Highlights from the proposal to change the NCAA's governance structure, which was endorsed Thursday by the NCAA's board of directors. A formal vote is not expected until the board's quarterly meeting in August: - The five biggest football … More »

    AP - Sports - 35 minutes ago
  • New statue of Penn State's Paterno set for 2015 unveiling: alumni

    New statue of Penn State's Paterno set for 2015 unveiling: alumni

    By David DeKok HARRISBURG, Pennsylvania (Reuters) - Fundraising for a new statue depicting Joe Paterno "as the man he was and not Joe the football coach" is set to begin two years after his image was removed from Penn State University because of a … More »

    Reuters - 37 minutes ago
  • George Hincapie offers an unvarnished look at cycling in new memoir

    George Hincapie offers an unvarnished look at cycling in new memoir

    George Hincapie was the "Loyal Lieutenant" who helped Lance Armstrong to seven Tour de France titles, only to later provide the key testimony that brought his downfall. Now, Hincapie is talking again about one of the darkest eras in cycling. In a … More »

    The Canadian Press - 38 minutes ago
  • Texas' Kouzmanoff to have back evaluated

    Texas' Kouzmanoff to have back evaluated

    Texas third baseman Kevin Kouzmanoff was scheduled to be evaluated Friday at home by a back specialist before the Rangers make a roster move to activate Adrian Beltre from the disabled list. Kouzmanoff, who is hitting .362 in 13 games and is the … More »

    AP - Sports - 38 minutes ago
  • Gomez helps spark aggressive Brewers' hot start

    Gomez helps spark aggressive Brewers' hot start

    MILWAUKEE (AP) -- The Brewers' new leadoff hitter can aggravate pitchers by slugging homers or stealing bases. Carlos Gomez is flustering foes, and his energetic approach has helped Milwaukee jump out to the best record in baseball. … More »

    AP - Sports - 39 minutes ago
  • Legalize it! Joe Maddon jokes pine tar should be legal in Colorado and Washington

    Legalize it! Joe Maddon jokes pine tar should be legal in Colorado and Washington

    Rays manager jokingly compares MLB's pine tar problem to marijuana legalization. … More »

    Big League Stew - 40 minutes ago
  • Armstrong teammate Hincapie pens stark memoir

    Armstrong teammate Hincapie pens stark memoir

    George Hincapie was the ''Loyal Lieutenant'' who helped Lance Armstrong to seven Tour de France titles, only to later provide the key testimony that brought his downfall. Now, Hincapie is talking again about one of the darkest eras in cycling. In … More »

    AP - Sports - 42 minutes ago
  • Twins get rare road series win vs. Rays

    Twins get rare road series win vs. Rays

    ST. PETERSBURG, Fla. (AP) -- Sam Fuld had enjoyed plenty of success at Tropicana Field. For the Minnesota Twins, big moments in the ballpark had been fleeting. … More »

    AP - Sports - 42 minutes ago
  • Colorado PG Dinwiddie entering NBA draft

    Colorado PG Dinwiddie entering NBA draft

    Spencer Dinwiddie expects to be healthy and wealthy by summer's end. The University of Colorado star point guard announced Thursday he's skipping his senior season and will declare for the NBA draft. Dinwiddie said at a news conference in Boulder, … More »

    AP - Sports - 47 minutes ago
  • Former Rangers great Jardine dies aged 65

    Former Rangers and Scotland defender Sandy Jardine has died at the age of 65 after battling cancer for 18 months, the Glasgow club said on Thursday. Jardine made almost 800 appearances for Rangers, winning three league titles, and was twice voted … More »

    Reuters - 47 minutes ago
  • Bills hire Dixon as pro scout

    ORCHARD PARK, N.Y. (AP) -- The Buffalo Bills have hired Gerald Dixon as a pro scout. … More »

    AP - Sports - 50 minutes ago
  • NCAA endorses more power for big schools

    NCAA endorses more power for big schools

    The NCAA's board of directors took the first step toward shifting power to the five largest football conferences on Thursday, endorsing a 57-page plan that calls for giving 65 of the nation's biggest schools more autonomy in how to fund … More »

    AP - Sports - 50 minutes ago
  • US ski coach gets 4 months for money laundering

    The head coach of the U.S. Alpine speed team, Andreas Evers, was fired by the U.S. Ski and Snowboard Association on Thursday, hours after the Austrian was sentenced to four months in prison plus 20 months on probation for money laundering. ''Core … More »

    AP - Sports - 54 minutes ago
  • Sevilla earn two-goal cushion against Valencia

    Stephane MBia and Carlos Bacca were on target for Sevilla as they took a big step towards reaching the Europa League final with a 2-0 victory over Valencia on Thursday. The Andalusian side continued their good form which has seen them win nine of … More »

    Reuters - 55 minutes ago
  • Ducks unsure on Getzlaf, mum on goalie

    Ducks unsure on Getzlaf, mum on goalie

    ANAHEIM, Calif. (AP) -- Two-thirds of the Anaheim Ducks' top line is injured, including their captain and leading scorer. Their most beloved player has been benched, and their rookie goalie looks shakier with every game. … More »

    AP - Sports - 1 hour 0 minutes ago
  • Henrik Zetterberg a game-time decision for Red Wings in all-important Game 4

    Henrik Zetterberg a game-time decision for Red Wings in all-important Game 4

    The Detroit Red Wings' locker room is bursting with new life. … More »

    Puck Daddy - 1 hour 0 minutes ago
  • No Bills cheerleaders in 2014 after suit

    Pack up the pom-poms in Buffalo, because the Bills will be playing without the support of their official cheerleaders this year. Stephanie Mateczun, whose company manages the Buffalo Jills cheerleading squad, said Thursday she has suspended … More »

    AP - Sports - 1 hour 2 minutes ago
  • Yankees lose Nova to Tommy John surgery

    Yankees lose Nova to Tommy John surgery

    BOSTON (AP) -- New York Yankees right-hander Ivan Nova has decided to have season-ending Tommy John surgery for a partially torn elbow ligament. … More »

    AP - Sports - 1 hour 5 minutes ago
  • Jason Collins named one of TIME Magazine's 100 most influential people, for good reason

    Jason Collins named one of TIME Magazine's 100 most influential people, for good reason

    The impact of the Brooklyn Nets center continues to be felt. … More »

    Ball Don't Lie - 1 hour 6 minutes ago
  • Owners to discuss expanded playoffs

    Owners to discuss expanded playoffs

    The NFL will discuss expanded playoffs at the owners' meetings next month in Atlanta. Commissioner Roger Goodell told a gathering of Associated Press Sports Editors on Thursday that a vote is uncertain on the proposal to add two teams to the … More »

    AP - Sports - 1 hour 17 minutes ago
  • Pagenaud still upset with Power over Long Beach

    A week off did nothing to mellow the tension between Simon Pagenaud and Will Power stemming from contact between the two at Long Beach. Pagenaud refused to accept an apology from Power following the April 13 race in which Pagenaud was spun from … More »

    AP - Sports - 1 hour 23 minutes ago
  • Florida diving coach killed in boating accident

    University of Florida diving coach Donnie Craine died Thursday morning in a boating accident off the coast of Bokeelia, the school announced. The Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission, which is investigating the accident, says two … More »

    AP - Sports - 1 hour 24 minutes ago
  • Optimistic Arizona Cardinals begin conditioning

    Optimistic Arizona Cardinals begin conditioning

    TEMPE, Ariz. (AP) -- The optimistic Arizona Cardinals began work this week under an intense new conditioning coach in their first formal gathering to prepare for the coming season. … More »

    AP - Sports - 1 hour 26 minutes ago
  • Reds beat Pirates for seventh win in 9

    Reds beat Pirates for seventh win in 9

    Considering the Cincinnati Reds started the year at 3-8, however, they were happy to get their record to 11-11 on Thursday. Ryan Ludwick lined a two-run double after two batters were hit by pitches, lifting Tony Cingrani and the Reds over the … More »

    AP - Sports - 1 hour 26 minutes ago
  • CB Trufant retires as Seahawk

    CB Trufant retires as Seahawk

    When it was clear Marcus Trufant's time with the Seattle Seahawks was over following the 2012 season, he was given a message by general manager John Schneider and coach Pete Carroll on his way out. If it became apparent that Trufant was ready to … More »

    AP - Sports - 1 hour 30 minutes ago
  • McRoberts fined $20K for foul on James

    McRoberts fined $20K for foul on James

    NEW YORK (AP) -- Charlotte Bobcats forward Josh McRoberts was fined $20,000 by the NBA on Thursday for making unnecessary and excessive contact with Miami Heat forward LeBron James. … More »

    AP - Sports - 1 hour 30 minutes ago