What's Buzzing:

Shutdown Corner

Jerry Rice responds to Randy Moss’ claim that he’s the greatest receiver ever

Frank Schwab
Shutdown Corner

View gallery


(USA Today Sports Images)

Nothing against Randy Moss and his bravado, but Jerry Rice is the greatest receiver ever. Since he's the greatest NFL player ever, that only makes sense.

Moss made some waves during media day when he said he thought he was the greatest receiver ever. Well, it turns out that Rice is in New Orleans as part of ESPN's Super Bowl coverage, and the subject was obviously brought up to Rice, who thought what most everyone else did.

"I’m very surprised Randy Moss used that in those words, that he’s the greatest," Rice said on ESPN's "NFL Live." "You’d never hear me say I’m the greatest football player to ever play the game. I let my body of work speak for itself, and I think I was able to be very productive on the football field.

Moss said that he can't be defined by stats, but that seemed to flummox Rice as well.

[Y! Sports Fan Shop: Buy Super Bowl XLVII merchandise]

"You have to look at the stats, you have to look at how you impacted the game, and it’s all about winning this right here, this is it, the Super Bowl, and I was fortunate to win three," said Rice, who was rightfully ranked No. 1 on the NFL Network's ranking of the top 100 players of all time in 2010. "Randy he finally has a chance to prove himself this weekend, and I wish him the best."

So that's settled. But where does Moss rank among the GOATs? Well, here's a stab at it:

1. Rice
No need discussing this further.

2. Don Hutson

View gallery



It's hard to compare players of different eras, but Hutson dominated his. An eight-time first-team All-Pro, Hutson led the league in receptions eight times in 11 seasons (finishing second twice and sixth once), first in yards seven times (finishing second three times and third once), and led the league in receiving touchdowns nine times (finishing second twice). That's unbelievable production. This one is as easy as ranking Rice first.

3. Moss
The thing about Moss is what might have been. What if he hadn't mailed in the Oakland part of his career, what if he hadn't had such a bad attitude that seemed to overshadow what he did on the field at times, and so forth. But here's a list: Rice, Emmitt Smith, LaDainian Tomlinson. The answer? The only human beings with more NFL touchdowns than Moss' 157. And let's not forget, if not for David Tyree, Moss would have a fourth-quarter game-winning catch in a Super Bowl to go with his other tremendous accomplishments.

[Related: Kaepernick taking silence-is-golden approach to media circus]

4. Calvin Johnson

View gallery


(USA Today Sports Images)

Too soon? Well, if he retired today, he'd still be the only player with two of the top eight greatest seasons for a receiver in NFL history, in terms of receiving yards. His 1,964 this year is the best ever, and his 1,681 last year is eighth. Rice only makes the top 10 in single-season receiving yards once (he is second; his next best season is 20th). Johnson also slogged along with some bad quarterbacks before Matt Stafford, and is just 27. He's likely the most physically gifted receiver we've ever seen. We will be talking about this guy long after he retires. So scoff if you wish, but if we were picking teams, I'd be more than happy with Megatron over anyone but the three listed above him here.

5. Lance Alworth
Tough call over Terrell Owens and Marvin Harrison, but Alworth dominated his era. Alworth led the AFL in either receptions, receiving yards or receiving touchdowns three times each and was first-team All-Pro six straight seasons from 1963-68. He averaged a staggering 18.9 yards per catch, impressive for a guy who was in the top seven of the league in receptions seven straight seasons.

Don't miss a thing from New Orleans this week!
Follow @YShutdownCorner, and the Shutdown Corner Facebook page!

NFL video from Yahoo! Sports:

Other popular content on Yahoo! Sports:
Dan Wetzel: Atlanta deaths still weigh on Ray Lewis
Jim Harbaugh responds to President Obama's fear of football violence
NBA Power Rankings: Spurs are new No. 1
Alex Rodriguez the biggest name in new PED report | Denials

Sign up for Yahoo Fantasy Hockey
Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.
    • Australia quick Pattinson fit but rules out test return

      Australia quick Pattinson fit but rules out test return

      Australia fast bowler James Pattinson is ready to return to cricket next month after being out of action since February due to injury but has ruled out playing tests this year. The right-arm quick returned from injury in the second test against New … More »

      Reuters - 20 minutes ago
    • Klopp hits back at doubters for questioning Liverpool defence

      Klopp hits back at doubters for questioning Liverpool defence

      (Reuters) - Liverpool manager Juergen Klopp has said that he is losing respect for critics who continue to question his side's defensive frailties. Liverpool overcame a nervy finish to beat West Brom 2-1 on Saturday, but Gareth McAuley's late goal … More »

      Reuters - 22 minutes ago
    • Bangladesh hope Chittagong marks a test turning point

      While their limited-overs side have already savoured victories over the world's top sides, Bangladesh cricket hopes their narrow defeat to England over five days in Chittagong will be a watershed moment for the test team. Bangladesh sent England … More »

      Reuters - 50 minutes ago
    • Finnish minnows IFK Mariehamn win league title

      Finnish minnows IFK Mariehamn hailed their team spirit and work ethic after capturing a stunning first league championship in a thrilling climax to the season. Dubbed "mini-Leicester" by local media in a salute to last season's surprise English … More »

      Reuters - 1 hour 9 minutes ago
    • Wilshere keen to make most of loan spell at Bournemouth

      Wilshere keen to make most of loan spell at Bournemouth

      (Reuters) - Jack Wilshere said he was stepping outside his comfort zone when he joined Bournemouth in August but feels eager to make major strides during his loan spell after a string of injuries stunted the midfielder's progress at Arsenal. Once … More »

      Reuters - 1 hour 26 minutes ago