What's buzzing:

Puck Daddy

Why did Jamie Benn escape suspension for this Matt Cooke elbow?

Greg Wyshynski
Puck Daddy

View photo

.
In overtime on Saturday night, Jamie Benn of the Dallas Stars was carrying the puck through the neutral zone when Matt Cooke of the Minnesota Wild lined him up.

Benn lost the puck and delivered an elbow to the upper body of Cooke as he went through him. There was no penalty on the play, despite Cooke’s protest.

So will the NHL step in to do what the referees didn’t do on this play?

No, according to Mike Heika of the Dallas Morning News, who reports that there’s no hearing for Benn and that with the Stars back in action on Monday, he doesn’t expect there will be one.

Heika’s theory is that Benn was making a protective, defensive play against Cooke, rather than a predatory one.

Yes, there is a difference. The NHL sees defensive plays as reactive rather than premeditated. It doesn’t mean these aren’t penalties – and it’s a total joke that Benn’s wasn’t – but under the current standards of player safety, a defensive hit like Benn’s isn’t subject to supplemental discipline.

It’s all explained in this recent video by the NHL on defensive contact to the head:

A video or other embedded content has been hidden. Click here to view it.

So if it’s not a hearing, it’ll be a strong warning to Benn and he’ll be on the watch list.

At least there’s some method to the madness, rather than simply having “because it’s Matt Cooke” as the reason.

View Comments (78)
  • NHL Playoff Death Watch: Which teams can clinch tonight?

    NHL Playoff Death Watch: Which teams can clinch tonight?

    Since we're down to the final moments of postseason life for teams in contention, Puck Daddy solemnly begins a daily countdown to annihilation. … More »

    Puck Daddy - 10 minutes ago
  • NCAA Hockey: Jack Eichel line leads BU; Minnesota annihilated

    NCAA Hockey: Jack Eichel line leads BU; Minnesota annihilated

    In which we recap the day’s events in the NCAA tournament. … More »

    Puck Daddy - 2 hours 13 minutes ago
  • Stars-Canucks Preview

    A strong second half has the Vancouver Canucks primed to rejoin the postseason, but the ultra-competitive Western Conference won't afford them any comfort the rest of the way. With a slight cushion in the playoff race, the Canucks face off Saturday … More »

    AP - Sports - 8 hours ago
  • Bachman gets shutout, Oilers cool Stars

    Bachman gets shutout, Oilers cool Stars

    Richard Bachman got a win against his former team, and put a dent in their playoff chances. Bachman made 29 saves for his second NHL shutout and the Edmonton Oilers beat the Dallas Stars 4-0 on Friday night. ''On a selfish note, it feels good to … More »

    AP - Sports - 8 hours ago
  • Wild score 3 in 3rd to get past Flames

    Wild score 3 in 3rd to get past Flames

    The Minnesota Wild poured it on in the third period against the Calgary Flames. Thomas Vanek and Mikko Koivu scored early in a three-goal third period and the Wild pulled away to beat the Flames 4-2 on Friday night. Matt Dumba and Zach Parise also … More »

    AP - Sports - 8 hours ago