Big League Stew

Harold Reynolds had a good explanation of why the infield fly rule call was a correct one (Video)

Kevin Kaduk
Big League Stew

When all the Turner Field trash throwing and Internet outrage had subsided on Friday night, MLB Network's Harold Reynolds offered a detailed and measured explanation of why he thought left field umpire Sam Holbrook had applied the infield fly rule call correctly. Using footage of similar calls from the past and a second-by-second breakdown of the play that helped seal Atlanta's wild card fate, Reynolds' lesson was the best I saw all night and that included the onsite press conference from Joe Torre and the umpiring crew.

Look, I can admit when I'm wrong and, after seeing the former infielder talk about the play, I think I agree that Holbrook interpreted the rule as written and that he acted no differently from a lot of routine regular season call that we never give a second thought.

View gallery

.

(Getty/TBS)

I still believe the rule is an ill-written one, though. The MLB rulebook defines an infield fly rule as a fly that an infielder can catch with an "ordinary effort" and there's just too much room for judgment and interpretation in that. How can you define such a play as "ordinary" when it's not immediately apparent that the infielder can make the catch? How can you apply such a routine label when a shortstop has to backpedal a significant distance while an outfielder approaches and an opposing crowd screams its head off? It seems to me that no "ordinary" play should involve so many hurdles or factors for an umpire to check off before he declares the rule in play.

So what's the solution? I'm not sure we need one given that we wouldn't even be talking about this had St. Louis shortstop Pete Kozma made the catch. St. Louis outfielder Carlos Beltran said he had never seen anything like it, so it'll be awhile before we see it again.

If we did need one, though, I suppose it would include a definition of distance. Maybe we could the joke photo from one Redditor to help aid umpires in the future?

View gallery

.

(Reddit)

Are you ready for the postseason?
Follow @bigleaguestew, @KevinKaduk and the BLS Facebook page!

Sign up for Yahoo Fantasy Hockey
Sorry you didn't like this comment. Please provide a reason below.

Are you sure?
Rating failed. Try again.
Request failed. Try again.
We will promote constructive and witty comments to the top, so everyone sees them!
Sorry, we can’t load comments right now. Try again.
    • Youngstown State eliminates Wofford in 2 OTs

      Youngstown State eliminates Wofford in 2 OTs

      Tevin McCaster's 2-yard touchdown run in the second overtime provided the winning margin as Youngstown State edged visiting Wofford 30-23 in the national quarterfinals at Stambaugh Stadium. The Penguins (11-3), from the Missouri Valley Football … More »

      AP - Sports - 2 minutes 22 seconds ago
    • Lousiville's Lamar Jackson wins Heisman Trophy

      Lousiville's Lamar Jackson wins Heisman Trophy

      NEW YORK (AP) -- Lamar Jackson is the first Louisville player to win the Heisman Trophy, beating out preseason favorite Deshaun Watson of Clemson despite some late-season struggles. … More »

      AP - Sports - 4 minutes 12 seconds ago
    • Ingram gives UNC-Wilmington 81-80 win over St. Bonaventure

      SAINT BONAVENTURE, N.Y. (AP) -- Denzel Ingram scored on a step-back jumper at the buzzer and North Carolina-Wilmington defeated St. Bonaventure 81-80 on Saturday night. … More »

      AP - Sports - 4 minutes 30 seconds ago
    • Eastern Washington shuts out Richmond to reach FCS semis

      Eastern Washington shuts out Richmond to reach FCS semis

      Oh, the high-powered offense is still rolling, but the Eagles don't necessarily have to overcome their defense by winning shootouts. Eastern Washington (12-1), a Big Sky Conference co-champion, will host Youngstown State (11-3) from the Missouri … More »

      AP - Sports - 4 minutes 32 seconds ago
    • Mary Hardin-Baylor ends Mount Union's Stagg Bowl streak

      For the first time in 12 seasons, Mount Union will not appear in the Division III championship game. In its place, Mary Hardin-Baylor will play in its first Stagg Bowl since 2004 - the season before Mount Union's 11-year streak began. Mary … More »

      AP - Sports - 4 minutes 32 seconds ago