What's buzzing:

Big League Stew

Dodgers turn first 2-5-6-3 triple play in history but Padres cry foul over umpire’s actions

Kevin Kaduk
Big League Stew

Before Sunday, it had been 130 years since anyone turned a similar type of bizarre triple play that the Los Angeles Dodgers turned against the San  Diego Padres in the ninth inning of a 5-4 win.

But with the logistics involved and the help from the home plate umpire that the Dodgers received, it'll probably take another 130 years for anyone to do it again.


For those keeping score at home, that's a 2-5-6-3 triple play that went around all four bases, the first 2-5-6-3 triple play that featured a putout at third, second and first. (A 2-5-6-3 triple play turned by the St. Louis Cardinals in 1950 started with a strikeout.)

Make sure to watch Full Count every night for more great highlights!

According to this list compiled by SABR, three instances of a 2-5-4-3 triple play — swapping out the shortstop for the second baseman — occurred in the 19th century. The last major-league 2-5-4-3 triple play occurred in a Sept. 13, 1882 game between the Cincinnati Red Stockings and Louisville Colonels.

With the relative bounty of 2-5-4-3 triple plays before the deadball era, one wonders if the ballplayers involved were still unclear on the rules of baseball. (As a nod to Old Hoss Radbourn, we'll also acknowledge it's possible they were just exceedingly drunk.)

View photo


Bud Black argues with umpire Dale Scott on Sunday. (AP)

Sunday's triple play, however, was the product of a weird set of circumstances that started when San Diego's Jesus Guzman squared around to bunt with runners on first and second.  Javy Guerra's pitch came high and inside, deflecting off Guzman's bat to an area in front of the plate. Guzman and the two baserunners stayed put as they thought the bunt was foul after home plate umpire Dale Scott threw his hands up in a dead ball motion, but catcher A.J. Ellis followed through on the play. He picked up the ball and started the 270 feet of throws as Scott then pointed that the ball was fair.

From MLB.com:

"I just wanted to play it out," said Ellis, whose Dodgers won on a walk-off single a few minutes later. "One thing we learn is you keep playing and don't assume anything. Just play, play, play until somebody stops you."

It was the Dodgers' first triple play of any kind since June 13, 1998, and its controversial nature led to Bud Black's ejection after the Padres manager argued the ruling.

"(Scott) was waving, not once, but twice," said (Chase) Headley, who was on first. "To me, that means it's a foul ball. What are we supposed to do? From my vantage point, we did what we [baserunners] were supposed to do. It's just a crazy thing."

The Padres certainly have a beef with the wishy-washy way that Scott handled the play — especially since the Dodgers won the game in the bottom of the inning — but for better or for worse the play will stand by itself in baseball history as one of a kind.

UPDATE: MLB senior vice president Peter Woodfork released the following statement on Monday afternoon after investigating the play (via Gaslamp Ball):

"After review and discussion with the umpire, we have determined that the call itself of a fair ball was correct. However, while making the call, there was an incorrect mechanic, which appeared to confuse San Diego's base runners. At no time did the umpire verbally kill the play on the field. After reviewing the entire situation following the game, the umpire realizes his hands were in an exaggerated upward appearance similar to a call that would indicate a dead ball. While we all agree that it was a fair ball that did not hit the batter, the umpire recognizes that the proper mechanic was not executed as he tried to avoid the catcher."

Want more baseball fun all season long?
Follow @bigleaguestew@KevinKaduk and the BLS Facebook page!

Other popular content on the Yahoo! network:
Greg Biffle's Sprint Cup win at Texas proves quick, and easy | Video: Biffle pulls away
Video: Bryan Bickell's OT goal completes wild rally, gives Chicago series split with Phoenix
Y! Autos: Researcher's physics paper gets him out of a ticket

View Comments (2467)
  • Diving great Greg Louganis says he appreciates fellow Olympian Jenner's journey

    Diving great Greg Louganis says he appreciates fellow Olympian Jenner's journey

    Greg Louganis said he was unaware of fellow Olympian Bruce Jenner's gender identity struggle when their paths crossed at the Summer 1976 Games and in later years. The diving great, among the first prominent athletes to come out as gay, said … More »

    The Canadian Press - 8 minutes ago
  • Beijing pitch to IOC for 2022 includes environmental improvements since 2008 Summer Olympics

    Beijing highlighted environmental improvements since he Summer Olympics in 2008 in its final presentation to the IOC before voting Friday to determine which city will be awarded the 2022 Winter Games. Beijing mayor Wang Anshun told the IOC … More »

    The Canadian Press - 9 minutes ago
  • Carrasco goes the distance in Indians' 3-1 victory

    Carrasco goes the distance in Indians' 3-1 victory

    Carlos Carrasco threw a two-hitter, Carlos Santana hit a two-run homer and the Cleveland Indians beat the Oakland Athletics 3-1 on Thursday night. Francisco Lindor had two hits for the Indians, who won their second straight following a six-game … More »

    AP - Sports - 11 minutes ago
  • Rizzo helps Cubs beat Brewers 5-2

    Rizzo helps Cubs beat Brewers 5-2

    Chicago was struggling before Anthony Rizzo got the Cubs back on track with one mighty swing in Milwaukee. Rizzo hit a three-run homer with two out in the eighth inning, and lifting the Cubs to a 5-2 victory over the Brewers on Thursday night. … More »

    AP - Sports - 12 minutes ago
  • Sabathia dehydrated after Yankees' 7-6 loss in Texas

    Sabathia dehydrated after Yankees' 7-6 loss in Texas

    CC Sabathia was taken to the hospital with symptoms of dehydration after the New York Yankees' 7-6 loss at Texas on Thursday night. Sabathia, moved up a day in the rotation to start after Michael Pineda was put on the disabled list earlier in the … More »

    AP - Sports - 17 minutes ago