Dr. Saturday

Doc Five: Ways to make college football’s Final Four perfect – No. 1, expand it to eight teams

Frank Schwab
Dr. Saturday

View photo

.

(USA Today Sports Images)

This offseason we will count down various topics from Monday through Friday, bringing you the top five of the important and definitely some not so important issues in college football. It's the Doc Five, every week until we will thankfully have actual games to discuss.

WAYS TO MAKE COLLEGE FOOTBALL'S FINAL FOUR PERFECT

NO. 1, EXPAND IT TO EIGHT TEAMS

Don't be fooled, the college football playoff that will be begin in the 2014 season isn't the perfect solution.

The college football powers were happy to slap the term "playoff" on what they're offering and try to appease the fans. It's better than the current setup. That's not saying much.

Expanding the championship from two teams to four won't be the final answer, we hope. Maybe four teams is just a test run. Figure out the logistics – and realize how much money it will make.

Then after a few years, make it a real playoff.

The NCAA tournament has figured out ways for its "student-athletes" that it tries so mightily not to exploit to participate in a three-week playoff event. Those players survive it. Two football teams every year would be exposed to possibly playing 16 games, with a conference championship and 12 regular-season games. Right now, two teams have the possibility of playing 15 games. It's not that big of a difference.

This not the "bigger is better" argument. Expanding the NCAA tournament to 96 games was an all-time awful proposal that thankfully was shot down before basketball's postseason was ruined. Similarly, a 16-team playoff (or even 12 with byes) isn't ideal for football. The 16th-best team in college football doesn't have a right to play for a championship. But four isn't enough either.

Four teams is going to leave a few deserving clubs wondering why they weren't included. Using this number, it seems as tough as ever for a team outside of the major conferences to ever get a shot. And, really, that was probably the point of settling on four. It also makes it tough to sort out which four teams from the SEC, Big Ten, Pac-12, Big 12 and ACC are most deserving. Someone from that group is getting left out. Not that all of those conferences produce playoff-worthy champs every year, but there will be many years when the fifth team will have a comparable resume to the third or fourth teams in the playoff. And four teams doesn't leave much wiggle room for deserving at-large teams either, much less the years Notre Dame needs a spot among the top four.

Eight teams gives the playoff a bit of everything. A deserving major-conference champion won't get left out. There's room for at-large teams that obviously deserve a chance. There is also room for smaller conference teams that earn a shot. And when it comes down to it, the ninth team in the pecking order won't usually have a compelling argument that it got unfairly left out. An eight-team playoff would be the most fair way to determine the champion. As long as the field stays at four, the playoff will need fixing.

Besides, is there anyone in America who would be against four more college football playoff games every year?

- - -
Want to join the conversation? Hit us up on Twitter @YahooDrSaturday and be sure to "Like" Dr. Saturday on Facebook for football conversations and stuff you won't see on the blog.

Sign up for Yahoo Fantasy Hockey
Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.
    • Bryce Harper and Noah Syndergaard are building an old school feud

      Bryce Harper and Noah Syndergaard are building an old school feud

      Noah Syndergaard (left) and Bryce Harper are not on the best of terms? As if the escalating tensions at Yankees camp weren’t enough drama for the opening weekend of spring training, the rivalry between the Nationals and Mets — and specifically … More »

      Big League Stew - 1 hour 14 minutes ago
    • Bye-week curse has NHL at a loss

      Bye-week curse has NHL at a loss

      The NHL instituted bye-weeks this season as a kickback to the players, in exchange for their agreeing to skate their hung-over asses off in a 3-on-3 All-Star Game tournament format. But the byes are also for the sake of player safety in the regular … More »

      Puck Daddy - 3 hours ago
    • Missouri Mavericks honor Negro League's Monarchs with special jerseys (Video)

      Missouri Mavericks honor Negro League's Monarchs with special jerseys (Video)

      The ECHL’s Missouri Mavericks won their sixth in a row with a 2-1 win over the Quad City Mallards Saturday, and before and during the game they paid tribute to a big part of Kansas City’s history. The Mavericks honored the 75th anniversary of the … More »

      Puck Daddy - 4 hours ago
    • Yahoo Daily Fantasy Hockey: Sunday picks

      Yahoo Daily Fantasy Hockey: Sunday picks

      Cam Ward, CAR vs. TOR ($24): Ward is too affordable to pass up against a struggling Toronto team. Expect those struggles to continue on the second night of a back-to-back against Ward, who has held his last four opponents at PNC Arena to a total of … More »

      Puck Daddy - 5 hours ago
    • NHL Three Stars: Stone's 5-spot for Sens; Roussel nets first hat trick

      NHL Three Stars: Stone's 5-spot for Sens; Roussel nets first hat trick

      Ottawa Senators centre Derick Brassard (19) left wing Ryan Dzingel (18) and right wing Mark Stone (61) celebrate a goal by Chris Wideman (not shown) during third period NHL hockey action against the Toronto Maple Leafs in Toronto on Saturday, Feb. … More »

      Puck Daddy - 13 hours ago