What's Buzzing:

Big League Stew

Topps erases Pete Rose from baseball cards

Big League Stew

View gallery



Pete Rose has not appeared on his own Topps card since Major League Baseball banned him in 1989. Any player on the permanently ineligible list is prohibited from being included in any licensed MLB product. And that doesn't only go for the picture on the front and the "complete batting record" on the back, apparently.

Author Rob Harris of Chicagoside noticed that any mention of Rose's name has been scrubbed from Topps first new set of cards for 2013 — even when its inclusion seems organic.

He writes about the '13 set:

On the back of each card, wedged between each player’s personal information and his “Complete Major and Minor League Batting Record,” there’s a little line labeled “Career Chase.” On every card, whether the player is a living legend or a rookie, there is a sentence indicating how close that player is to reaching one of the game’s big records.

So, for example, it says on the card for Paul Konerko that his 422 career home runs "are 340 shy of Barry Bonds’ record of 762." Everybody in the set gets a blurb like this. "Player 'X' is 4,000 shy of Nolan Ryan's record, or Cy Young's, etc." Only, this is what it says on the card of A.J. Pierzynski:

[Related: Topps unveils the world’s largest baseball card]

View gallery


(via Chicagoside)

I guess it's not Pete Rose's record anymore! It would be one thing if none of the record holders were named on any of the cards. Then nobody would have noticed Pete Rose's name not being there for hits. Harris did get Topps to comment, though:

Clay Luraschi, a spokesman for Topps, called the omission of Rose “a simple decision” but declined to elaborate. When pressed, he repeated that it was “plain and simple” that Rose’s name should not appear on cards.

So it appears to be related to MLB ban and not to, say, a dispute over licensing monies (even though players get paid through their union, not the league, when it comes to their likeness, and Rose would seem to be in good standing with the MLBPA). Topps wants to keep its license with MLB, and that's obviously understandable. It also might be taking Rose's ban a little far.

(And before you EVEN bring it up: Yes, Barry Bonds' name has been associated with PEDs and he's been punished for it by the BBWAA when it comes to the Hall of Fame vote. But he hasn't been punished by MLB. He's not ineligible for anything — like Rose, or the Black Sox guys. So he can be on cards, according to the rules.)

UPDATE: Has Topps ever so obviously scrubbed Rose's name before? @Nightowlcards came across this from 2010:

(Via @Nightowlcards)

No mention of stats that Rose leads in — hits, doubles, runs, walks, at-bats. It's not proof of anything, but it's a little curious. And much more subtle. This is how to omit Pete Rose without letting on you're doing it.

UPDATE II: Rose's name somehow slipped through the cracks in this 2006 Topps card of Shawn Green:

View gallery


(Via @nightowlcards)

A slip-up? Or has there been a change in policy?

It seems like Topps could have used some creative license. Not producing new Pete Rose cards is one thing — after all, that's the rule. And not making it so obvious that he's banned would have been OK, too. MLB can keep Pete Rose's plaque out of the Hall of Fame. But the league isn't going to leave Cooperstown because the museum still shows Pete Rose exhibits that include his memorabilia. The Hall of Fame still acknowledges Pete Rose happened. MLB probably isn't going to cut off Topps because Pete Rose's name is on the back of some cards.

Besides, scrubbing his name off the back — in this particular case — comes off as petty. And vengeful, from MLB's standpoint. OK, we get it, Pete Rose has been banned, you're all mighty and powerful.

Most of all, it's also a lie by omission. Pete Rose happened. Remember?

Big BLS H/N: CeeAngi

Pitchers and catchers are reporting!
Follow @AnswerDave, @MikeOz, @Townie813 and @bigleaguestew, on Twitter,
along with the BLS Facebook page!

Fantasy Baseball video from Yahoo! Sports

Other popular content on Yahoo! Sports:
Jadeveon Clowney should challenge NFL's 'three-years-out' rule
Kentucky's Nerlens Noel has torn ACL, out for season
MJ's decision to play for Wizards doomed his legacy in Washington
David Beckham's first training session with PSG ... boring

Sign up for Yahoo Fantasy Hockey
View Comments (4369)
  • Saints' Fonte backs Long to fill Pelle's boots against City

    Saints' Fonte backs Long to fill Pelle's boots against City

    (Reuters) - Southampton skipper Jose Fonte has backed Shane Long to fill the void created by the club's leading scorer Graziano Pelle, who will miss Saturday's Premier League clash against Manchester City after picking up his fifth booking of the … More »

    Reuters - 11 minutes ago
  • Gerrard to train with Liverpool but rules out loan return

    Gerrard to train with Liverpool but rules out loan return

    (Reuters) - Steven Gerrard will return to former club Liverpool to train next week and is looking forward to learning from manager Juergen Klopp, but has ruled out returning to Anfield in a playing capacity. Gerrard, who plays in the United States … More »

    Reuters - 24 minutes ago
  • Exclusive - Brazil's Petrobras corruption investigators to probe Olympic contracts

    Exclusive - Brazil's Petrobras corruption investigators to probe Olympic contracts

    By Caroline Stauffer SAO PAULO (Reuters) - Brazilian police investigating corruption around state-run oil firm Petrobras also plan to probe more than $10 billion of construction contracts for the 2016 Olympic Games in Rio de Janeiro, a lead … More »

    Reuters - 31 minutes ago
  • UNC closes on 21-3 run to beat K-State

    UNC closes on 21-3 run to beat K-State

    North Carolina coach Roy Williams runs a drill in practice designed to mimic exactly what the Tar Heels faced against Kansas State, an eight-point deficit in the closing minutes. Justin Jackson scored 22 points and Kennedy Meeks added 15 as … More »

    AP - Sports - 33 minutes ago
  • Morkel strikes as India reaches 149-6 at tea in Nagpur test

    Morkel strikes as India reaches 149-6 at tea in Nagpur test

    South Africa pace bowler Morne Morkel took two more wickets in the second session as India struggled to capitalize on batting first, reaching 149-6 at tea on the first day Wednesday of the third test. Morkel dismissed Ajinkya Rahane (13) and … More »

    AP - Sports - 48 minutes ago