What's Buzzing:

Puck Daddy

Scott Hartnell’s 6-year deal with Flyers: Shrewd pre-CBA move or bad business?

Greg Wyshynski
Puck Daddy

View photo


Getty Images

In signing Scott Hartnell to a 6-year, $28.5-million contract extension, I suppose there's a bit of astonishment and/or ridicule expected for the Philadelphia Flyers.

Here's Ed Snider, Big Voice on the owners' side of collective bargaining, signing yet another player to a long-term deal that sneaks their salary in under the CBA wire. You know, because the system is so inadequate that it was imperative to get Hartnell and Wayne Simmonds locked into 6-year deals before it expires …

But that scorn shouldn't be transferred to Hartnell, who has earned every bit of that $4.75 million he'll earn annually beginning in 2013-14 and continuing through his 37th birthday.

Now, $4.75 million annually for a player that's broken 30 goals twice (including last year's 37) and 60 points the same number of times might be viewed as overpayment.

I don't see it that way. He gets that and more as an unrestricted free-agent next summer, salary rollback be damned; hell, if P-A Parenteau is a $4 million a year player after being John Tavares's wingman, what does Hartnell deserve for having meshed well with both Jeff Carter and Claude Giroux with the Flyers?

Part of the wager here with Hartnell is that he's going to be a top-line player with Giroux for a good portion of that contract; which, conversely, is a wager that Jaromir Jagr wasn't more of an engine for that line's success than he's often given credit.

Well, save for Hartnell himself, to Dave Isaac of the Courier Post:

Although he started out the year on the fourth line, he quickly found his way to the top unit with Claude Giroux and Jaromir Jagr, where they all flourished.

"I have a lot left in the tank," said Hartnell, who will be 37 when the deal expires in 2019. "Last year was a good example. I give Jaromir Jagr a lot of credit for my success last year.

"I was more in-tune practicing with him than I was at any point in my career."

But projecting Hartnell's offensive numbers, which should wane anyway as he reaches his mid-30s, misses a more significant number when it comes to this contract: 147.

As in 147 PIMs on average over the last five seasons. That's enforcement, agitation and tone-setting from a vital forward on some very successful Flyers teams. That's the ability be as effective running his yap as he is running opponents:

A video or other embedded content has been hidden. Click here to view it.

From the Hartnell Down thing to the unbridled enthusiasm at the All-Star Game and the Winter Classic, who he is and what he does is infectious for the Flyers. (Granted, for some opponents it's like Ebola …)

Sign up for Yahoo Fantasy Hockey
Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.
    • Australia's Minjee Lee wins Blue Bay LPGA in China

      Australia's Minjee Lee wins Blue Bay LPGA in China

      Minjee Lee got up-and-down one last time at Jian Lake on Sunday to win the Blue Bay LPGA for her second victory of the year and third in two seasons. The 20-year-old Australian chipped to 3 feet from the front runoff area on the par-5 18th for her … More »

      AP - Sports - 2 minutes 46 seconds ago
    • Pinturault leads Hirscher after 1st run of WCup opening GS

      Alexis Pinturault of France and Marcel Hirscher of Austria continued their giant slalom dominance from last season as they finished 1-2 in the first run of the season-opening World Cup race on Sunday. Pinturault led the defending overall champion … More »

      AP - Sports - 2 minutes 46 seconds ago
    • Bangladesh stay alive in chase of 286 to win test

      Bangladesh stay alive in chase of 286 to win test

      (Reuters) - Bangladesh lost the top half of their batting order before tea as they chase 286 for victory against England on the fourth day of the closely-contested opening test at Chittagong on Sunday. With captain Mushfiqur Rahim (22) and Sabbir … More »

      Reuters - 45 minutes ago
    • Cubs fans dare to dream as Chicago's 'lovable losers' go to World Series

      By Nick Carey and Timothy Mclaughlin CHICAGO (Reuters) - Jubilant fans of the Chicago Cubs erupted in celebration on Saturday when the franchise clinched a berth in this year's World Series, pumped up by the dizzying prospect that their team could … More »

      Reuters - 1 hour 21 minutes ago
    • Sunderland match unwanted 110-year milestone

      Sunderland match unwanted 110-year milestone

      Sunderland became the first top-flight club in more than 100 years to fail to register a win in any of their first nine league games in two successive seasons when they suffered a 1-0 defeat by West Ham United on Saturday. Winston Reid's goal deep … More »

      Reuters - 1 hour 28 minutes ago