LaDontae Henton scored 15 and grabbed eight rebounds, and Josh Fortune added 10 points for the Friars (4-2).
Derek Needham paced the Stags (3-3) with 18 points. Fairfield shot just 35.2 percent (19 of 54) and committed 16 turnovers.
Cotton, who entered the game as the Big East’s leading scorer with 24.5 points per game, went 6 of 13 from the floor, hitting his only two 3s of the game in the key run.
Vincent Council, Providence’s leading scorer from last season at 15.9 points per game, missed his fifth straight contest. He suffered a leg injury 5 minutes into the season opener.
The Friars, who beat UNC Ashville in the third round of the Puerto Rico Tip-off tournament Sunday, led by eight at halftime.
- Phillies-Dodgers Preview
- @POTUS unscripted: Obama shows a looser side on Twitter
- Ned Yost explains why he didn't pick A-Rod for the AL All-Star team
- Gold Cup preview: Title contenders, best group games, USA's key player
- Jon Lester gets a hit. Finally.
- Quarterback De'Andre Johnson dismissed from Florida State
- MLB All-Star pitchers, reserves and final vote candidates announced
- Your winners and losers from the NBA's 2015 free-agent market
- Rollins rallies Dodgers past his old Phillies team, 10-7
- Kyrgios slams 'racist' Olympic great Fraser
- You know how many Royals were voted All-Stars starters by MLB players? Zero
- 13 remaining free agents who can help NBA teams
- The ridiculous snubbing of Clayton Kershaw and how the MLB All-Star Game lost its way
- Arizona signs 'key building block' Dylan Strome to entry-level contract
- 40 schedule observations for this college football season
- Andrea Pirlo could have the same impact in MLS as David Beckham