What's Buzzing:

Shutdown Corner

No flag, but no foul? Non-call on 49ers’ final incompletion will be debated (Video)

Frank Schwab
Shutdown Corner

The moment San Francisco 49ers Colin Kaepernick's final fourth-down pass hit the ground, the beginning of the debate could be heard on whether there should have been a penalty.

Baltimore Ravens cornerback Jimmy Smith was all over 49ers cornerback Michael Crabtree on a fade route. The Super Bowl hung in the balance, as the Ravens led 34-29 with less than two minutes left. The 49ers had just two timeouts left and as it turned out, they wouldn't get the ball back in time to run another offensive play.

A call would have given the 49ers a fresh set of downs and a great chance to take a lead with less than two minutes left in the Super Bowl. No call would practically end San Francisco's chances. With the world watching, it's an enormous pressure situation for the officials too.

[Wildest Super Bowl ever: The top 10 moments from Super Bowl XLVII]

The officials kept the flags in their pockets. 49ers coach Jim Harbaugh vehemently protested to no avail. A season that started with a full-blown controversy over replacement refs ended with fans wondering if the normal officials whiffed on a huge decision.

Watching the replays, CBS color commentator Phil Simms waffled back and forth on whether he thought Smith made a great play or it was a little more. It was a judgment call that could have gone either way, and it's rare that a defensive back gets the benefit of the doubt on such a play anymore.

[Joe Flacco validates himself with a Super Bowl MVP award]

Smith made initial contact within five yards, which was legal. Harbaugh emphatically signaled he thought it should have been a holding call, and Smith did get his left arm around enough to pin Crabtree's right arm very briefly. It was a very close call, and the officials didn't make it.

Whether it was a penalty or not doesn't really matter anymore. The Ravens won the Super Bowl. That won't stop people from debating if they thought Smith should have been flagged.

Don't miss a thing from New Orleans this week!
Follow @YShutdownCorner, and the Shutdown Corner Facebook page!

Popular Super Bowl video on Yahoo! Sports:

More Super Bowl content on Yahoo! Sports:
Super Bowl history: Champions and MVPs
Colin Kaepernick has chance to pull off a game-winning drive and falls short
John and Jim Harbaugh share sweet but awkward exchange after Super Bowl | Photos
Watch: Check out all of the Super Bowl ads | Commercials breakdown

View Comments (509)
  • Mayweather happy in retirement but hints at ring return

    Mayweather happy in retirement but hints at ring return

    (Reuters) - Floyd Mayweather Jr is happily retired but the 39-year-old unbeaten American hinted in an interview on Saturday that a return to the ring could not be completely ruled out. Mayweather quit boxing in September after accumulating a 49-0 … More »

    Reuters - 6 minutes ago
  • Boxing-Mayweather happy in retirement but hints at ring return

    Floyd Mayweather Jr is happily retired but the 39-year-old unbeaten American hinted in an interview on Saturday that a return to the ring could not be completely ruled out. Mayweather quit boxing in September after accumulating a 49-0 record during … More »

    Reuters - 18 minutes ago
  • Formula One sets July deadline for cockpit device

    Formula One sets July deadline for cockpit device

    By Alan Baldwin SOCHI, Russia (Reuters) - Formula One will decide by July which head protection device it favours for 2017 with more testing likely at the Spanish and Monaco Grands Prix, race director Charlie Whiting said on Sunday. Red Bull … More »

    Reuters - 21 minutes ago
  • Leicester seek to clinch title with win at Old Trafford

    Leicester seek to clinch title with win at Old Trafford

    The champagne is at the ready, the Premier League trophy in place but what used to be a routine occurrence at Old Trafford will have a surreal twist on Sunday if Leicester City beat Manchester United there to clinch the title. Leicester's cast-iron … More »

    Reuters - 30 minutes ago
  • Piller hits every green en route to two-shot LPGA lead

    Piller hits every green en route to two-shot LPGA lead

    (Reuters) - American Gerina Piller produced another ball-striking clinic in the third round at the Texas Shootout on Saturday to earn a two-shot lead and put herself in position for her first LPGA title. The world number 20, in her sixth LPGA … More »

    Reuters - 33 minutes ago