What's buzzing:

Big League Stew

Minor leaguer Cody Decker disputes scouting report, offers to provide shirtless photo evidence

Mark Townsend
Big League Stew

View gallery


Cody Decker (right/Getty Images)

When the baseball news cycle slows down over the holidays, we start scratching and clawing for every bit of information we can find to satisfy our thirst.

That includes scouring the rumor mills with regularity, checking in with the beat writers on Twitter almost hourly, and even searching for scouting reports to learn a little bit more about the up and coming talent around the game.

That’s what some San Diego Padres were fans doing this week when they came across a piece written by Rich Wilson of Prospect361.com, where he ranked the organizations top ten prospects. When one reader noticed the name of Cody Decker missing from the list, he asked Wilson for an answer, which he received.

‘Well at least you didn’t say Jaff Decker. Cody will be 26 next year and struggled in AAA before moving back to AA where he hit for a lot of power. Not a physical specimen at 5-foot-11 and 240ish but has a highly leveraged swing that when he makes contact, goes a long way. Bat speed is really slow though and he struggles against breaking pitches. Right-handed 1B really need to hit and he doesn’t. Poor man’s Matt Adams?

Not really a prospect for me but could be an extra bat off the bench in the big leagues. Statistical profile is similar to Sands but I like Sands bat better. Mind you, I don’t see Jerry Sands as a regular big league outfielder, but I put him a notch above Decker.’

Another person who read Wilson’s less than encouraging response was Decker himself, and let’s just say he had a little problem with Wilson‘s weight guesstimation and the breakdown of his swing. Take a look.

View gallery



Decker confirmed his response via Twitter on Friday, just in case you wondered if someone may have been posing as him.

On his baseball reference profile, Decker is listed as 5-foot-11 and 220 lbs, which matches up with his side of that story. And having never seen him play, I can't really say whether or not Wilson's other findings are completely inaccurate. I can look at his numbers though and see he has slugged 87 home runs in four seasons while posting a healthy .895, so the ball does indeed travel when he squares it up.

I don't know if that's enough to make him a real prospect, and that's really not even the point of why I'm writing. I just thought Decker's response was humorous and even a little refreshing since you know he's not the only player who's ever disagreed with a scouting report.

Good for him for standing up for himself. Also, I hope he's prepared to deal with the endless stream of shirtless photo requests he's likely already receiving.

Big BLS H/N: Eye on Baseball

Looking for more baseball chatter?
Follow @bigleaguestew, @Townie813 and check out the BLS Facebook Page

View Comments (9)
  • Indians Cody Anderson loses perfect game in 7th inning

    Indians Cody Anderson loses perfect game in 7th inning

    Somewhere around the fourth inning, Cody Anderson realized he was chasing perfection. ''I kind of knew that everything was going pretty smooth,'' Cleveland's rookie right-hander said after taking a bid for a perfect game into the seventh inning of … More »

    AP - Sports - 10 minutes ago
  • Altuve helps Astros to 6-1 win over Royals

    Altuve helps Astros to 6-1 win over Royals

    Chris Carter and Jose Altuve homered to back a solid start by rookie Lance McCullers, and the Houston Astros beat the Kansas City Royals 6-1 on Monday night. In a matchup of teams with the best records in the American League, Houston snapped Kansas … More »

    AP - Sports - 13 minutes ago
  • Rays stymied by Anderson, Indians 7-1

    Rays stymied by Anderson, Indians 7-1

    The Tampa Bay Rays were stymied again. This time it was Cleveland rookie Cody Anderson's turn to shut them down. Anderson took a perfect game into the seventh inning in his second major league start, and the struggling Indians snapped a three-game … More »

    AP - Sports - 17 minutes ago
  • Blue Jays' potent offence silences by Buchholz in 3-1 loss to Red Sox

    Blue Jays' potent offence silences by Buchholz in 3-1 loss to Red Sox

    Jose Bautista's potent bat has been unusually silent lately. Bautista's hitless streak reached six games on Monday as the Blue Jays fell 3-1 to the Boston Red Sox at Rogers Centre. "He's squaring some balls up, he was on a nice little roll but … More »

    The Canadian Press - 23 minutes ago
  • LEADING OFF: Sale's K streak, Verlander and Hamilton back

    LEADING OFF: Sale's K streak, Verlander and Hamilton back

    A look at what's happening all around the major leagues Tuesday: … More »

    AP - Sports - 45 minutes ago