What's buzzing:

Dr. Saturday

Your take: Should the SEC base divison champs on division wins?

Graham Watson
Dr. Saturday

View photo


(Gerald Herbert/AP)

Your Take is a chance to start to thoughtful, spirited, intelligent and nice conversation about some of the hotter topics in college football. It allows the reader to have a voice as the best comments will be compiled into a later post (if there are enough good comments). Join in the conversation and have your thoughts heard.

LSU coach Les Miles wants the SEC to examine how it chooses its division champions.

Miles, who was speaking in Birmingham at a luncheon for the Changed Lives Christian Center, said he was in favor of counting just games within the division toward the division title.

"I want the schedule to be fair and I want it to give everybody the same opportunity," Miles told the Birmingham News. "I'm for the Western Division deciding the Western Division champion and the Eastern Division deciding the Eastern Division champion."

South Carolina coach Steve Spurrier suggested the same idea, but SEC commissioner Mike Slive said he didn't think it would be fair to make some games more important than others. However, the intense rivalry games between teams from the East and West Divisions have often made the road to the division title difficult. LSU currently plays Florida every year in its cross-divisional rivalry game while Alabama plays Tennessee. In the past, Florida has been a much tougher opponent than the Vols.

Currently, those cross-divisional rivalries don't appear to be going anywhere. With the addition of Texas A&M and Missouri this season, the league is scheduled to play six division games, one cross-divisional rivalry game and one rotating game against a team from the opposite division.

"Eventually they will realize it doesn't benefit either team," Miles told the paper. "If you would go back and look at the number of wins historically since 2000, I think you'll find LSU, Georgia, Florida and Alabama would be right in that mix. I think you should seed those people away from each other if you want an opportunity for the best teams to be the best teams without eliminating each other's opportunity of winning."

What do you think about the Miles-Spurrier plan? Should the SEC pick its division champs based on division games? Or should the teams with the best overall records — regardless of whom they play — continue to represent in Atlanta?

This isn't a novel concept. Most sports and others college football conferences base their division champs on division wins and use the overall conference wins as a tiebreaker. It seems like the fairest way to pick division champions.

What's your take?

- - -
"Like" Dr. Saturday on Facebook for football conversations and stuff you won't see on the blog. And follow Dr. Saturday at its new home on Twitter: @YahooDrSaturday

View Comments (14)
  • What happens when KHL team refuses to pay its players? (Puck Daddy Interview)

    What happens when KHL team refuses to pay its players? (Puck Daddy Interview)

    Mark Dekanich isn’t your typical athlete looking for extra money. He just wants what he’s owed by Medvescak Zagreb because he says the team hasn’t paid him for services rendered. … More »

    Puck Daddy - 6 minutes ago
  • Dredge leads at Russian Open

    Bradley Dredge shot 5-under 66 Friday to lead the Russian Open by one stroke at the halfway stage. The Welshman started the day tied for third but had a bogey-free second round for 10-under 132 overall after teeing off on a damp morning at the … More »

    AP - Sports - 13 minutes ago
  • Man United says Madrid 'clumsiness' at fault in De Gea spat

    Man United says Madrid 'clumsiness' at fault in De Gea spat

    Manchester United says Real Madrid is trying to deflect attention from its own ''clumsiness'' by blaming the English club for the collapse of David de Gea's transfer. De Gea failed to secure his desired move to Madrid before Monday's transfer … More »

    AP - Sports - 17 minutes ago
  • Oliveira of Portugal wins 13th Vuelta stage, Aru keeps lead

    Oliveira of Portugal wins 13th Vuelta stage, Aru keeps lead

    Nelson Oliveira of Portugal sped away to win the 13th stage of the Spanish Vuelta, while Fabio Aru kept his lead on Friday before the Grand Tour enters three straight days in the mountains. Oliveira broke free from an escape group of 24 riders with … More »

    AP - Sports - 18 minutes ago
  • Astana thrown out of MPCC

    PARIS (AP) -- Astana has been thrown out of the Movement for Credible Cycling for a breach of the group's regulations. … More »

    AP - Sports - 20 minutes ago