What's Buzzing:

Buzzing The Net

World junior championship: Don Cherry chalks up Canada’s loss to Americans being in the CHL, even though collegians scored all 5 USA goals

Neate Sager
Buzzing The Net

View photo


Boston College's John Gaudreau has 7 goals in Team USA's last three games (The Canadian Press)

When it Canada loses a big hockey game to the United States like it did Thursday at the world junior championship, you just know there will be a faction of sore losers.

That's fine that people react poorly, because at least it shows they are . What is really baffling is trying to figure out when exactly it became a requirement to make some sweeping, blanket generalization to explain away Team Canada's result in the tournament. After Team USA throttled Canada 5-1 in the semifinal on Thursday, Twitter was full of bullflop that attempted to attribute the outcome to the Americans' abundance — more than one-third of their lineup, including the goalie! — of players who play in the Canadian Hockey League.

[Sunaya Sapurji's must-read: U.S. stuns Canada with emphatic semifinal victory]

Three guesses which iconic commentator wrapped himself in the flag and protectionism. The first two do not count.

Right, Grapes. Just like the main reason Canada's athlete of the year, Christine Sinclair, and her Olympic women's soccer teammates did so well is because they played in the NCAA.

The worst response is to take this seriously. To be fair to Cherry, at least this time he didn't imply American and European players should not be in the CHL like he did regarding Russia's Nail Yakupov a few weeks ago. That would cynically hypocritical coming from someone who promotes his brand by helping coach in the CHL Top Prospects Game, where his lineup later this month will include Team USA forward Ryan Hartman from the Plymouth Whalers, a U.S.-based OHL team.

The point is just to say, enough already. The improved depth of the world junior championship field, where hyped medal hopefuls can now end up in the relegation zone, makes it unpredictable. Canadians defensively pointing out the CHL presence on Team USA must have been the X factor makes no sense.

Beginning with John Gibson and continuing on through Seth Jones and his whole half-season with the Portland Winterhawks, Team USA's major junior guys have been very good for coach Phil Housley. Please keep in mind that Jones, Hartman and Toronto Maple Leafs power-winger prospect Tyler Biggs only came to the CHL this season, so 'major junior guy' is a misnomer.

[Puck Daddy: Here's the most adorable moment
of the U.S.'s world junior win over Canada

In all, though, nine Team USA players have major junior background. The 2012 iteration that finished an embarrassing seventh had seven. That two-player swing was not a difference maker. Gibson, who chose the Kitchener Rangers over the University of Michigan, was outstanding in goal. However, their best attackers were John Gaudreau and Jake McCabe, respectively from the Boston College Eagles and the Wisconsin Badgers. Each scored two goals; another collegian, Jimmy Vesey from Harvard, added a single.

(As an aside: anyone who repeated the "McCabe has only two goals this season for Wisconsin but had two today" should watch this and then say he cannot be an active offensive defenceman.)

It's never one thing. Credit goes where credit is due, to several sources. There is no one way to get to the NHL. Claiming otherwise comes off as being a poor sport.

Gaudreau is an exemplar of the USHL-to-NCAA development path. His small physical stature contributed to him being available for the Calgary Flames to take in the fourth round of the 2011 draft. However, he produced big-time numbers by the standards of a 17-year-old in the USHL (72 points in 60 games) and has continued to do so through a season-and-a-half on Chestnut Hill.

Canada's entire lineup hails from major junior. But who cares? That tells you nothing about them.

There might be some broader argument that Canadians who take this tack are showing disrespect how much the U.S. sports industry does for countless Canuck athletes in other sports. (Wait, there are other sports?) The University of Portland can't take the lioness' share of the credit for alumna Christine Sinclair's success, but it helped the 29-year-old advance during her teens and early 20s. The same goes for all the basketball players from Cherry's corner of the world, Southern Ontario, who are elevating the country's hoops reputation — the Cleveland Cavaliers' Tristan Thompson, Orlando Magic rookie Andrew Nicholson, UNLV's Anthony Bennett, Michigan State's Nik Stauskas and high school phenom Andrew Wiggins. You want to be defensive about Americans and Europeans thriving in the CHL, then credit the NCAA for helping Canadians in a way this country either cannot or will not do itself.

By the way, Sweden is in the gold-medal game, presumably all because two of forwards, Rickard Rakell and Victor Rask, respectively skate for the OHL's Plymouth Whalers and WHL's Calgary Hitmen. Hopefully that sarcasm was not too oblique. The point here is there's no need to stretch for the broad, all-encompassing argument after your country's team totally geeks it in a big game. It's just a bunch of stuff that happened.

Neate Sager is a writer for Yahoo! Canada Sports. Follow him on Twitter @neatebuzzthenet. Please address any questions, comments or concerns to btnblog@yahoo.ca (video: TSN).

View Comments (627)
  • Delaying Rio Games would give "false security" on Zika - WHO panel head

    Delaying Rio Games would give "false security" on Zika - WHO panel head

    By Stephanie Nebehay GENEVA (Reuters) - Postponing the Rio Olympics due to fears that the event could speed the spread of the Zika virus would give a "false" sense of security because travellers are constantly going in and out of Brazil, the chair … More »

    Reuters - 8 minutes ago
  • South Africa name hooker Strauss as captain

    South Africa name hooker Strauss as captain

    South Africa named hooker Adriaan Strauss as captain on Monday for next month's three-test home series against Ireland. New coach Allister Coetzee, who named a new-look squad on Saturday, praised the 30-year-old's skills two days later. "Adriaan's … More »

    Reuters - 9 minutes ago
  • New FIFA official Fatma Samoura arrives in Zurich

    ZURICH (AP) -- FIFA's new top administrator, United Nations official Fatma Samoura, has met staff in Zurich for the first time and will start work on June 20. … More »

    AP - Sports - 9 minutes ago
  • Factbox - List of players who have scored 10,000 test runs

    (Reuters) - List of players who have scored 10,000 runs in test matches after England's Alastair Cook achieved the feat on Monday: Sachin Tendulkar (India) 15,921 Ricky Ponting (Australia) 13,378 Jacques Kallis (South Africa) 13,289 Rahul Dravid … More »

    Reuters - 12 minutes ago
  • Factbox - England captain Alastair Cook

    Factbox - England captain Alastair Cook

    Factbox on England captain Alastair Cook, who became the first English batsman to score 10,000 runs in test matches in the second test against Sri Lanka on Monday. *Scored an unbeaten 104 on test debut against India at Nagpur in 2006, and made his … More »

    Reuters - 12 minutes ago