What's Buzzing:

Big League Stew

Cole Hamels suspended five games for admitting he intentionally threw at Bryce Harper

Kevin Kaduk
Big League Stew

View photo


(Getty Images)

If there's anything that's more pointless and stupid than baseball pitchers throwing at batters to act "old school" or "make a point," it's the punishment that usually follows.

Mind you, I'm not suggesting that Philadelphia Phillies lefty Cole Hamels should have escaped reprimand after plunking Washington Nationals phenom Bryce Harper on Sunday night and then later admitting that he had done it on purpose.

No, Hamels definitely deserved to be disciplined after needlessly putting Harper's health at the mercy of a 92 mph fastball — an act that Washington GM Mike Rizzo later described as "gutless," "fake tough" and other words not suitable for this space.

[Related: Cole Hamels admits he intentionally plunked Bryce Harper]

The "pointless" and "stupid" I'm referring to is the way that Major League Baseball continues to "punish" starting pitchers with terms that don't recognize they play only once every five games. While a five-game suspension is exactly that for a position player or relief pitcher, it's merely an exercise in schedule manipulation when it involves a starting pitcher.

Take this Hamels case, for example. As Matt Gelb of the Philadelphia Inquirer notes, Thursday's off day for the Phillies  means that Hamels can immediately start serving his suspension without appealing it — a move that GM Ruben Amaro says will definitely occur — and the only consequence will be that his next start will come on Sunday instead of Saturday. Meanwhile, the person who could end up being punished the most would be staff ace Roy Halladay, who won't get the extra day of rest that Thursday's off day normally would have allowed.

I know some will respond that Hamels got his punishment when Harper stole home later in the inning or when Jordan Zimmermann hit Hamels later in the game, but how does any of this — including the fact that Zimmermann escaped completely unscathed — make sense to anyone else? While the collective bargaining agreement doesn't allow for the separate language, wouldn't it be more just for a pitcher to be punished in "starts" rather than games? Shouldn't a team have to go through nine starts without the punished pitcher for the sentence to hold any truth in advertising?

Make no mistake. When the punishment for hitting a batter really remains only one free base — which I still contend is a silly move that's a bit like undercutting a guy heading for a layup but then dunking the basketball for him anyway — pitchers are going to continue to engage in their own brand of dumb tough-guy justice. If you agree that this is wrong in the slightest bit, then you'll also agree that the punishment never fits the crime when it involves a starting pitcher being suspended for games he wasn't ever going to play in the first place.

Want more baseball all season long?
Follow @bigleaguestew@KevinKaduk and the BLS Facebook page!

Other popular content on the Yahoo! network:
Pat Forde: John Marinatto the latest example of a commissioner who didn't do enough
Washington Redskins don't take long to fall in love with RGIII
Marc J. Spears: Kobe Bryant's new Lakers teammates earn his trust
Y! Screen: Famous celeb smooches caught on camera

View Comments (1264)
  • Twins end Keuchel's 17-game run at home

    Twins end Keuchel's 17-game run at home

    The Minnesota Twins were the first team in over a year and a half to beat Dallas Keuchel in Houston, and they did it with patience. Brian Dozier broke out of a slump with three hits and the Twins snapped Keuchel's 17-game home winning streak with a … More »

    AP - Sports - 11 minutes ago
  • Thunder hold on beat Spurs 98-97, even series at 1-1

    Thunder hold on beat Spurs 98-97, even series at 1-1

    Russell Westbrook had 29 points and 10 assists, and the Oklahoma City Thunder held on to beat San Antonio 98-97 on Monday night, evening the series at one game apiece when the Spurs failed to score on a wild sequence in the final seconds. Kevin … More »

    AP - Sports - 24 minutes ago
  • Gonzalez sharp as Nats 5-hit Royals

    Gonzalez sharp as Nats 5-hit Royals

    In the meantime, the Nationals manager is content to rely on his pitching to win games. Ryan Zimmerman and Daniel Murphy drove in the only runs in the first inning. Gonzalez (2-1) went just six, but he scattered four hits and a pair of walks in … More »

    AP - Sports - 28 minutes ago
  • Wainwright has 1 of Cards' 5 HRs in win

    Wainwright has 1 of Cards' 5 HRs in win

    Adam Wainwright knew his mammoth home run changed the complexion of Monday night's game. ''Right now, it's all about wins for me,'' Wainwright said. Wainwright pitched six innings and hit a three-run home run - the first of five for St. Louis - as … More »

    AP - Sports - 36 minutes ago
  • Penguins top Capitals 3-2 to take 2-1 series lead

    Penguins top Capitals 3-2 to take 2-1 series lead

    Outhit, outshot and largely outplayed, Pittsburgh grabbed control of its Eastern Conference semifinal against Washington anyway. Matt Murray made 47 stops and the Penguins did just enough counterpunching to edge the Capitals 3-2 on Monday night for … More »

    AP - Sports - 37 minutes ago