What's buzzing:

Puck Daddy

Watch 3-on-3 overtime between NJ Devils vs. LA Kings; better than shootout? (Video)

Greg Wyshynski
Puck Daddy

View photo


Getty Images

The overtime format debate in the NHL is raging, as the League’s general managers recently entertained ideas to minimize the shootout’s frequency (and influence) for something that better captures the essence for the previous 65 minutes of team play.

Thursday night’s games were a microcosm of that debate, on three fronts:

The best contest of the evening, by far, was that between the St. Louis Blues and the Boston Bruins, in which the inter-conference rivals engaged in a brutally tense regulation, a thrilling 4-on-4 overtime before the Blues won in an anti-climactic shootout.

You could hear the deflation in the voices of NESN’s Jack Edwards and Andy Brickley once it was clear the skills competition would determine the winner; Edwards lamented that a tie would have been preferable.

In the Colorado Avalanche’s win against the Phoenix Coyotes, we saw another spin on overtime: The 4-on-3 power play, on which the Avs scored. Some sort of dueling power plays format has been suggested as a shootout alternative; it provided the chance for Ryan O’Reilly to score the game winner.

Then, in the New Jersey Devils’ win over the Los Angeles Kings, fans got a glimpse of what Red Wings GM Ken Holland would like to see: 3-on-3 overtime. Jaromir Jagr went off for holding, Dustin Brown matched that penalty with one for diving (a questionable call), and away we went for two minutes of 3-on-3:

This offered the good and the bad of the format.

Some of it was tentative. Players know one errant blast from the top of the zone could lead to an odd-man rush the other way. So the Kings were a bit more conservative with the puck in the attacking zone.

But the beauty of 3-on-3 is that even the briefest mistake can open up the game, and around the 1-minute mark you got a sense of the excitement this format can bring - wide-open ice, long lead passes, great chances.

Finally, we got another look at the format’s benefits: Exhaustion. Jagr’s goal came after Anze Kopitar, Drew Doughty, and Willie Mitchell has skated for around 40 seconds of 3-on-3. Jagr, meanwhile, was fresh out of the box.

Again: 3-on-3 isn’t perfect, and there are certainly some aspects that make us wary. But it’s good enough to try, not only as a deterrent to the shootout’s inequitable tedium but as it’s own form of overtime entertainment.

What do you think? Should the NHL go 4-on-4 then 3-on-3 then the shootout?

Sign up for Yahoo Fantasy Hockey
View Comments (66)
  • Devils to retire Brodeur's No. 30

    Devils to retire Brodeur's No. 30

    Shortly after Martin Brodeur was selected by the New Jersey Devils with the 20th pick in the 1990 NHL draft, the 18-year-old goaltender was confused. The Devils will retire the No. 30 jersey of their longtime goaltender and erect a statue during … More »

    AP - Sports - 1 hour 16 minutes ago
  • All eyes on McDavid as Oilers open season full of hope

    All eyes on McDavid as Oilers open season full of hope

    The only negative for the hometown fans of the Edmonton Oilers is that their new era, the one built around 18-year-old rookie Connor McDavid, will begin on the road. McDavid, the No. 1 overall pick and the latest youngster thought to be the next …

    AP - Sports - 1 hour 20 minutes ago
  • Blues name DiMaio director of player personnel

    ST. LOUIS (AP) -- The St. Louis Blues have promoted Rob DiMaio to director of player personnel. … More »

    AP - Sports - 1 hour 31 minutes ago
  • Blackhawks put Rozsival on long-term IR

    CHICAGO (AP) -- The Chicago Blackhawks have placed defenseman Michal Rozsival on long-term injured reserve. … More »

    AP - Sports - 1 hour 34 minutes ago
  • Canucks have different look, approach in Year 2 with Benning

    Canucks have different look, approach in Year 2 with Benning

    The Vancouver Canucks for years were a team built on speed and skill. Entering their second year under general manager Jim Benning, the Canucks are emphasizing hard work and a pack mentality as they try to return to the playoffs. Vancouver piled … More »

    AP - Sports - 1 hour 40 minutes ago