Puck Daddy

Rick Nash Derby: Shockingly, he’ll only go to six teams with great centers

Greg Wyshynski
Puck Daddy

View photo

.

Getty Images

Earlier this week, Aaron Portzline of the Columbus Dispatch updated the Rick Nash Derby (such as it is) with a definitive six-team list of approved destinations: The Boston Bruins, Detroit Red Wings, New York Rangers, Philadelphia Flyers, Pittsburgh Penguins and San Jose Sharks.

Three Original Sixers. Two storied franchises based in the Northeast. And the San Jose Sharks.

Or, in summary: Patrice Bergeron and/or Tyler Seguin; Pavel Datsyuk; Brad Richards; Claude Giroux and/or Danny Briere; Sidney Crosby and/or Evgeni Malkin; and Joe Thornton.

Nash has never had a star center. He scored 41 goals with Andrew Cassels as his center with the Columbus Blue Jackets, and meshed well with Manny Malhotra; otherwise, the Jackets have tried more options at the pivot for Nash than Senators have tried goaltenders in the last decade.

OK, he had Jeff Carter last season, so let's alter that to "Nash never had a star center who wasn't soul-crushingly bitter about his lot in life before winning a Stanley Cup with the LA Kings." Besides, the Carter experiment spoke to Nash's chemistry problem with some centers: Nash likes the puck. Carter likes the puck. There's only one puck. (Well, usually.)

So while Nash's apparent refusal to play nord of da border has gained infamy, his list also tells us what he's looking for in a roster to flourish as an offensive star.

From the Dispatch:

"To me, Rick Nash should not touch the puck before the offensive blue line," said former NHL forward Ed Olczyk, now a broadcaster with the Chicago Blackhawks and NBC Sports. "I mean, yeah, drop the puck back to a defenseman, sure, but he should not be carrying the puck up the ice, and you see that too much, in my opinion.

"His next team -- if you look at the teams on the list -- will have a distributing centerman and an offensive defenseman who can get the puck up the ice - bang! - right away. He needs to find somebody to play with -- somebody with high-end skill -- and play with them consistently, develop some chemistry and play off each other. Right now, teams scheme against him. It's just too easy to scheme against him the way he's played."

Every one of the teams on Nash's list has those two components, even if Detroit's elite puck-moving defenseman is now a scout in Europe. And as Joe Haggerty notes, at least one of the Bruins' centers would likely have to move to get Nash, and someone should tell Scott Howson is won't be Tyler Seguin.

Is it coincidental that the teams on Nash's list all have elite puck-distributing centers? Perhaps. Good teams usually do. Or Nash knows that wherever he goes, he doesn't want to be the object of affection for opposing defenses. He wants other players that can get him the puck and take the heat off him in coverage.

In theory, he also wants players — and coaches — that are going to allow him to grow as a player. Ray Ferraro of TSN had a great observation in the Dispatch about Nash having too much "junior" left in his game; as in, he tries to do too much on his own and thinks his size and power can overcome multiple player coverage from the defense, which it can't. (How very Lindrosian.) From Ferraro:

"He's not playing junior hockey any longer if he ends up in New York (John Tortorella) and Detroit (Mike Babcock), I'll promise you that. Those coaches will get it out of him in a hurry."

I still think Detroit is a fascinating destination, but don't the Wings need to focus a tad more on the blue line?

Sign up for Yahoo Fantasy Hockey
Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.
    • Harden scores 20 in Rockets' runaway win over Denver 128-110

      Harden scores 20 in Rockets' runaway win over Denver 128-110

      James Harden scored 20 points and the Rockets led from start to finish in beating the Denver Nuggets 128-110 on Friday night. Eric Gordon and Ryan Anderson had 18 points each and Sam Dekker added 17 for Houston, which completed an impressive … More »

      AP - Sports - 4 minutes 53 seconds ago
    • Former France coach Laporte named French federation president

      Former France coach Laporte named French federation president

      (Reuters) - Former France coach Bernard Laporte was appointed president of the French rugby federation on Saturday. Laporte, who led Les Bleus to the World Cup semi-finals in 2003 and 2007, came first ahead of incumbent Pierre Camou after a vote by … More »

      Reuters - 11 minutes ago
    • Ruthless Chelsea fight back to sink Man City

      Ruthless Chelsea fight back to sink Man City

      Chelsea came from behind to secure a dramatic 3-1 win at Manchester City and forge clear at the top of the Premier League as their top-of-the-table clash ended in a mass brawl and two City players were sent off on Saturday. Diego Costa, the … More »

      Reuters - 12 minutes ago
    • Tom Shields sets American record in 100-yard butterfly

      Olympian Tom Shields has set an American record in the 100-yard butterfly at the U.S. Winter Nationals. Shields, who won a gold medal in Rio as part of the 4x100-meter medley relay, became the first swimmer to break 44 seconds in the event. … More »

      AP - Sports - 24 minutes ago
    • Suspect in McKnight shooting released

      Suspect in McKnight shooting released

      A road rage incident possibly sparked by a driver cutting off another on a nearby bridge spiraled into a shooting that left an ex-NFL player dead, authorities said, amid criticism the shooter was allowed to go free. Joe McKnight, 28, was shot … More »

      AP - Sports - 36 minutes ago