Puck Daddy

Marty St. Louis traded to NY Rangers for Ryan Callahan, picks in blockbuster

Greg Wyshynski
Puck Daddy
Marty St. Louis

View photo

NEW YORK, NY - FEBRUARY 10: Ryan Callahan #24 of the New York Rangers skates against Martin St. Louis #26 of the Tampa Bay Lightning at Madison Square Garden on February 10, 2013 in New York City. The Rangers defeat the Lightning 5-1. (Photo by Scott Levy/NHLI via Getty Images)

Marty St. Louis made a demand, got his wish and the powers in the Eastern Conference may have dramatically shifted to the New York Rangers – in the short term.

The Tampa Bay Lightning traded St. Louis to the Rangers on Wednesday for forward Ryan Callahan, a 2015 first-round pick and a 2014 second-round pick, with conditions.

It’s the first captain for captain trade in NHL deadline history.

Callahan was a pending UFA that couldn’t come to terms with the Rangers in time. Reports were that they had agreed to term (six years) but had a gulf of around $500,000 per season in money.

You have to give to get, and clearly GM Steve Yzerman wanted a top six forward from the Rangers if it meant sending his second best offensive player there. Callahan gives the Lightning a tenacious defensive forward and someone that gives them a net presence; how many Steven Stamkos slappers will sail through a Callahan screen, or generate rebounds for Callahan to cash in?

Plus, how does losing a heart and soul player like Ryan Callahan affect the Rangers’ room?

As for St. Louis and the Lightning … well, obviously they were at an end. Bringing him back after this public discourse with Yzerman was impossible; he would be a captain in name only after attempting to jump ship from a playoff team. The perception that his Olympic snub lit the fuse is inescapable, and not refuted by St. Louis. It’s frankly insulting to think that he’d allow that to necessitate this after ending up with a gold medal around his neck.

St. Louis is 38 and is signed through 2015. He’s a point per game player, and has maintained that pace without Stamkos in the lineup. The good news is Stamkos is back; the question is whether losing St. Louis is losing their grip on a playoff spot.

How does he fit in with the Rangers? On Brad Richards’ wing one assumes, with Carl Hagelin on the other side. It immediately upgrades the Rangers’ top six to one as potent as anything the Boston Bruins or Pittsburgh Penguins can roll out.

But it’s short term, and it borders on short-sighted. There was no market for St. Louis.

He wasn’t going anywhere but New York, with a home in Connecticut and a long-gestating desire to play with the Rangers. And yet they ship Callahan, a first and a second and potentially another pick if Callahan signs with the Lightning.

Per Pierre LeBrun: “The 2nd-rounder in 2014 to Tampa becomes a 1st if the Rangers get to conference final; if Callahan re-signs in Tampa then the Rangers get Tampa’s 2nd in 2015 and Tampa gets Rangers 7th in 2015.”

Again: St. Louis was only going to the Rangers. The bridges between him and the Lightning were smoldering. Yet Glen Sather anted up quite a bounty for him.

On the Milbury Scale:

View photo


The Milbury Scale 2014 - 3 Milbury

That’s a solid three. Yzerman wins the trade even before making a single pick. There’s no replacing St. Louis. He’s a special player. But Yzerman potentially just got a top-six captain and two first-rounders for a 38-year-old that was all boo-boo faced over an exhibition tournament snub.

The Rangers get a short-term boost, no doubt. But the cost is larger than St. Louis’ thighs.

Of course, if they win the Cup ...

More NHL coverage on Yahoo Sports:

Sign up for Yahoo Fantasy Hockey
Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.
    • Rowe, Panthers still hopeful for turnaround this season

      Rowe, Panthers still hopeful for turnaround this season

      The last few days have been filled with awkward moments for Florida Panthers interim coach Tom Rowe. First, there was the unfortunate scene where Gerard Gallant loaded his luggage into a taxi after getting fired as Florida's coach last week. … More »

      AP - Sports - 15 minutes ago
    • Ryan scores twice to lift Canes over Kings 3-1

      Ryan scores twice to lift Canes over Kings 3-1

      Derek Ryan waited longer than most NHL players for his chance. Ryan scored twice, Cam Ward made 21 saves and the Carolina Hurricanes beat the Los Angeles Kings 3-1 on Thursday night. Ryan had his first multigoal performance in 20 NHL games. … More »

      AP - Sports - 47 minutes ago
    • Dubnyk, Wild aim to shut down high-flying Oilers

      Maybe Bruce Boudreau was tired and cranky after his Minnesota Wild team concluded a five-game, 10-day road trip earlier in the week. "If (Dubnyk) was in Toronto there would be no Carey Price," Boudreau said, nodding to the notion that players on … More »

      AP - Sports - 1 hour 3 minutes ago
    • Darling, Blackhawks brace for Rangers

      For the past two-plus seasons, Chicago Blackhawks goaltender Scott Darling fulfilled his role as Corey Crawford's backup without complaint. Naturally, Darling has bigger dreams of becoming a No. 1 netminder. "I think that, being patient, he can … More »

      AP - Sports - 1 hour 9 minutes ago
    • Benn scores 200th goal, Stars beat Predators 5-2

      Benn scores 200th goal, Stars beat Predators 5-2

      For the first time this season, Dallas Stars coach Lindy Ruff started Jamie Benn and Tyler Seguin on a line centered by Jason Spezza. Benn scored his 200th career goal and added two assists, Spezza also had a goal and two assists, and Seguin added … More »

      AP - Sports - 1 hour 38 minutes ago