What's Buzzing:

Big League Stew

Yet another blown call that could have been easily corrected by replay (Video)

Kevin Kaduk
Big League Stew

If every bad postseason call and the ensuing outcry counts as a move toward the logical adoption of instant replay then the good news is that we made some progress this weekend.

The bad news is that yet another postseason game had to be unnecessarily marred by baseball's slow crawl to reason. One night after a wrong call at first base killed an early Yankees rally in Game 1, second base umpire Jeff Nelson booted a much easier call in Sunday's Game 2. Nelson's error in judgment — he ruled Omar Infante safe in the eighth inning when Robinson Cano had clearly tagged him as he scrambled to get back to the bag — unnecessarily extended the inning and allowed the Tigers to add an extra two runs in a 3-0 win at Yankee Stadium.

Though the impotent Yankees offense couldn't turn the call into a full-blown controversy by managing to score a run in their final two turns at the plate, it was the first order of business in the press conference for Yankees manager Joe Girardi (who was thrown out of the game for arguing the call). Resident MLB wonk Joe Torre was even summoned to the interview room, where he passed along the news that Nelson admitted to getting the call wrong.

[Related: Yankees try to disguise empty seats at ALCS by moving fans]

Here's what Girardi had to say about the call after the game (via ASAP Sports):

View gallery


(Getty Images)

"It's frustrating.  I don't have a problem with Jeff's effort, I don't, because he hustled to get to the play.  But in this day and age when we have instant replay available to us, it's got to change.  These guys are under tremendous amounts of pressure.  It is a tough call for him because the tag is underneath and it's hard for him to see.  And it takes more time to argue and get upset than you get the call right.  Too much is at stake.  We play 235 days to get to this point, and two calls go against us.  We lose it by one run last night.

"And I'm not saying if Robby Cano is safe last night that it changes the game.  The outcome may be the same, but I like to take my chances.  There is more pressure on the pitchers when it is 1‑0 in the eighth inning and your club is hitting than 3‑0.  I would like to take my chances."

As I wrote after the blown call on Cano at first base on Saturday night, there aren't many non-Yankees fans who are going to cry over the pinstripes having a break go against them. But maybe there should be because I'm of the belief that Bud Selig will never be pressured into action until it clearly costs the Yankees a postseason win and the New York media unleashes its hounds on the commissioner. What's some temporary sympathy for the Yankees when it means fixing baseball's most glaring weakness?

Still, it's ludicrous that baseball isn't close to implementing a review system, even if it's just a guy in the pressbox with a box of popcorn and his own television. Allowing these bad calls to stand is bad for the game, no matter who they're going against.

View gallery



Make sure all of your bases are covered this postseason ...
Follow @bigleaguestew@KevinKaduk and the BLS Facebook page!

Related MLB video from Yahoo! Sports:

Other popular content on the Yahoo! network:
Devastating news for fearsome NFL star Ray Lewis
Will Silva-Jones become UFC's version of Pacquiao-Mayweather?
Disturbing accident before game will sideline Giants' Roberto Kelly for several days
GrindTV.com: Daredevil breaks sound barrier during skydive

Sign up for Yahoo Fantasy Hockey
View Comments (380)
  • Edmund makes baptism of fire in Davis Cup final

    Edmund makes baptism of fire in Davis Cup final

    By Martyn Herman GHENT, Belgium (Reuters) - Unheralded British youngster Kyle Edmund faces a Davis Cup baptism of fire when he makes his debut in the final on Friday against Belgium's David Goffin in the opening rubber. The 20-year-old, ranked … More »

    Reuters - 26 minutes ago
  • FIFA recovers and donates 48 luxury watches to non-profit organization

    FIFA ethics committee has donated 48 luxury watches it recovered from soccer officials to a non-profit organization. The CBF initially said the Parmigiani watches were given to a group of 65 officials but the investigatory chamber of the ethics … More »

    The Canadian Press - 33 minutes ago
  • Ashwin, Jadeja among wickets as India pushes for victory

    Ashwin, Jadeja among wickets as India pushes for victory

    Spinners Ravichandran Ashwin and Ravindra Jadeja were among the wickets on Thursday as India pressed for victory in the third test after dismissing South Africa for a meagre 79. South Africa was 32-2 in its second innings chasing 310 for victory … More »

    AP - Sports - 34 minutes ago
  • 2 Russian weightlifters and dancer banned for doping

    The Russian anti-doping agency says two weightlifters and a sport dancer have been banned for doping. The weightlifters include Russian junior silver medalist Azamat Dzhioev, who received a four-year ban. Also suspended is Russian Cup bronze … More »

    AP - Sports - 40 minutes ago
  • Canada's Hannah upgraded to Pan Am Games bronze medal in marathon

    Canada's Rachel Hannah will receive a bronze medal from the marathon at Toronto's Pan American Games. The Toronto runner finished fourth in the race last July, but winner Gladys Tejeda of Peru was stripped of her gold medal after a failed doping … More »

    The Canadian Press - 45 minutes ago