What's buzzing:

Puck Daddy

More talk, more tension: NHL frustrated by NHLPA’s moving targets

Puck Daddy

View photo


Getty Images

NEW YORK -- What almost blew up talks Wednesday? Pensions.

Yes, pensions.

After the NHL made a counterproposal -- which included raising the so-called "make-whole" payments to $300 million -- the NHL Players' Association made pensions a priority. That surprised and angered the moderate owners, and that almost led to them walking out.

The owners have long been frustrated that the players' priorities have been a moving target. One of the reasons for Tuesday's owners-players powwow -- with NHL commissioner Gary Bettman and NHLPA executive director Don Fehr out of the room -- was to identify what each side really needed in this deal. The Toronto Maple Leafs' Larry Tanenbaum, one of the six owners involved in talks, said early Wednesday afternoon that there was "absolutely" more clarity in each sides' stance afterward.

But things clouded again Wednesday as the sides went back and forth, working on specifics instead of looking at the big picture. That goes for both sides. The owners moved significantly, but each part of their proposal is tied to the others. While one part might look good, another might look bad -- and the overall picture might look worse to the players.

The owners upped their so-called "make-whole" offer to $300 million -- up from $211 million, finding middle ground with the $393 million the players proposed previously. But that was tied to a 10-year collective bargaining agreement (with an out at eight years). The players haven't wanted to go longer than five years.

The owners also backed off on some contracting demands, keeping arbitration and free agency eligibility as it was in the last CBA. But they kept insisting on term limits -- five years, or seven if a team re-signs its own player -- and five-percent limit on salary variance to stop back-diving, cap-circumventing deals. The players have not wanted term limits, and they have their own proposal addressing cap circumvention in which a team's cap advantage is becomes a penalty if a player retires before his contract runs out.

There were tense moments Wednesday. Buffalo Sabres goalie Ryan Miller lashed out. Boston Bruins owner Jeremy Jacobs, the chairman of the board of governors and a hardliner, threatened to leave.

But the real danger is this: The players have gotten the owners to back off, and the rope-a-dope strategy has been effective. But if they keep ticking off the owners who came to make a deal, it could backfire. We could have another breakdown, another delay.

I am still optimistic there will be a season. I still think it is too early to panic, even if talks blow up Thursday -- a real possibility with Bettman and Fehr reentering the room. It is Dec. 6. The drop-dead date, though undefined, probably is still at least a month away.

The sides are too close not to make a deal. Too many people on both sides have been pushing too hard this week. But closing the deal is much easier said than done, especially if no one is sure where the finish line really is.

View Comments (50)
  • NCAA Hockey: Jack Eichel line leads BU; Minnesota annihilated

    NCAA Hockey: Jack Eichel line leads BU; Minnesota annihilated

    In which we recap the day’s events in the NCAA tournament. … More »

    Puck Daddy - 17 minutes ago
  • Stars-Canucks Preview

    A strong second half has the Vancouver Canucks primed to rejoin the postseason, but the ultra-competitive Western Conference won't afford them any comfort the rest of the way. With a slight cushion in the playoff race, the Canucks face off Saturday … More »

    AP - Sports - 6 hours ago
  • Bachman gets shutout, Oilers cool Stars

    Bachman gets shutout, Oilers cool Stars

    Richard Bachman got a win against his former team, and put a dent in their playoff chances. Bachman made 29 saves for his second NHL shutout and the Edmonton Oilers beat the Dallas Stars 4-0 on Friday night. ''On a selfish note, it feels good to … More »

    AP - Sports - 6 hours ago
  • Wild score 3 in 3rd to get past Flames

    Wild score 3 in 3rd to get past Flames

    The Minnesota Wild poured it on in the third period against the Calgary Flames. Thomas Vanek and Mikko Koivu scored early in a three-goal third period and the Wild pulled away to beat the Flames 4-2 on Friday night. Matt Dumba and Zach Parise also … More »

    AP - Sports - 6 hours ago
  • Richard Bachman makes 29 saves, earns shutout as Oilers blank Stars 4-0

    Richard Bachman makes 29 saves, earns shutout as Oilers blank Stars 4-0

    The Edmonton Oilers continue to mess with visiting teams' playoff plans. Richard Bachman made 29 saves to record his second-career shutout as the Oilers dealt the Dallas Stars' post-season prospects a blow with a 4-0 victory on Friday. Jordan … More »

    The Canadian Press - 7 hours ago