What's Buzzing:

Puck Daddy

Why did Jamie Benn escape suspension for this Matt Cooke elbow?

Greg Wyshynski
Puck Daddy

View photo

.
In overtime on Saturday night, Jamie Benn of the Dallas Stars was carrying the puck through the neutral zone when Matt Cooke of the Minnesota Wild lined him up.

Benn lost the puck and delivered an elbow to the upper body of Cooke as he went through him. There was no penalty on the play, despite Cooke’s protest.

So will the NHL step in to do what the referees didn’t do on this play?

No, according to Mike Heika of the Dallas Morning News, who reports that there’s no hearing for Benn and that with the Stars back in action on Monday, he doesn’t expect there will be one.

Heika’s theory is that Benn was making a protective, defensive play against Cooke, rather than a predatory one.

Yes, there is a difference. The NHL sees defensive plays as reactive rather than premeditated. It doesn’t mean these aren’t penalties – and it’s a total joke that Benn’s wasn’t – but under the current standards of player safety, a defensive hit like Benn’s isn’t subject to supplemental discipline.

It’s all explained in this recent video by the NHL on defensive contact to the head:

A video or other embedded content has been hidden. Click here to view it.

So if it’s not a hearing, it’ll be a strong warning to Benn and he’ll be on the watch list.

At least there’s some method to the madness, rather than simply having “because it’s Matt Cooke” as the reason.

View Comments (78)
  • Orpik: 'It was a bad hit' on Maatta

    Orpik: 'It was a bad hit' on Maatta

    PITTSBURGH (AP) -- Brooks Orpik was trying to be physical. Yet the instant the Washington Capitals defenseman made contact with Pittsburgh defenseman Olli Maatta's head early in Game 2 on Saturday night, Orpik knew he had crossed a sometimes vague … More »

    AP - Sports - 1 hour 13 minutes ago
  • Barry Trotz hints NHL favored Penguins on Orpik suspension

    Barry Trotz hints NHL favored Penguins on Orpik suspension

    "I’m disappointed, but I’m not surprised based on who we’re playing and all that." … More »

    Puck Daddy - 1 hour 52 minutes ago
  • Quiet Crosby, Ovechkin; Jones leading Sharks; Raanta re-signs (Puck Headlines)

    Quiet Crosby, Ovechkin; Jones leading Sharks; Raanta re-signs (Puck Headlines)

    Here are your Puck Headlines: A glorious collection of news and views collected from the greatest blogosphere in sports and the few, the proud, the mainstream hockey media. Have a link you want to submit? Email us at puckdaddyblog@yahoo.com. … More »

    Puck Daddy - 2 hours 8 minutes ago
  • Rangers, backup G Raanta agree to deal

    The New York Rangers have agreed to a deal with backup goalie Antti Raanta. The 26-year-old Raanta appeared in 25 games with the Rangers this season after being acquired from the Chicago Blackhawks in June. Raanta earned a win in each of his first … More »

    AP - Sports - 2 hours 25 minutes ago
  • Olli Maatta out of Game 3; should Fleury replace Murray?

    Olli Maatta out of Game 3; should Fleury replace Murray?

    Pittsburgh Penguins coach Mike Sullivan said that defenseman Olli Maatta, last seen struggling to leave the ice after Brooks Orpik’s head shot, will not play in Game 3 of their Eastern Conference semifinal series. … More »

    Puck Daddy - 2 hours 57 minutes ago