Karl Alzner signs with Canadiens, but is he worth investment?

The Montreal Canadiens have agreed to a deal with Washington Capitals free agent defenseman Karl Alzner. According to Aaron Ward of TSN, it’s a five-year deal, and colleague Darren Dreger has it at just over $23 million total.

Alzner, 28, made $2.8 million against the cap on his last four-year deal with the Capitals.

So what are the Canadiens getting with Alzner?

A workhorse, for one. Alzner hasn’t missed a regular season game in the last seven seasons, playing between 19 and 21 minutes per night. He’s cracked 20 points only twice in his career, earning a reputations as a stalwart defensive defenseman while playing with more offensively minded players like John Carlson.

But they’re getting a player whose game has really fallen off in the last two seasons, where he’s been a negative possession player in each. Last season, on a good possession team, Alzner had a Corsi percentage of 47.2. He’s a minus-148 in shot attempts over the last two seasons, the worst on the Capitals by a country mile in that span.

What created such a drop-off this season? Alzner said off-season hernia surgery contributed to it. From the Washington Post:

“It’s kind of been standing still at a certain percent,” Alzner said. “There are days when I’m stiffer than other days and I can’t quite move as good, and so I have to manage the game a little differently. … I’ve never been the fastest skater, but I’ve always been a good enough skater where I can a lot of times skate myself out of trouble or catch up, if need be, and this year, I’ve been a little bit slower.

“Part of it, I’m sure, is mental just because you want to guard it a little bit. Of all years, this would be a year where I wouldn’t want that to happen because the team is good and I want to be able to help as much as I can. But at the same time, it’s hard to get over that mental hurdle.”

Frankly, a player struggling like this after sports hernia surgery should scare the bejeepers out of teams, but there is also a conventional wisdom in the NHL that it just takes more than a season to recover from them.

If the number is $4.6 million, that’ll likely make Alzner the third-highest paid defenseman on the Canadiens next season, barring what happens with Andrei Markov.

So is this a good move for the Canadiens?

It’s amazing what about $400,000 can do.

At $5 million over five years, this probably gets thumbs-down immediately. At $4.6 million – that’s Jason Demers and Anton Stralman territory – it gives you pause. Yes, the stats were atrocious last season. Yes, this a wager from GM Marc Bergevin that Alzner needed a season to work through his surgery recovery.

But if the question is whether you want Alexei Emelin at $4.1 million and 31 years old or Karl Alzner at around $4.6 million and 28 years old, you take the latter option every single time, because he’s a better player. And it’s not necessarily a contract you’re saddled with if things don’t work out in, say, three seasons.

Smart move for both the player and the team here.

Greg Wyshynski is a writer for Yahoo Sports. Contact him at puckdaddyblog@yahoo.com or find him on Twitter. His book, TAKE YOUR EYE OFF THE PUCK, is available on Amazon and wherever books are sold.

MORE FROM YAHOO SPORTS


What to Read Next